4 ms·
"Should Dr. Lui really know how to handle the situation ..." Yes he should. This [1] is literally the second link to the Google search "what do I do if someone
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
"Should Dr. Lui really know how to handle the situation ..."
Yes he should. This [1] is literally the second link to the Google search "what do I do if someone steals my photograph" and it has a nice check box of things to do which includes this step:
Do some research
Find out the infringing person’s name as well as their contact information.
This information is often available in the website’s “About Us” section.
Use a website such as WhoIsHostingThis.com to learn the website’s ISP. This information may be necessary later
Typing "Netflix General Counsel" into Google gives you the address of Dave Hyman as the first link.
If you go to Gough Lui's website (http://goughlui.com/about-me-a-short-bio/publications-and-appearances/ http://goughlui.com/about-me-a-short-bio/publications-and-ap...) he is clearly fairly internet aware and understands how to use search engines.
Based on that I think it is well within the GP's expectation that Dr. Lui should be able to figure that out and send a letter to Netflix demanding either they stop shipping their product or retroactively license his imagery for $<x> where he might want to consult with a Photography Agent to understand what size 'x' might represent.
[1] https://www.whoishostingthis.com/blog/2016/01/27/images-stolen/ https://www.whoishostingthis.com/blog/2016/01/27/images-stol...
- mherdeg 9y agoSomething like 1-5% of the news.ycombinator front page is customer service escalations. I don't think it's totally crazy to write a blog post & publicize it on social media as an alternative to the traditional executive-email-carpet-bomb. It's not necessarily the best strategy but it's certainly not the worst.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI completely agree with that, and it isn't crazy to write a blog post about it. That said, a blog post that had his written letter to the general counsel and Netflix's unsatisfactory response to that, would seem to merit escalation. Dr. Lui seems to have made a good start but it is early days yet it seems to me.
- trcollinson 9y agoGreat link! In fact according to this Dr. Lui actually did all of the right things. Let’s recap: The link says “make a copy of the infringed work.” It seems from this blog post and what he sent to the customer service and PR link he certainly did that. “Determine that the use was actually theft.” Again I think Dr. Lui did that as well. It seems he has at least a basic understanding of copyright law. “Do some research.” Well he has a hard time finding the corporate information for Netflix, or even a phone number. In his post he points this out. So as a means to find that information he did contact customer service. I guess he could have contacted their isp ;) which is another suggestion that your link gives. But I’m not sure he would have found any additional help by doing so. My point is two fold. First, your helpful checklist isn’t actually that helpful in this case. Second, he actually followed all of those steps. I guess he could have googled for Netflix corporate. This would have shown him officers and directors. Whether that would be useful is hard to tell. It’s also important to remember that General Counsel is an American term. It does not always translate outside of the US.
- chris_wot 9y agoHe’s an Australian. That doesn’t give him much leeway. Rather ironically, Netflix has prevented VPNs due to copyright infringement. It’s hyopcritical of them not to deal with those in other geographic areas than the U.S.
- tareqak 9y agoThanks for your replies! Along with your other reply here, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15794032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15794032, I do think both sides could have done better, but it not a path sufficiently well-traveled. The issue at large seems deserving of some best practices love: e.g. 1) All inbound corporate communication channels should have an escalation path to the registered agent / general counsel. 2) Potential plaintiffs should be able to access the directions here https://blogmedia.whoishostingthis.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/Photographers-Images-Stolen.jpg https://blogmedia.whoishostingthis.com/wp-content/uploads/20... from here https://www.whoishostingthis.com/blog/2016/01/27/images-stolen/ https://www.whoishostingthis.com/blog/2016/01/27/images-stol... . 3) The directions in 2) need additional guidance language for international issues. 4) Maybe 1) should have a link to 2) or something like it, but for more general legal issues / workflows. I can see that in this case that a web search would have helped, but the root of every complicated, multi-party, decision problem is probably not going to be found on the first page every single time. In 2017, I'd strongly argue that it really should be.
- xorgar831 9y ago> Yes he should. Why can't we program our <something> support departments to act on information they're given? Why do we need to program these departments like they're half AI zombies?
