4 ms·
An accredited investor is just a term for someone allowed to invest in things not regulated by the SEC. If you think that EVERYONE should be able to invest in t
by cortesoft 9y ago
An accredited investor is just a term for someone allowed to invest in things not regulated by the SEC. If you think that EVERYONE should be able to invest in things not regulated by the SEC, you are basically saying that being regulated by the SEC should be completely voluntary (i.e. a company can choose to be regulated or not).
You can argue that it should work like that, but we intentionally decided to make SEC regulation the rule, and only grant exceptions for investors who have demonstrated they can handle the risk.
There is nothing saying that a non-accredited investor can't invest when a valuation is low. The investment just has to be regulated by the SEC.
- ringaroundthetx 9y ago> You can argue that it should work like that, but we intentionally decided to make SEC regulation the rule, and only grant exceptions for investors who have demonstrated they can handle the risk. We had no say in this. The SEC unilaterally created modern day (1970s onward) accredited investor rules, although I'm sure they had their routine public comment period as if that made a difference. The 1930s Congress and public had no idea that exemption from their protection would take shape this way. Former accredited investor-like rules relied on financial literacy tests. These were predictable discriminatory and even the most compliant financial firms found them to be too vague. The SEC switched to the money tests to solve the lack of clarity and discrimination problems, LOL OOPS.
- cortesoft 9y agoSorry, the idea of SEC regulation being the rule, with only limited exceptions, was what I meant by the 'intentionally decided' bit. The exact mechanism for how an exemption is decided is certainly up for debate. I was simply saying the mandatory part was decided on by 'us'.
- conanbatt 9y agoFounders, employees, institutional and retail investors got together and voted for the SEC? Are you sure about that?
- gamblor956 9y agoAmerica is a republic. Founders, employees, institutional, and retail investors got together, voted for Congressional representatives who then wrote the law creating the SEC and investment rules decades ago. In the decades since, Founders, employees, institutional, and retail investors have continued to elect Congressional representatives who have strengthened and broadened those rules.
- conanbatt 9y agoReally. So if you made a public vote about removing the accredited investment requirements and 51% of the people voted against it, it would blow your mind entirely?