3 ms·
I'm glad you did post it - your comment made me think about it more carefully. In math circles my originally reply would have been considered overly verbose, a
by ColinWright 9y ago
I'm glad you did post it - your comment made me think about it more carefully. In math circles my originally reply would have been considered overly verbose, and when I'm talking about math I tend to drop into that style of communication. I needed to kick to get me out of it and explain in more detail.
But this is a standard problem when teaching proof in math. All too often a proposed "proof" simply doesn't prove the theorem, and if the theorem is actually true it can be extremely difficult to explain why the "proof" is wrong, inadequate, or incomplete. The most common form is "Well, I can't see how anything could go wrong." and that's notoriously hard to get around.
But I'm pleased you posted, and I'm pleased you enjoyed the post. Thank you.