8 ms·
I see a lot of comments here wondering why Apple seems to not care about software quality anymore. I don’t know if that’s true, but there’s a perfectly obvious
by teddyh 9y ago
I see a lot of comments here wondering why Apple seems to not care about software quality anymore. I don’t know if that’s true, but there’s a perfectly obvious answer: They don’t have to.
Software quality in macOS was important back when they were trying to get people to switch from Windows-based PCs to Macs. Nowadays, most people who were going to switch have already switched, so Apple has no incentive to keep up the same level of software quality anymore. They just have to keep people locked into their ecosystem (with iPhone etc.) enough that the barrier to switch out again is high enough.
There is no reason for Apple to improve macOS, since doing so won’t make anyone switch to Macs who hasn’t already switched, and not improving macOS won’t make anyone upset enough to switch back. Ergo, Apple leaves macOS to stagnate, and they will keep macOS at this bad-but-not-horrible-enough-to-switch level for the foreseeable future.
That’s my theory, anyway.
- skygazer 9y agoWhile your theory is interesting, if deeply cynical, the thing I find most interesting is that it's the top comment on an 800+ comment discussion when it was less than a minute old. Do new comments start at the top? I've never noticed that before. Edit: By the way, regarding the vulnerability, ANY password you use when you first attempt to login as root BECOMES root's new password. (Blank is a red herring.) So if you're going to test this, maybe use something non-obvious. In a terminal, setting a strong password for root with "sudo passwd" is the quickest mitigation. Ill-advised, but in a pinch, you can apparently 'secure' a machine you don't otherwise have access to by attempting to log in as root with a long random password you fail to remember. An admin on that machine can later change root's password with a "sudo passwd". Also, it appears the "dseneableroot -d" command suggested elsewhere here fails in preventing root login.
- JonCox 9y agoI think new comments do get a slight boost initially. But I also think people are venting their frustrations at the very noticeable decline in software quality from Apple over the last 3 years.
- manmal 9y agoThe higher the poster's karma, the higher her comment will be upon posting. This user has almost 6k karma, so it can rise high. Once the comment is at the top for a minute or so, it can stay there if enough people keep upvoting it. Try it and post a top level comment now. I'm pretty sure it won't be at the top initially because you don't have enough karma for that.
- dep_b 9y agoAh thanks, now it makes sense. I always wondered why sometimes my comments went straight to the top. I've lost too much productivity here, clearly! ;)
- manmal 9y agoYeah I only know because I‘ve watched my posts gain better positions when I hit 1k karma (iirc).
- Dangeranger 9y agoI have also seen new comments spring to the top of the conversation, but always assumed they were selected randomly, as some of them were from posters who were fairly new or had a low karma count.
- manmal 9y agoI guess this happens if the other posters are of low karma, or if the other comments are quite old.
- thinkloop 9y agoYes new comments get a bit of time near the top. The amount of time varies based on the amount and quality of other comments.
- ryanmclovin 9y agoSurely they havent used up the pool of people that might/want switch to macOS. How can anyone make even such statement?
- teddyh 9y agoSome years ago, I was hearing about people switching from PCs to Macs all the time. Later, not so much, but macOS was still getting praise. Maybe Apple looked at the conversion numbers at that time and decided that the cost of keeping up the quality of macOS wasn’t worth the few PC converts they were still getting, and they figured that not enough people would switch back to PCs since the iOS system lock-in effects, etc. would present enough of a barrier. So it’s not that there aren’t still people who could conceivably switch to Macs, it’s that Apple decided they didn’t need more converts quite as badly anymore. Still, only my theory of course.
- kakarot 9y agoThis goes against basically every corporate strategy ever, which is to always increase growth. At this state in the company's life there is a disconnect between those who make the software and those who make the business decisions. I don't think it's likely that Apple's board just decided to give up attracting new customers, and any apparent decline in quality is likely attributed to bad management; ineptitude, rather than purpose. Occam's Razor supports this hypothesis.
