3 ms·
> Although at Yale University, we actually bring in incomes around $30,000 per year, we’d be taxed like people who make $70,000. The hole this would blow in the
by gnicholas 9y ago
> Although at Yale University, we actually bring in incomes around $30,000 per year, we’d be taxed like people who make $70,000. The hole this would blow in the individual finances of graduate students would make advanced research impossible for many. I could wind up with $11,014 — more than a third of my actual take-home pay — going to taxes. This would mean I’d owe four times my current tax bill.
I'm surprised that someone making 30k would pay any income taxes, TBH. I'm not sure where the $11k number comes from, but I'd be curious to see how it would be that high with the larger standard deduction that the tax bill proposes. Not saying it's wrong; just saying there's no support provided and it seems a bit high. Note: I am a (former) tax lawyer.
- samfriedman 9y agoMany of my grad student friends simply don't file.
- jjoonathan 9y agoThey "make" 70k but only actually see 30k. They used to be taxed on the 30k, which amounted to little or nothing, but the proposal will tax them on the 70k. Paying the difference between tax on 30k and tax on 70k out of 30k minus living expenses is painful.
- gnicholas 9y agoYeah, but where does the $11k calculation come from? Did she run it through tax software from 2016, which doesn't include the larger standard deduction? This change would dramatically reduce the taxes owed by many people who do not itemize. The author admits she isn't a tax lawyer, so I'm curious to know how she arrived at such a detailed figure. Did she use a "how would the GOP tax bill affect your taxes" calculator from some website? She didn't just pull the number out of thin air, and its odd she doesn't say where it came from.
- mattkrause 9y agoI just sketched it out above and 11k seems about right.
- theptip 9y agoIf I lob $70k into the first income tax calculator that Google gives (https://smartasset.com/taxes/california-tax-calculator#ueiFyiZr57 https://smartasset.com/taxes/california-tax-calculator#ueiFy...) I get a $19k tax bill, which gives $30-19 = $11k after tax. There might be a deduction for the tuition fee cost that we're missing, but that sounds like where the number came from.
- gnicholas 9y agoThe point is that there are no accurate tax calculators for the new tax bill. The calculator you referenced is for current law. There are of course many difference to account for, but the single largest effect (other than the treatment of imputed tuition payment) is that the standard deduction doubles from $6k to 12k. This will make a big impact, and it's why we can't just rely on tax calculators for the old law when estimating our new taxes. Please reconsider your downvotes — I'm not making arguments in bad faith here. I am truly trying to understand where these numbers came from. If she did use one of these tax calculators, then she made a silly/simple mistake, which frankly the WaPo should have double-checked.
- mattkrause 9y agoI worked it out here[https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15625353 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15625353] for the current tax regime. Yale's tuition is actually a bit more than $40k; they quote $47600 for this year. I believe the GOP plan replaces the current standard deduction ($6350) and personal exemption ($4050) with a $12,000 standard deduction, but the first $90k are taxed at 12%, instead of including 10% and 15% brackets. So...12% of ($30,000 stipend + 47,600 tuition - 12,000 deduction) is $7872. Connecticut (where Yale is) also has an income tax that's 3% of the first $10,000; 5% of the next $40,000, and 5.5% of the amount between 50k and 100k. Assuming tuition is also subject to state tax, it works out to 10000 * 0.03 + 400000.05 + 27600 0.055 = $3,818. That works out to a total of $11,690 from take-home pay of $30,000. Ouch.
- gnicholas 9y agoThanks for taking the time to do the math. It would be interesting to see if various states put "adjustments" in place to back out the tuition from income, for state law purposes. In the event that this goes through at the federal level, I would imagine several states (CA, NY, MA) would do this in a heartbeat.