3 ms·
> I want an excellent case I can pack full of RAM, disks and GPUs, not external expansion with $70 cables that glitch and mess up the aesthetic in the process.
by derefr 9y ago
> I want an excellent case I can pack full of RAM, disks and GPUs, not external expansion with $70 cables that glitch and mess up the aesthetic in the process.
I feel like Apple was onto something here, but they screwed up by trying to scale up the mobile paradigm (black boxes connected by cables) when there's a very similar paradigm much friendlier to professional use—the server rack-mount paradigm—that they could just scale down.
Imagine a small "compute core" just like the trashcan Mac Pro (CPUs + RAM + GPUs, replace it all at once when the time comes)... except it's in the form-factor of a server blade, and is sitting in a rack roughly the size of a workstation PC.
You'd buy a "Mac Pro", and in the box would be the (very elegant, Apple-y) rack, one "compute core module" to slot into it, and one "storage module" as well (which is your boot device, making the compute-core diskless and so a commodity.) You could customize your order to get a RAID storage module instead. You could buy more pre-populated modules from Apple, or other vendors, or buy empty modules to install whatever components you want. Third-party empty modules would probably cost about as much as a USB hard-drive enclosure costs today.
And, of course, the modules would all connect to a shared backplane... which would just be PCIe. So it's all the same Thunderbolt idea, just shaped differently.
- bluedino 9y agoApple-specific modules would be expensive and limiting
- derefr 9y agoIf the backplane is PCIe, it'd be really hard to prevent third parties from just making their own modules. Or selling generic $10 PCIe-card enclosures. But that's rather the point: if Apple made this thing, they'd know that, so they probably wouldn't be trying to prevent an open ecosystem of modules at all. They'd be encouraging it, since that's the whole pitch behind why it'd succeed as a "workstation" product in the first place.
- Jyaif 9y ago100% with you, and I still hope this is what they'll replace the trashcan with.
- mastazi 9y agoSo basically you are imagining something like Razer's never realised Project Christine [1], but in a blade form factor? I would like that. Also something like that being made by Apple (which has the market power to sustain an add-on ecosystem) would make more sense, whereas Razer would have never had enough traction (hence the project being cancelled). [1] https://www2.razerzone.com/christine https://www2.razerzone.com/christine
- derefr 9y agoYes! Exactly. Apple could pull this off where Razer failed.
- m_mueller 9y agoI think enclosing each module like Razer did is defeating the purpose. Problem is, if you don't enclose I imagine it's hard to get this past the designers. Apple would need a way to make the internals themselves look good. That being said, the old Powermac / Mac Pro towers had very nice looking internals, I could see them exposing them like that.... Plus, it surely would have a nice looking front door.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoHell make it a Eurorack case. But all Apple styled. It's all the rage with hipster musicians. Imagine being able to intermix your analog modular synth modules with your Mac modules in the same cage.
- brudgers 9y agoApple used to make rack mountable Macs. They stopped in 2010. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xserve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xserve
- derefr 9y agoYes, but an Xserve would not fit under your desk; nor would its power requirements be compatible with the output of a 110V outlet; nor would it be bearable in sound or heat output to sit near one when it's running. And, on the other hand, an Xserve takes up 2U for a complete computer (a rack is for a cluster), whereas in the hypothetical system I'm talking about, one computer takes the whole ~10U by spreading its parts out over all those bays. I'm talking, here, about the consumer electronics-ization of the concept of rackmount servers (or, more specifically, of blade-server chassis-es.) Even if Apple still had the folks who created the Xserve on staff, there really wouldn't be much in common with the resulting architectures. Totally different needs.
- dijit 9y agoSounds like one of those Dell VTRX blade enclosures. http://www.dell.com/en-us/work/shop/povw/poweredge-vrtx http://www.dell.com/en-us/work/shop/povw/poweredge-vrtx
- nerdponx 9y agoAFAICT this model never took off because the total cost came out really high. People have been clamoring for external GPUs for at least a decade, but even nowadays that it's technically feasible by the time you drop the cash for it you're a good chunk of the way to a new gaming rig.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y ago> And, of course, the modules would all connect to a shared backplane... which would just be PCIe. There's an existing industrial standard, MicroTCA, that Apple could probably adapt for this.
- mruniverse 9y agoAs long as it's quiet and expandable and less expensive than the laptops, I don't care what the desktop looks like.