- teddyh 9y agoIncrease growth, yes, but not at any cost. My point is that Apple may have decided that at this time they don’t need the growth as much as they need internal developers to work on other things than macOS.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoOld school corps - DEC, HP, even IBM to an extent - weren't about increasing growth irrespective of consequences. The DEC Employee Handbook made a big deal out of Doing the Right Thing. Obviously that was subjective, frequently debatable, and sometimes just a pain in the ass - but it was a guiding principle for engineers of that generation, and for engineers who became managers. And it produced some outstanding engineering and innovation. Because it actually means "Do the best work you can, for your own self-respect, and also because you respect your users." That's light years away from "Screw as much money out of your customers as you can, as many overtime hours out of your developers as you can, and if the product is broken - who cares if the money keeps coming in?"
- zelos 9y agoI really hope that's not true and this is just some extended blip. That said, between this, the disk encryption bug, not being able to type "I" on an iphone you have to wonder what is going on. I recently upgrade my MacBook Pro to High Sierra and it's been plagued with problems (Weird red flash when displaying menus, hangs/crashes with external monitors etc.) Then I look at switching away, and I lose all the OSX software I own, all the easy iOS integration, all those Pages documents etc. Maybe I just need to build a cheap but upgradable Linux box and start trying to switch.
- rcarmo 9y agoI've been actively investigating that for over a year: https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2016/10/29/2240 https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2016/10/29/2240 I have to use Windows for work, though (I'm at a Microsoft subsidiary, and all we get are Windows machines), and I can live OK inside WSL.
- klmr 9y ago> not improving macOS won’t make anyone upset enough to switch back I’m not so sure about this — although it may be due more to the hardware side of their business: after the recent, disappointing iteration of their MacBook Pros I’ve heard a lot of people considering to switch (and actually switching). Taken together with software quality issues, I wouldn’t be surprised if at least a subgroup of users are leaving Apple gradually. That subgroup being professional users, of course: Apple is still unassailed as a status symbol, and casual (+ mobile) users seem more than happy.
- teddyh 9y agoNobody cares about what developers like in their computers, developers will go wherever the users are. And Apple now has a sizable chunk of computer users and an even larger chunk of smartphone users.
- bipson 9y agoThis only holds true if you consider lock-in IMO, e.g. you need a mac to develop iOS or mac apps, or you need a windows machine to develop windows apps. Otherwise I don't care which browser you are using to look at my pages, or which Desktop to run my qt app. There was a massive influx of developers switchting to mac laptops before it was popular with a majority of users (around 2008).
- m_fayer 9y agoThere's a big difference between a developer grudgingly keeping a cheap headless mini-computer under a stack of papers somewhere that gets used only as needed, and a developer using your system as their "home base" and buying into your entire ecosystem.
- teddyh 9y agoThat’s not a big difference for Apple. They’ve got their user base now, they don’t need developers to spread the word anymore.
- martijn_himself 9y agoI really don't think that to be the case. Quality on OS X was a priority in its own right and fundamental to everything at Apple, not just a by-product of a strategy to get people to move from Windows. Of course all that changed when its only priority became to shift more iPhones, and everything became secondary to that.
- e_proxus 9y agoWhile I think there's a chance you might be right, I don't think it's logical in the long run. I think changes in perception like this are accumulated over time and will in the end hurt the product. For some examples, look at the impression of Microsoft and Windows when it comes to quality. It is only now starting to improve, with gigantic efforts from Microsofts side. Another example is Linux and usability, which have constantly gotten better (maybe still not good enough, but that's better left for another thread) but still many see Linux as "advanced" and only for power users. These are not perfect examples, of course. What I mean is that I think it's bad strategy on Apple's part (if they're doing this deliberately), especially considering the resources they have at their hands. I wouldn't be surprised if Apple could increase it's desktop market share further by positioning themselves as high quality. However, it's a reputation they are losing fast.
- wlesieutre 9y ago>It is only now starting to improve, with gigantic efforts from Microsofts side. Is it? They axed their internal QA and definitely aren't catching all the bugs with the "Insiders Program." After the Fall Creator's Update I've had to log in twice (after the first one I just get sent back to the login screen). The workaround is disabling a setting: "Use my sign-in info to automatically finish setting up my device after an update or restart." I'm also getting repeated alerts that a restart is required to complete installing an audio driver, but restarting doesn't finish it. I probably need to track down the responsible driver, uninstall it, and reinstall manually or hope Windows does it. Obviously that's not as serious an issue as unauthenticated root access, but in day-to-day use of my Windows computer I don't have a very positive impression of their software quality.
