3 ms·
> By the same logic, do you think you're entitled to any commercial stock photo, so long as it's "generic" or "mechanical" enough? Yes, obviously. For example
by ars 9y ago
> By the same logic, do you think you're entitled to any commercial stock photo, so long as it's "generic" or "mechanical" enough?
Yes, obviously.
For example a simple direct photo of artwork has no copyright to the photographer. It doesn't matter if the person claims copyright - they don't have it.
There are tons of things people claim copyright to, without actually having that legal right. These photos of a VHS tape fall in that category - they do not meet the threshold of originality, because there is none. It is simply a mechanical photo of an object.
Copyright is a legal right, not a natural right. It's only given in specific circumstances.
Just because you did work, even if it was really hard, and you did a lot of work, does not mean you get copyright. That's simply not the legal standard.
- tptacek 9y agoYou seem very confident about this. I think you're wrong. Can you show either a statute or a court case in which it was decided that a photograph --- a work explicitly designated as copyrightable since at least the Copyright Act of 1870 --- was found not to be protected by copyright due to insufficient originality? For the countervailing evidence, you might check out the footnotes in Ets-Hokin v Skyy Spirits.