9 ms·
Without Capitalism we wouldn’t have anything like Facebook or Twitter. These services don’t control ‘the’ flow of information, they are entirely additive to wha
by simonh 9y ago
Without Capitalism we wouldn’t have anything like Facebook or Twitter. These services don’t control ‘the’ flow of information, they are entirely additive to what we had before. Arguing that we have worse options for communication now is bizarre.
So what is the non capitalist alternative? State controlled social media services? Really? That would be a better option in Romania right now?
Facebook is far from perfect, I barely use it at all because it winds me up, but it’s a fantastic Communications platform. And of course they shouldn’t be interfering like this, but it looks like they’ve been manipulated by people flagging content rather than deliberately taking a political stance. I’m sorry but this anti capitalism whining, without offering even a hint of what you think might work better, really winds me up. It’s just populist posturing.
- richrichardsson 9y agoSo if people can't posit an alternative, they must never complain about the existing system?
- jamespo 9y agoas long as they appreciate their complaining will come to nowt, do it as much as they like
- fghtr 9y ago>So what is the non capitalist alternative? Here they are: https://prism-break.org/en/all/#social-networks https://prism-break.org/en/all/#social-networks
- dawnbreez 9y agoI would go one further and suggest simply hosting your own site.
- andrepd 9y agoYes. Does anybody remember the ancient times there were these things called personal Web pages, and blogs, instead of everything being Facebook page/feed?
- simonh 9y agoExactly my point. These things all still exist and are easier to get started with than ever. Nobody is holding a gun to anyone's had and forcing them to use Facebook, or Twitter and honestly if it wasn't for this article about suppressing information about protests in Romania of Facebook I wouldn't even know there were protests in Romania. So something seems to be working out. If all this stuff had been posted on people's individual personally hosted blogs I would never know.
- LoonyBalloony 9y ago> So what is the non capitalist alternative? From my understanding, 100% worker owned and operated co-ops that give the average worker more democratic control in the work place.
- simonh 9y agoWhat's stopping those from starting up and doing the job right now? Sounds great. Where are they? Is there some aspect of the current system that's rigged against them somehow? I know a few of these do exist, usually founded on what was essentially a gift of the starting capital to the collective, but that doesn't seem like a scalable model.
- pectolino 9y agoFirst it is a confusion about the condition of capitalism and democracy. Capitalism can function very well in a dictatorship . Second , Facebook is able to make compromise about free speech because is just a bussiness . If in a country , the usage of facebook is conditionated by the power ,the company will accept the rules of the power because its interest is to make money in that country. You can see china.
- nickpp 9y agoDo you have an example? In most dictatorships I know state was deeply involved in the economy, thus making it socialist. Capitalism requires free markets. Freedom, the opposite of dictatorship.
- zaarn 9y agoState-controlled markets are not automatically socialist, they can for example be communist in nature too. Capitalism doesn't require a free market. As evidenced by American ISP's, all you need is capital and the will to have more of it plus the cooperation of the government. Freedom is not involved in Capitalism nor is it an evident feature of it.
- simonh 9y agoBy Capitalism people usually mean the freedom to own capital, the freedom to invest or spend it as one likes and the freedom to benefit individually from the fruits of one's labour. These are all real freedoms. If we redefine it so that Maoism, Leninism and even Marxism are all forms of capitalism then it really loses it's usefulness as a term and makes it impossible to understand what most people have ever said or written about it.
- zaarn 9y ago>These are all real freedoms. Nah, those are madeup freedoms for humans. Freedom isn't something real you can touch, smell or measure. And it should be mentioned that the entire first paragraph on Wikipedia about Capitalism doesn't mention freedom at all. The only instance of the word "free" in the opening section is in relation to "free market capitalism", a version of capitalism. >If we redefine it so that Maoism, Leninism and even Marxism are all forms of capitalism then it really loses it's usefulness as a term and makes it impossible to understand what most people have ever said or written about it. Not really nor did I do these things. Leninism as for example experienced in East Germany was decidedly different to the Social Market Capitalism in West Germany, one is a Capitalistic Market and the other is not. However, there is nothing about the East that makes a Capitalistic Market or even Free Market impossible.
- freeflight 9y ago> These services don’t control ‘the’ flow of information, they are entirely additive to what we had before. They very much do control the flow by "personalizing" the content people see and don't see based on how likely somebody is to click something for ad-revenue. That's the direct result of the "capitalist nature" of these platforms; If they can't monetize it, it's of no interest to them, so they try to capitalize on everything, even on users biases. Surfacing news about how refugees are not raping everything in sight won't do much for a user who has a very clear anti-refugee bias, such a user won't be very likely to click such news as such they won't be surfaced to the user. But if you surface news about how Germany is supposedly on the brink of collapse because refugees are roaming free as raping herds, to that very same user, then you will most likely just have generated ad-revenue. This doesn't just extend to what kind of news get surfaced, but through the whole system: Suggestions for friends, groups, and whatnot all take into account the individual users known "leanings", in essence creating echo chambers where only people of similar views interact with each other. While at the same time blending out any alternative/controversial view (for that group) by not even surfacing them to in the very first place, as they won't be very likely to click on them and as such less chance for ad-revenue. That's why so many people are so utterly convinced of their positions: Their social media feeds give them constant reinforcement for their position by only surfacing news, people, and organization who share these position. Eli Pariser's book "The Filter Bubble" has some very good (and scary) insights into this dynamic.
