6 ms·
whether this will help provide the kind of production volume needed to make consumer products (like laptops and desktops) more likely to be viable? It probably
by wmf 9y ago
whether this will help provide the kind of production volume needed to make consumer products (like laptops and desktops) more likely to be viable?
It probably won't, despite a lot of wishful thinking to the contrary.
Are general purpose chips likely to be one result of the development of RISC-V, or have I missed something fundamental?
Out of the whole RISC-V ecosystem it looks like only SiFive is working on that, so it will take time.
- guelo 9y agoThe announcement does say "we are providing all of our RISC-V logic work to the community." Whatever that means.
- garmaine 9y agoIt means essentially “open source,” its just that this time the source code is in a hardware definition language.
- microcolonel 9y ago> Out of the whole RISC-V ecosystem it looks like only SiFive is working on that, so it will take time. If you look at Qualcomm's strategy with x86 competition (using Dynamic Binary Translation), it's not hard to imagine that they might consider building RISC-V application processors; especially once they've proven their ability to deliver enough compatibility and performance with DBT to compete on ISAs for which their device is not licensed (and especially if they are sued by Intel and win, one of those things where you'd jump for joy if you saw a C&D in the mail).
- hawski 9y agoCan Qualcomm do that? Tegra K1 from nVidia was supposed to be x86 in similar way. They couldn't get a license so it became an ARM core.
- microcolonel 9y ago> Can Qualcomm do that? Tegra K1 from nVidia was supposed to be x86 in similar way. They couldn't get a license so it became an ARM core. NVIDIA bought Transmeta; Transmeta basically proved (by being sued into insolvency) that they couldn't compete on (up to date, still under patent) x86 with hardware or whole-system software DBT for licensing reasons. NVIDIA's K1/Denver products are very similar to Transmeta architectures still, but for ARMv8 instead of x86(or, more interesting, AMD64), and in this case they have an architectural license. What Qualcomm is doing is different. Qualcomm is doing software-only Dynamic Binary Translation, and they're doing it on a per-application basis (similar to the Mac 68K emulator, Rosetta, WOW64, or QEMU user mode).
- deepnotderp 9y agoEsperanto Technologies is working on high performance general purpose RISC-V processors.