- e_proxus 9y agoMaybe not quality wise in all areas (I agree with you there) but at least in giving a professional and modern impression compared to let's say Windows XP/7. Maybe operating systems are declining in quality in general, even though organizations sometimes try to improve them. I guess legacy plays a big role here.
- angrygoat 9y agoThese days, where is the lock-in? The core applications that I use (Firefox, Docker, VSCode, vim, ...) all work just as well on Linux, MacOS and Windows. I have a Mac, because it's (at least previously) been pretty secure by default, doesn't require me to invest a lot of time sysadmining my own box, and lets me dip into a healthy ecosystem of commercial software useful to my hobbies (like photography.) The software has definitely declined in quality, but not enough to massively annoy me. If there is lock-in, it's on the hardware side. I've got an early 2013 MBP, still going strong, a bit dented but it's been around the world with me a few times, so that's understandable. My workplace uses Dell XPS hardware, and that's good, but it still doesn't feel as solid to me. It's good, but it's not as good. I think the hardware is the laurel Apple has really been resting on. I could meet my main use cases on Linux quite happily, and dual-boot Windows for the rest. Right now the premium on Mac hardware, which only happily runs an increasingly decrepit operating system, isn't looking worth it. Previously, it was.
- scjr 9y agoWhile you don't believe you are locked in, I don't believe that you as a programmer "power user" are the majority that Apple cares about. I believe not only that for the majority of users there is a level of software lock-in, but further there is a high level of psychological lock-in, where users get used to and comfortable with Apple's design strength, which is Apple's main offering. As people get more comfortable and more older it is easy to say that people get more resistant to change.
- zelos 9y agoThe lock in is definitely less, but for me: - Large iPhoto library - Easy syncing with multiple iPhones (notes, photos etc) - Xcode for iOS development
- schuke 9y agoI second this. The only feature that I can immediately think of that locks me in the mac eco-system is the convenience of airdropping files with my wife. Apart from this, with most of my stuff on the cloud, there won't even be a migration process if I decide to switch to Windows.
- 9y ago
- elysian_eunoia 9y agoWhether or not most potential apple users have already switched, security is surely vital to keeping their customers with them. Much like the importance of feeling safe in our own house, if the computer that houses our information suddenly makes us feel unsafe or exposed, we'll naturally seek other options unless the issue is, shall I say, swiftly fixed or easily fixable.
- fergie 9y agoThere are probably a lot of people like me on HN who _need_ a unix box to do their work, and the various Macs are still far and away the best general purpose unix boxes available (best chassis, best peripheral compatibility, best (o|O)ffice software compatibility). Now that Google Docs and Office 365 are "good enough" for most things, I would probably be happy to go back to Linux if there was a Linux machine that had comparable build quality yet was a bit cheaper than a Mac.
- paprikka 9y agoCan't agree more. The main thing that keeps me using OSX is Adobe Creative Cloud. I'd mention aesthetics, but the current Linux distros look quite good, plus they're customisable.
- acidburnNSA 9y agoDell XPS 15 on Linux is pretty glorious you guys. My 2011 version is still kicking amazingly well with a 1TB SSD, and the newer models are way sleek. I also have a 2013 Sony vaio with dual boot linix/windows. Haven't booted to windows for anything but updating it for years.
- juanmirocks 9y agoSurely they should care about the security of their _own_ developers, who surely program in macOS. I believe we are being too harsh on Apple unnecessarily.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoI think it's more that desktop machines make them a fraction of the money that their iOS devices do. Development goes towards the profit centre. Remember that back when Apple made only computers, right before the iPod, they were on the verge of bankruptcy and barely profitable. Since then their laptops have taken off, of course, and I have no idea how much money they make off them. But compared to the huge torrent of cash Apple makes off iPhones I can't imagine the beancounters see a huge amount of value in investing heavily in the parts of OS X that aren't shared with iOS.
- nathanvanfleet 9y agoI kind of love how you frame it as "everyone who has switched has switched" as if the job is done. As if there would be no market to capture. Which isn't true. And doesn't even consider the reality that there are young computer buyers who they need to capture because existing users don't buy new machines or won't last in the long run (people die).
- teddyh 9y agoThere is always more market to capture, but the cost of capturing those few additional users might not be worth it (to Apple, currently). And new users don’t look to the quality of the OS to pick their platforms, they look to existing user bases. And Apple now has a sizable existing user base, especially if you also count iPhones.
