2 ms·
Hogwash. Looking past the author's insulting and sophomoric use of "geek" as a derogatory put-down, let's get to his claims: > The "US is behind on broadband"
by potatolicious 16y ago
Hogwash.
Looking past the author's insulting and sophomoric use of "geek" as a derogatory put-down, let's get to his claims:
> The "US is behind on broadband" thing is a myth.
Yet no sources are cited. All he does is wave his hands about how Mossberg is the only one saying it, and everyone is just a regurgitating idiot. Last I checked, this issue has been around for a while, and is supported by a lot more voices than Mossberg.
Then he starts going to a straw man - claiming the regulatory angle is fundamentally undemocratic, and completely ignores the fact that existing telcos operate with a government-granted monopoly, making internet service fundamentally not a free market enterprise to begin with.
> "At the root of this anger against the ISPs is that they want faster Internet access and they don’t want to pay for it"
I'm not sure how much more ignorant this comment can get. My internet service at home experiences frequent lag spikes up to 3000ms, yet I have to just deal with it because no other ISP can operate where I live (this is a city thing, not a building thing). Quit pretending there's a free market when there is none.
> "since I’m about as geeky as they come"
I'm not sure how this can be, since he seems to claim to be a geek, yet he uses the term in a derogatory way and pisses all over the demographic frequently in the post, portraying them as entitled children, and blind sheep following the Mossberg prophet.
So let's summarize: straw man argument, appeal to ridicule, argument from ignorance (i.e., there is no problem with ISPs because the studies claiming problems are allegedly problemtic), appeal to emotion (the pointless linking of this to "democracy")... is this a high school rhetoric class or something?