4 ms·
> you don't have the choice to get another ISP Patently false. Of the several million developed US census blocks, 100% have multiple ISPs offering 10Mbps+. [1
by paulddraper 9y ago
> you don't have the choice to get another ISP
Patently false.
Of the several million developed US census blocks, 100% have multiple ISPs offering 10Mbps+. [1]
In fact, I daresay it is easier to switch your ISP than to switch your social network. The hooplah around NN is an effective distraction; ISPs aren't even close to being the monopoly to worry about.
[1] https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-344499A1.pdf https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-344499A1.p...
- british_india 9y agoRidiculous. Over the past 15 years, I have lived in Phoenix, Houston, Salt Lake City, New York City, Cincinnati and NOT ONCE did I have a choice.
- mindslight 9y agoAt first I was wondering how I could turn your citation into a referral to an actual provider! But thinking about the technicals, the unit of a census block is basically meaningless. DSL can easily achieve 10MBit+ when close to a central office. There will tend to be a CO close enough to somewhere in each census block, making that class of speed technically "available". But this is ultimately meaningless when it comes to the actual distances involved for most of the people within.
- paulddraper 9y agoI'll concede that a census block isn't a perfect measure. There are 11 million of them in the US, and I don't know of a comprehensive study with better units.
- epicide 9y agoThey should have put "you don't have a REAL choice to get another ISP". 10Mbps would not be enough for me nor most of my (even non-technical) family members. Beyond that, the ones that do offer faster speeds have a cap that I would go past pretty much every month. I even live in a fairly sizeable city. If I had another realistic option than cable, I would've already taken it. The issue comes from the fact that a lot of ISPs are, for reasons above, basically monopolies. This is, by itself, a really bad thing™. Lack of NN just lets them blackmail everybody from both sides on top of having practically 0 competition. EDIT: your link actually shows you're wrong. The graph on page 6 (which I assume you're referring to) shows that 100% have multiple choices of 3+ Mbps, not 10+. 10+ only has 97%. Sure, it's only 3%, but that's still not 100% and not "patently false". In that document, they don't mention prices, anywhere. Also, on that same page, they mention: > A provider that reports offering service in a particular census block may not offer service, or service at that speed, to all locations in the census block. Accordingly, the number of providers shown in Figure 4 does not necessarily reflect the number of choices available to a particular household and does not purport to measure competition.
- paulddraper 9y ago> 10Mbps would not be enough for me nor most of my (even non-technical) family members. !!! I won't say that is impossible to use that much. But Netflix -- who, if anything, is pressured to overestimate -- advises only half that speed for streaming high-definition video. [1] Twenty dial-up modems is more than enough to make for a workable internet, outside of 3+ HD video streams, downloading disk images, etc. [1] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/306 https://help.netflix.com/en/node/306
- epicide 9y agoI know of several homes where more than one Netflix stream is common, then throw in a Twitch/YouTube stream on top of that. Realistically, you don't always see speeds at what you pay for (especially during peak hours). At least I don't. So, I think it makes sense to pad your max speeds a bit. As far as 20 dial-up modems: I don't see where you get 20 from or even why that comparison matters. We aren't just using geocities and AIM anymore.
- paulddraper 9y agoSorry, 20 was a typo. I meant 200 modems, which is the equivalent of 10mbps.
- timthelion 9y ago"who, if anything, is pressured to overestimate" um, why would they be pressured to overestimate. They don't want to scare away customers who would think "well I'm not sure if my internet is fast enough..." HD video streaming is surprisingly not the most bandwidth intensive activity. Facebook is actually more intensive. As is online gaming. And HD streaming is especially easy when its done by netflix which already has a network non-neutral setup https://www.beet.tv/2013/05/netflix-2.html https://www.beet.tv/2013/05/netflix-2.html. You may think "well, that 10Mbs is the same whether or not it is being streamed from next door or across the ocean", but you'd be wrong, due to the fact that low latency network connections are much more efficient at using that bandwidth.
- slg 9y agoThat is including satellite. The latency of satellite internet is too high to really be considered as a viable alternative to other high speed ISPs. The bandwidth might be high enough to make Netflix streaming practical, but you are not going to be able to do anything that requires consistent real time communication.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Cozumel 9y agoAnd that's why 40% of Detroit homes don't have internet?[0] [0]https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/kz3xyz/detroit-mesh-network?utm_source=mbtwitter https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/kz3xyz/detroit-me...
- jlgaddis 9y agoI work for an ISP that appears on (some of) those U.S. broadband maps. They are incredibly inaccurate and far from being up-to-date.
- heurist 9y agoFunny that my house in a block with around 300 other residents is only covered by one ISP, then.
- toxican 9y agoMy options are Comcast, Century Link, satellite, and some kind of mobile tethering or just using my phone. Comcast is going to be the source of all of my problems if NN crumbles, so let's look at Century Link. I could be same amount of money to them, but I'd get like a 1/10 the speed if I was super lucky. As far as I'm concerned it's not a practical alternative at all given how we use the internet in my house and our financial limitations. So then there's satellite, which is not a practical solution either. I'd probably end up paying more and have worse internet speeds than I would with DSL. AND I'd completely have to give up any sort of online gaming that I do. A great way to finally kick that WoW habit, but not really a practical alternative to Comcast. Okay so what about mobile tethering? I already pay as much as I currently pay for Comcast each month for my cell phone and I've got like 3GBs of data total to use. Last month, with Comcast, I used close to half a TB. I'm not going to do the math for what it would cost me to do that with my mobile carrier, but it's more than I spend on all my other utilities combined, I'm sure. And that's, of course, assuming a carrier available to me is able to provide decent speeds or even allows tethering at all. So that's not a practical alternative. So sorry I do not buy it. It's like saying "you don't need a water supplier! You've got Coke, beer, and coffee available to 100% of everyone!". Yes, technically those are liquids that consist of some water, but the price is going to be ridiculous, you're going to have kidney stones, and you're going to be fat.
- fludlight 9y agoAlmost all US addresses have a choice between the local cable monopoly at 150Mbps+ or a variety of DSL companies at one tenth that speed. That's not much of a choice at all.