- Humdeee 9y agoI was going to comment the same thing. Most people are always open to switching if the evidence is there to support a better workflow or experience. The realm of endless marketing to all the demographics will never stop.
- reubenswartz 9y agoNot to excuse the bug, but I think it has more to do with the annual upgrade cycle for the iPhone. Everything else Apple does has to tie into this, which is a pretty tight cycle for an OS with new "regular" OS features, plus the integrations with iOS. They can't afford to wait 2 years (or whatever) to update the phones, and Mac OS gets pulled along for the ride.
- frik 9y agoIt reminds me of the Windows 95/98 login. At the logon screen, just pressing ESC got you to the desktop. Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAH2j9mRgUM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAH2j9mRgUM
- recursive 9y agoIt's kind of similar, but that was intentional. There was even a "Cancel" button in the GUI that did the same thing.
- toadkicker 9y agoTheir QA department has been in a downward spiral since 2014. I would love to name some people who were doing a fantastic job running the place until then, but I'll spare the embarrassment. This really isn't about some mega company not caring as much as one of their cornerstone departments being unable to function effectively.
- teekert 9y agoI do see people switching to Linux for this reason, Apple the new MS, Ubuntu the new Apple?
- draw_down 9y agoWhat? Of course they have to care.
- yoz-y 9y agoMaybe. But this particular bug happened precisely because Apple has changed _something_ in macOS. Also this something was probably quite profound since it has impacted a part of software that, at least from the outside, haven't changed much since a long time. A lot of macOS users would actually prefer Apple to do less with it than what they are currently doing.
- hellofunk 9y ago> this particular bug happened precisely because Apple has changed _something_ in macOS I don't know much about this bug but I have seen several reports that the bug has actually existed quite some time and is not new, only the publicity surrounding it is now shining a bright light on it.
- yoz-y 9y agoI thought it was confirmed that it is new to High Sierra, it was indeed lingering on forums as a "administrator hint" though.
- hellofunk 9y agoI think you are right, but it's still been in the wild for several months, despite that Apple just realized a comment claiming they discovered the problem yesterday.
- hellofunk 9y ago> There is no reason for Apple to improve macOS, since doing so won’t make anyone switch to Macs who hasn’t already switched, and not improving macOS won’t make anyone upset enough to switch back. I wouldn't be so sure about that. There are a lot of "about to switch" people out there, in both directions, who are just waiting for either the extra nudge or the extra reason to not switch.
- _sdegutis 9y agoBut customer retention is still important. I've heard of a lot of people switching away from Macs to Linux and Windows, especially with Windows building up their own official Linux subsystem now. PC hardware is cheaper than Apple's, and hardware (even the "good stuff") becomes obsolete after 5 years anyway. Besides, most software is cross platform these days. The only real good retention plan Apple has is that we can't release iOS apps without owning Apple hardware; there's a few Mac-specific software titles that certain professionals rely on; and a little bit of "it's overall higher quality than PCs" mindshare that some people still have either from the 80s and early 2000s, but that can't last long if Apple keeps this up.
- pwdisswordfish2 9y agoUnder your theory, given a comparison between "not modern" and "modern", software and hardware that is not modern may be higher quality. Should users always choose "modern" over "mot modern"? Or does this choice require actually knowing all the changes from one version to the next? Do macOS users diff the Darwin source trees against each other to follow changes? Would that have revealed a "bug" like this one? Would having macOS fully open source enable users to spot "bugs" like this one? Should users that care about things like UNIX "security" switch to a fully open source UNIX-like OS instead of a corporate-controlled one?
- jsight 9y agoSaying that you only care about existing users via lockin and don't expect switchers is a sure path to doom in the long run. Surely that cannot really be it. Incompetence seems to be a more likely fit here than that.
- SZJX 9y agoNah. At this rate people will simply abandon the ship sooner or later. There's definitely some deterioration going on instead of only a cynical strategy shift. The new MBP isn't attractive anymore. The software stagnates. The only reason I keep using Mac for usual use cases is just its wonderful collection of dictionaries (I like to constantly learn new languages). I wonder why no publisher ever bothered coming up with a decent dictionary software on Windows/Linux yet instead of making do with crappy online versions. If they did I'd happily just use a Windows + Linux dual boot machine.