3 ms·
There is nothing to support bitcoin That's what I've been realizing latey: there is something to support Bitcoin, and that something is the blockchain. The rea
by nerdponx 9y ago
There is nothing to support bitcoin
That's what I've been realizing latey: there is something to support Bitcoin, and that something is the blockchain. The reason banks and big financial companies are interested in it is not for its speculative value. They are interested in the fact that it is both decentralized and immutable. As long as financial corporations are willing to exchange Bitcoin for USD, then Bitcoin is a reasonable store of value.
There's also value in Bitcoin because it's a good entry point into other cryptocurrencies that could turn out to be better general-purpose exchange media, like Litecoin.
It's a bit like US Treasury Bonds. Nobody buys them for the tiny rate of return they offer, but they have genuine, valid use as a financial instrument. Normal people, however don't typically buy them, and normal people probably shouldn't be buying Bitcoin either unless they have some spare cash to gamble on it.
- jorblumesea 9y agoUS Treasury bonds are backed by the military and economic might of a superpower, and the fact that it's an IOU that's almost bulletproof. That's a really big part of their value. It's the safest investment possible which is why governments funnel money into treasuries. Bitcoin just has the power of faith in the network and that liquidity will exist when you want to cash out. Neither of which is certain. Bitcoin really doesn't have any support. Exchanges don't have close to the liquidity needed to allow everyone to withdraw their coins in fiat currency.
- thucydides 9y agoI've heard many people say this, and it seemed sensible enough at first. But on further thought, I sincerely can't make sense of it. Dollars are just green pieces of paper. We accept them for goods and services because... everyone ELSE agrees to accept them for goods and services. It's circular. How is the might of the US military relevant here? If you lived in South Korea, would you accept the South Korean won, or would you refuse your salary because their military is too weak compared to the United States? I would take my salary in South Korean won because all of my neighbors and strangers will take it in exchange for goods and services. Circular. The circular argument that cryptocurrency has value has turned into a self-reinforcing cascade. Ironically, because of network effects, the more users and speculators there are in Bitcoin, the more utility it actually has, because others will accept it as money. This - and the human tendency toward envious imitative buying - causes the price to rise even further. Cryptocurrencies are easier to secure and transfer than gold, which we only think has "value" because it's shiny and rare. Yet gold is worth $8 trillion. Why not crypto? (caveat: Bitcoin could fall precipitously in the short, medium, or long term. My argument is that cryptocurrency - Bitcoin, Ethereum, or something else - will be more valuable than gold in 10 years or so.)
- monktastic1 9y ago> How is the might of the US military relevant here? If I understand correctly, it's because nobody's going to come and steal our resources. Of course, given the relative peace in the world, probably nobody is going to steal South Korea's either....
- kelnos 9y agoThe enduring "value" of the US dollar -- for people who live/work in the US, anyway -- is more that it's the only currency you can pay your US taxes in. Its legitimacy as a currency for everything else stems from that.
- tooltalk 9y ago> ... everyone ELSE agrees to accept them for goods and services. It's circular. If you think about it, there is nothing circular about US dollar's supremacy. If you reside in the US, you are bound by the Legal Tender law -- meaning, by law, you have to accept US dollars as a valid payment for meeting financial obligation. The US dollar is also the defacto reserve currency of the world. All important commodities, for instance oil, are priced and traded in USD -- though there have been a number of bilateral agreements between oil-producing nations and consuming nations (eg, Iran-Turkey, Russia) to breakout of this, the USD still rules the day. If you want to understand how the US dollar became the reserve currency of the world, you do necessarily have to understand the WW2 (ie, military conflict), the Brettonwood agreement that came after the war, the collapse of the agreement in the 70's, and what US has been doing militarily and diplomatically to maintain their dollar hegemony since, but, in short, it isn't just about some arbitrary blind trust in the US dollar by the world (or circular reasoning) that we ended up with the system that we now have. > How is the might of the US military relevant here? If you lived in South Korea, would you accept the South Korean won, or would you refuse your salary because their military is too weak compared to the United States? I would take my salary in South Korean won because all of my neighbors and strangers will take it in exchange for goods and services. Circular. IMO, this is a terrible example to demonstrate your point. In case of national security threat or economic crisis, it's not uncommon to see smart monies fleeing to gold or other safer currency (eg, Swiss Franc, Japanese Yen, or USD). South Koreans are less likely to hold their own currency if the US decides to withdraw all 30K US troops and break any agreements in place to militarily assist the South in case of military conflict.
- TheDong 9y ago> They are interested in the fact that it is both decentralized and immutable So like https://ipfs.io/ https://ipfs.io/ or various other append-only logs? Or the certificate transparency project? The blockchain is the least efficient way to create a distributed append-only log if there are a fixed number of trusted actors publishing to it. Banks can far more easily publish append-only logs of transactions without the extra noise of "mining" and comparing longest chains based on proof-of-work.
- dsacco 9y ago> The reason banks and big financial companies are interested in it is not for its speculative value. They are interested in the fact that it is both decentralized and immutable. None of the blockchain projects or proposals being worked on by enterprise financial institutions are decentralized. A decentralized ledger is conceptually antithetical to a small group of organizations which trust each other and want to retain control over the shared ledger. It can be immutable, but for that matter I don't really think it's immutable in the same sense as a decentralized, permissionless ledger is. The organizations in charge of the blockchain can create a hard fork, which everyone participating with the organizations will have to abide by, because the blockchain is not decentralized. In fact, what we actually have is a consortium of companies deploying distributed database structures and calling them blockchains. I'm sure there is a legitimately new innovation that can emerge from this sort of blockchain, but it won't be decentralization or immutability.
- chiaro 9y agoNah. Banks and big financial companies interested in the blockchain will spin up their own version without tying it to the unstable mess of bitcoin. e.g. https://ripple.com/ https://ripple.com/ And people do by treasury bonds for their rate of return, when the investment must be as riskless as possible.
- AndrewBissell 9y agoThere's no point to a decentralized database like a blockchain when you run it from a handful of centralized chokepoints which are easily censored or pressured by political actors. You may as well just use a SQL database that everyone syncs up periodically. Bankcoins like Ripple are pointless. People buy treasury bills when they care more about return OF capital than return ON capital. Bitcoin and gold are also solid assets in this regard, particularly because they are bearer assets that don't represent a liability or promise-to-pay by some third party.
- chiaro 9y agoAnd yet, banks and financial institutions are vastly preferring blockchains that have been uniquely developed for their needs. There's very little appeal in simply accepting the transaction costs and times in bitcoin when you can spin up a version with whatever spec and interoperability you desire. If by 'return of capital' you mean a propensity for an asset to retain its value, bitcoin is utterly inappropriate. Even gold is far too volatile and is only rationalised on those grounds against (very) long tail risk.
- stale2002 9y agoWell sure. Banks prefer blockchains because it provides the properties of a SQL database that everyone syncs up with. And this complicated, sql database by another name is vastly vastly preferable to the stuff that banks are doing now. Yes, the fact that blockchains act as a public database is way way better than the outdated stuff that banks spend billions of dollars on. But it is still not the 'innovative' and interesting part of blockchains.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]