- ggdG 9y ago> Surfacing news about how refugees are not raping everything in sight won't do much for a user who has a very clear anti-refugee bias, such a user won't be very likely to click such news as such they won't be surfaced to the user. But if you surface news about how Germany is supposedly on the brink of collapse because refugees are roaming free as raping herds, to that very same user, then you will most likely just have generated ad-revenue. It's strange how you - out of all possible kinds of stories that might go viral on social media - choose to evoke a charicature of the mass influx of "refugees" into Germany and its consequences on public order and on the safety of women in public places. This is strange because your view seems to be that a benevolent govenment can protect hapless citizens from fake news stories by censoring social media. However, in the aftermath of New Year's Eve 2015-2016 exactly the opposite happened. When more than 1200 women got sexually assaulted during one night, on one city square in Cologne [1], not a single newpaper or TV channel dared to break the news in the following 4 days. It was only very reluctantly - when the outrage on social media became too big to ignore - that they started covering it. Thanks to this coverage it became gradually clear that similar incidents had happened all over Germany that night, and also in other European countries. It also became clear that the Cologne police was understaffed at that time as many officers were diverted to Bavaria [2] to help manage the influx of a million [3] largely undocumented foreigners into the country. This created a de facto lawlessness in the streets of Cologne that allowed groups of muslim males on New Year's Eve to subject Western women to the same Quran/Hadith-inspired misogyny and violence [4] [5] [6] as women in Muslim countries [7]. Without the unregulated social media (and in spite of its many well-known flaws) the German general public would never have been made aware of these events and of the initial cover-up by the government. On June 30 2017, slyly planned on the same day as the gay marriage bill (which got all the attention that day) [8], the German parliament approved a bill to censor "hate speech" and "fake news" on the internet. [9] So today it is very well possible that news about another "Cologne-scale" event would never bubble up into public knowledge because now social media are censored just as thoroughly as regular media. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Year%27s_Eve_sexual_assaults_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Year%27s_Eve_sexual_assaul... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jan/06/tensions-rise-in-germany-over-handling-of-mass-sexual-assaults-in-cologne https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jan/06/tensions-rise-... [3] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2016/05/04/germany-welcomed-more-than-1-million-refugees-in-2015-now-the-country-is-searching-for-its-soul/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2016/05/04... [4] https://www.thereligionofpeace.com/pages/quran/women-worth-less.aspx https://www.thereligionofpeace.com/pages/quran/women-worth-l... [5] https://www.thereligionofpeace.com/pages/quran/rape-adultery.aspx https://www.thereligionofpeace.com/pages/quran/rape-adultery... [6] https://www.thereligionofpeace.com/pages/muhammad/rape.aspx https://www.thereligionofpeace.com/pages/muhammad/rape.aspx [7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_sexual_assault_in_Egypt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_sexual_assault_in_Egypt [8] http://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2017/06/world/germany-same-sex-marriage-cnnphotos/ http://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2017/06/world/germany-sam... [9] https://www.theguardian.com/media/2017/jun/30/germany-approves-plans-to-fine-social-media-firms-up-to-50m https://www.theguardian.com/media/2017/jun/30/germany-approv...
- jacobr 9y ago> So what is the non capitalist alternative? State controlled social media services? The alternative is not state controlled media, but rather anything other than an oligopoly. For several reasons it overtook IRC, personal websites, etc, but alternatives are not unthinkable.
- sandinmytea 9y ago"Bicameral" board structure in a B-Corp w/ appropriate mission. A blocking vote's worth of "stakeholders" which have predetermined portions of a holdings company (Ben Cohen, thnx!) Accept capital the same, yet shareholders only have x% instead of x+f*users%. Make revenue via advertisement, hosting, SaaS; aggregate, anonymize and make available the data. Cloud computing, independent instances + economies of scale for the cohort. AI assisted web-rings for social media/hypermedia. It would profit-share the popular content creators AND open source contributors.
- nickpp 9y agoSounds interesting, now go build it. Don’t just tell others what to do, lead by example and prove that it’s viable.
- simonh 9y agoNot unthinkable, but all the ones that have been suggested are, either unusable for most people. ‘Install your own server!’ Or quite possible but nobody is actually doing it, and therefore are irrelevant. That’s the thing with Capitalism, it gets stuff done.