- codingdave 9y agoFor all we know, they DID act on the information given... and sent him down a pointless rabbit hole to prevent him actually taking the correct steps to address the problem. After all, Netflix is in the wrong here... and I don't know of any corporation who will happily assist someone in filing a grievance against themselves. On the contrary, if someone is sending repeated emails about something that could potentially be a lawsuit, I'd guess my lawyer would advise the same thing -- ignore it unless they actually file paperwork. Think of it like getting pulled over for speeding -- Everyone knows you did something wrong. But when the officer says, "Do you know how fast you were going?", do you respond with "Yes, officer, I was going 31 in a 25. Please give me my ticket now." No, you admit no wrong and hope they don't push it so you get away with it.
- Matt3o12_ 9y agoBecause it is in Netflix best interest if he doesn’t get a laywer. He said the images can easily go up to $600 and I believe this is truly what he would have gotten if they asked. Now since he they took it without asking, he probably could get a lot more (it is after all used as promotional material and there are a lot of ads for it). If Netflix wanted the copyright infringement to go away as quickly, and cheaply as possible, they would just pay him without lawyers on his part who would probably advice him to go to court. You’re analogy with the police office is a bad one for this example. Image you dumped another can without you realizing that. Fortunately for you, the other person does not call the police immediately. Instead, they manage to track you down and send you a letter asking you to pay for the damages. You can assert that this did in fact happen because their paint is on your car. This is in your best interest. You really don’t want to get charged for a hit and run. You are glad he did not go to the police, pay the damages and send a nice apology letter. Netflix probably did not know about the copyright infringement. It probably was made by a design company. Netflix should have know whom the VGA cassette originates from, but they did not and this is unfortunate but can happen. It is in netflix’s best internet to go away silently. What I believe had happened is that he was sent to the wrong department. That department saw the email and though it was not authentic/a fake to quickly export money or baseless. A company must get a lot of emails: “you owe me money because xyz”.
- cavisne 9y ago"Typing "Netflix General Counsel" into Google gives you the address of Dave Hyman as the first link." Fairly sure thats incorrect. I found no mention of their corporate address on a *netflix.com domain, just a bunch of head quarters aggregators.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOn my machine, the first link in the search results is to the ir.netflix.com pages (ir stands for Investor Relations) which has the list of directors and managers. That is a Netflix owned page. And if you click the 'annual reports' link it shows the corporate headquarters address at the top. So you are correct, it is two clicks to get both the name and address of the general counsel from Netflix. And while I don't necessarily expect anyone to know off the top of their head that the top legal contact for a company will be called their 'general counsel', there are many many many stories on the web about people who have had their photos misappropriated and used (from travel brochures to bus stop ads) and doing any research at all would give you a clear sense of what the right course of action would be to do here. Further I would expect anyone with a PhD to be familiar with how to research a new topic of interest, to evaluate sources, and to derive the key principles underlying the system if they were widely understood and published (like image copyright is).
- Declanomous 9y agoI don't know why I would contact the general counsel of a company if they stole my work. I'm not an artist, but I have made some art, and if someone stole that art I would call the company itself. Additionally, I've tried calling the corporate number for a number of companies in the past, and oftentimes they are just a message that says I should email them if I need to contact corporate. SF companies are particularly bad with this, I guess paying people to answer the phone is a waste of money. If your customer service can't figure out how to escalate legal issues, that sounds like the fault of the company, not the fault of the person who is trying to bring legal issues to their attention.
- seandougall 9y ago
- wpietri 9y agoEh. He made a good-faith attempt to contact them. The first person he talked to told him who to contact. If there's an error here, it's on the part of Netflix, not Dr. Lui.
- chefandy 9y agoTalking to a rich corporation’s GC without any idea about how to turn your claim into leverage is like asking a mob consigliere to pay the cleaning bill after one of their guys murdered someone in your pizza shop. At best they’re going to ignore you or tell you to piss off. At worst they’re going to try to intimidate you into silence. Either way, “just email their lawyers” is likely a fruitless endeavor without your own to push the right buttons.
- Nexxxeh 9y agoWhile a beautifully painted analogy, it's possibly a somewhat overly cynical one. As demonstrated previously with the C&D to the Stranger Things themed pop-up, Netflix's in-house counsel are reasonable and PR savvy. I'd hold off the mob comparisons for a little while.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]