3 ms·
> "Then I remembered that nutrition in America is a total disaster, that ⅔ of the country is obese or overweight, and that half of the country either has diabet
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
> "Then I remembered that nutrition in America is a total disaster, that ⅔ of the country is obese or overweight, and that half of the country either has diabetes or is at high risk of having diabetes soon. If we start providing education like we provide nutrition, then God help the little children…"
The irony here is (pardon the hyperbole) literally deadly.
If we're going to prevent obesity then more people need to be educated on the causes. In many (read: all) of the non-medical condition based cases, the individual is their own best enemy. There is nothing more choice based than what you put in your mouth.
No doubt, there's room for improvement in the food system. But I've seen people with choices consistently choose badly. To blame the system is blaming a symptom.
- mattmanser 9y agoThis is discussed extensively in the article, and is in fact the main argument of the article. The thrust of his argument is that capitalism forces companies to play to biological triggers that are bad for us, and to play them hard. And then use psychological tricks to make you feel ok for falling for them, even though you logically know you shouldn't. If they don't their competitors will. So the system is deliberately exerting pressure to become obese, it's not a symptom, it's a direct cause. He even uses examples of how Brazil and other countries have been targeted deliberately by companies selling sugar and salt and have suddenly developed obesity problems, after US companies ran around giving away desserts and other sugar laden food. I would re-read the article and pay attention to the parts about Coke, Raisin Bran and Minute Maid juice, plus him discussing Brazil, if you missed the arguments.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoYes. I got all that. I see it everyday. My point is that when we've reached a point where it's acceptable to blame anything but ourselves for what we buy at the supermarket...for what we put in our mouths...then we are in very bad shape. Fixing the system isn't going to fix The Problem. The lack of self responsibility will only manifest itself elsewhere. Put another way, in the bigger scheme of things, we can't keep complaining about the power of the overseers (i.e., the 1% et al) and make every solution one that champions the Nanny State.
- mrguyorama 9y agoAt a certain point I think it's reasonable to say that a company spending half a billion dollars on psychology research and manipulation (advertising) MIGHT just have the upper hand.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoPardon my non-HN tone but...does that reasonable point come before or after I look down and can't see my own penis when I pee? How isn't that a trigger for "something is wrong"? Yes, there is a well-armed enemy. But most people I've come in contact with are in denial that enemy exists. You can't stop a problem if you're unwilling to admit it exists. You can't improve your health if you're more committed to the idea that you have a God-given right to a sugar frosted donut. Is it unreasonable to expect people to look in the mirror, literally? I'm not suggesting it's easy, but why is trying a bad thing? Furthermore, and not to get too off-topic, but aside from too many sugars/carbs the average American diet includes too much factory farmed animals - whether that's milk or meat. Those animals are VERY resource intensive. Those animals also produce green horse gases (i.e, they fart, a lot). So when was the last time you heard ANYONE of significant leadership say "America! You need to change your diet - for your own good, as well as the good of the planet"? Sure Obama got us ACA but he never met the much bigger (no pun intended) - less politically beneficial - root problem head on. That's. Not. Leadership. Is it?
- mattmanser 9y agoWe're not talking about sugar coated donuts are we? We're talking about a supposedly innocuous looking water that turns out it's sugar laden and a healthy looking breakfast cereal that again has huge amounts of added sugar. While in the us/UK/etc. there is now widespread knowledge that coke and sweets are bad for you, the healthy looking alternatives also have tons of sugar added, deliberately, with manipulative packaging. But in poorer countries they're just using the old cheaper tactics, showing deliberate malice even though they know their product is generally damaging. In my supermarket in the UK if you want to buy sugar free yoghurt you have to inspect the fine print. A large number have sugar as their second biggest ingredient. They're out to trick you all the time, with things that look like they have no sugar in them. Not sure how your Obama beef is relevant.
- desertrider12 9y agoIf you want to blame private grocery stores for obesity (and I don’t think you can), it’s only because they don’t exist in poor areas and they’re too hard to get to. If the government wants to attack the problem, public transport is the solution, not “free” restaurants. Public transport is an example of something governments are good at.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoAgreed. No doubt food deserts are a real issue and they need to be addressed. But why is that holding up everything else. Btw, have you ever seen this TED Talk? (Note: I'm not a TED fan but this Ron Finley is a genius.) https://www.ted.com/talks/ron_finley_a_guerilla_gardener_in_south_central_la https://www.ted.com/talks/ron_finley_a_guerilla_gardener_in_... As I was saying, what about all the people NOT suffering from such a situation? What's their excuse? Funny how the poor get blamed for making bad choice, but non-poor (white) people get to blame the system or anything but themselves (for their obvious bad choices.) Unless we lock down every last cookie, sugar cereal, etc. the availability of better nutrition - which the majority have access to already - ain't gonna work. It was the system that go us here. It's time to try solving the real root problem. That is, too many people are willing to poison themselves on the regular. (Rant over.)