- salvar 9y ago> So what is the non capitalist alternative? State controlled social media services? Really? That would be a better option in Romania right now? Right here you ask for an alternative, then suggest it is one particular alternative, then argue against that as if it's the only answer. Do you think that's an honest way of debating?
- simonh 9y agoStill no actual suggestion of an alternative.
- Can_Not 9y agoWhat about both non-capitalist and non-state controlled?
- salvar 9y agoThat's not an answer to my question. Did you accidentally reply to the wrong comment?
- simonh 9y agoNo I suggested a possible alternative and asked if there were any others. All I got back was snark.
- imran3740 9y agoHere's one: Mastodon [0]. It's decentralized, you can deploy your own instance, and doesn't (necessarily) rely on advertising. [0]: https://joinmastodon.org/ https://joinmastodon.org/
- _Tev 9y ago> It's decentralized, you can deploy your own instance So it's useless as a social network. Not an alternative. I wonder when will the anti-centralization people realize that their solutions are not for everyone, and that's why so many people don't care about them.
- tomcooks 9y ago> So what is the non capitalist alternative? State controlled social media services? Come on. More like decentralized, optionally self hosted istances of open source social networks. Given the amount of politics meddling that Facebook,Twitter Google and Amazon do especially out of the US, i would consider THEM the actual state-controlled service.
- simonh 9y agoOk, fair enough. Systems like that do exist, but practically nobody uses them. We need an alternative that actually addresses people's need in a way they access. But even in the system you describe, what is to stop biased operators from infiltrating the system and biasing the distribution of messages to filter out opposing views, or generating fake content? How does a system like that maintain integrity? Until you have a reliable functional, usable system it's just pie in the sky.
- lakechfoma 9y agoYou're right but at least that pie in the sky is something WE lowly mortals can have a say in. FB/Twitter/Google are black boxes and we have no idea what their real interests are, how they implement/enforce/change the processes that skew the media we consume. Would it actually be any better? Who knows but something has gotta give cause what we got now is definitely broke and not going to be fixed
- simonh 9y agoOf course we have a say. We can choose which services we use, and we can vote in and lobby governments that regulate them effectively.
- bogomipz 9y agoYou seemed to have selectively seized on the work "capitalist" in the OPs post. Nowhere does the post seem to be an attack on capitalism. The OP stated: >"Having facebook, or any similar monolithic capitalist behemoth ..." All three words together "monolithic" + "capitalist" + "behemoth" need to be taken together, it is not the same thing as the same as just saying "capitalist." >"These services don’t control ‘the’ flow of information, they are entirely additive to what we had before." Except they are not additive for groups that never consumed the older mediums in the first place: http://www.journalism.org/2015/06/01/facebook-top-source-for-political-news-among-millennials/ http://www.journalism.org/2015/06/01/facebook-top-source-for...
- coldtea 9y ago>Without Capitalism we wouldn’t have anything like Facebook or Twitter. So, like, three gifts at once? Though, citation needed. The web was created by public funds, in a European public institution. The internet by army funds, in a US public institution. What we call capitalism is just a way of organizing the economy that emerged circa 14-15th century (people have almost always bought and sold things, but not in a capitalist context). Historically capitalism has never been the only game in town (and I'm not talking about communism either). Whole societies and empires rose and flourished without it -- and they could have just as well created social media too, if they had the technology at the time. They have created tons of great stuff we now build upon anyway. >These services don’t control ‘the’ flow of information, they are entirely additive to what we had before. Arguing that we have worse options for communication now is bizarre. Of course they control the flow of information, that's how they make money. That they don't control "the whole flow" or that they don't hold people at gunpoint to dictate their own flow is irrelevant for what we're discussing. It's enough that they control a large enough flow, for enough people, to be hugely (and negatively) influential in the flow of overall information. And of course, they're not neutral to the flows they allow.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoMaybe Free Market was meant, instead of Capitalism
- coldtea 9y agoEven free market is a recent obsession. Societies historical had all kinds of protections, tariffs, and other measures (heck, not just Italian city states or Rome, the US itself had heavy tariffs, subsidies and such for most of its existence, until they established their economic and diplomatic dominance, and only then pretended like its all about the free market). That's on top of the cultural, religious, civic and other restrictions on trade in the past.
- simonh 9y agoI didn’t say internet, I said Facebook and Twitter. Both were both founded with VC funds.
- Chris_Jay 9y agoThe choice isn't a binary between corporate monopolies or a non capitalist alternative, there is a very wide spectrum of possible 'topias between those two extremes. Methinks public discourse is overdue for a revival of good old fashioned Aristotelian Virtue Ethics.
- drumttocs8 9y agoThe alternative is very obviously nonprofits, such as Wikipedia, who do a fantastic job of serving up the internet's original intended purpose- free information exchange without a catch.