3 ms·
I suppose one has to know calculus and topology to navigate Earth. Worth a smattering of quantum physics and wave physics. Oh wait. Those do not fall under suc
by AstralStorm 9y ago
I suppose one has to know calculus and topology to navigate Earth. Worth a smattering of quantum physics and wave physics.
Oh wait. Those do not fall under such narrow definition of intelligence.
- jessaustin 9y agoHow many insects or birds know "calculus and topology"? You're straining so much here, to be both narrow and broad, that you contradict yourself.
- AstralStorm 9y agoExactly the point. Those skills are not needed to successfully navigate the Earth, yet we have developed them. The rationale was general self improvement and more control over nature. So the general premise is to ensure better and higher survival. Which is a changing objective function. No reason why a GAI wouldn't have a similar instinct or capabilities. Author also misposes no free lunch theorem. It pertains to algorithms not computational ability, and we're entirely not sure if true intelligence is an immutable algorithm. (Human is not, because of genetics.) There is no real equivalent theorem for self modifying algorithms, (or changing objective functions) and if there were, it will run afoul of halting problem. Three theorem also had at least one known hole where it does not apply to coevolutionary algorithms. (Such as part of Alpha Go to go for an easy example.) While environment puts on a hard limit, the limit is extremely high, on the order of 2^300. The optimising does not have to go for the simplest algorithm to solve the problem. And we do not know enough about informational capacity of matter in quantum states to be honest.
- cdancette 9y agowhat is 2^300 ?
- AstralStorm 9y agoBits of estimated Kolmogorov complexity of the universe.
- visarga 9y agoNo, you suppose wrong. You should suppose we are social animals that collectively solve problems, and that calculus and topology are just side effects of that.