4 ms·
It is an insidious problem. There were a couple of kids around here that weren't stealing the cars, they were just breaking into them on driveways at 2AM and ru
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
It is an insidious problem. There were a couple of kids around here that weren't stealing the cars, they were just breaking into them on driveways at 2AM and rummaging around for spare change and what not.
Almost every countermeasure defeats the convenience factor. One proposal was to have the key light up and you pressed a button on it to say 'yeah do your thing' but at that point why not just have the old style push to open fob?
Perhaps something magnetically coupled rather than RF coupled will help keep it reliably a near field sort of interaction but even that is subject to a slightly more sophisticated relay device.
- jwr 9y agoFortunately, this problem has an easy solution. IEEE 802.15.4 UWB (Ultra-Wideband) radios with timestamping functionality allow measuring the time of flight (well, not directly, but it can be inferred from an exchange of messages) of your signal. With some added crypto, it isn't difficult to build a solution which is limited to a specified distance. You can get as precise as ±20cm. This means that you can build a system which will not work beyond a certain distance, because signals will take too long to travel. I'm surprised this hasn't been picked up by car manufacturers yet. Perhaps there is too little market pressure.
- londons_explore 9y agoThe time of flight is not cryptographically secure. Ie. an attacker can trick it. There are protocols which are though: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distance-bounding_protocol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distance-bounding_protocol
- xr4ti 9y agoSure. However, I think the objective would to increase difficultly and the level sophistication required for exploitation rather than compete security. For instance, a physical lock on your front door can easily be defeated by someone with the requisite tools and expertise, but that doesn't make them useless as a security measure.
- jwr 9y agoBy itself it isn't, but use the timestamps as part of an authenticated exchange, and you're fine.