5 ms·
Do scientists use OSX much? Just asking. OTOH a fully-packed graphical / video / audio workstation could be well-received. I just don't think Apple want users
by nine_k 9y ago
Do scientists use OSX much? Just asking. OTOH a fully-packed graphical / video / audio workstation could be well-received.
I just don't think Apple want users to tinker with their machines at all. Fewer configurations = fewer support calls.
- make3 9y agoscientists I know have osx laptops and run jobs on linux compute clusters.
- walshemj 9y agoAKA an expensive way of running telnet or xwindows sessions - when a basic leveano or dell would be cheaper and run full fat office and not the cut down mac versions
- robotresearcher 9y agoResearch profs travel a lot, and thus enjoy battery life and light weight. Many CS and math profs live in LaTeX and shell and not Office. Mac is handy.
- walshemj 9y agoAnd a lot more expensive in a bang for buck way.
- robotresearcher 9y agoDepends how much you weight the battery life and form factor bang. And UNIXness. I value these a LOT. Also: trackpad. Apple's is the best by a mile.
- make3 9y agomore like, having a beautiful ui experience with a full shell, and sending the heavy lifting to a machine made specifically for that
- walshemj 9y agoThat's a matter of opinion and finder is a terrible UI for a file manager for any one who has used windows or Linux file managers. And the way Apple has diverged from a more traditional UNIX like Linux is a big problem if you are developing to run on Linux as it adds a whole new set of risks.
- make3 9y agoalso got what is worth, modern version of Mac office are really good
- walshemj 9y agoIll give you that the latest version of office is an improvement you can go beyond 56K rows in excel now! but its still not as good as the real thing.
- TetOn 9y agoGeneticist in a large academic lab here, I'd say 99% of all computers in use are Macs. Some instrument-tied PCs, a couple of Windows laptops, and that's it. Any data analysis (and these are predominantly sequencing scale datasets) that isn't running on the institutionally provided cluster is also being done on Macs. In my ~20 years on the job in various places, OSX really changed everything; labs used to have a few Macs around for non-analytic tasks where the old MacOS was just easier. Post OSX, it's nearly all Macs unless it ships with an instrument of some kind (and then it's likely Windows). The analytic tool chain is/was massively unix based, so adapting to OSX was easy and came with a very nice GUI that also did the aforementioned easy non-analytic tasks.
- qubex 9y agoThe high-tide of Apple machines in genetic research actually has nothing to do with what most people might presume and has a very specific, very technical reason. The AltiVec (“Velocity Engine”) present in G4 and even more so in 64-bit G5 machines was discovered to be extraordinarily efficient at performing the calculations required for the Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (commonly known as BLAST). At the time, the G4/G5 architectures had a massive lead on other chips present on the market at the time (i80x86-derived machines such as Pentium III, Pentium 4, and Pendium M; but also other exotic architectures such as MIPS, SPARC, and DEC’s Alpha. Eventually other architectures caught up by adding vector units or vector instructions of their own, and Apple stripped any basis of fact out of this when they switched to Intel, but by a form of institutional inertia, Macs still rule in the genetics segment.
- robotresearcher 9y agoA non-scientific mental inventory gives the common setup among my CS colleagues: - Personal computer: MacBook Pro (Linux on Thinkpad or XPS 13 runners up) - Lab workstations: Linux on Dell - Compute server: Racks of Linux on Dell / Generic box of NVIDIA GPUs / Amazon ECC
- masukomi 9y agobut do "lab workstations" really equate to "workstations of people in the business" or "computers this school got a good deal on" ? I think the latter. I suspect that they're irrelevant to this discussion.
- robotresearcher 9y agoI choose my lab workstations. Institution discounts factor in to my decision, but I choose.
- Eric_WVGG 9y agomy impression is that the predecessor of OSX, NeXT, was pretty much the OS of choice in sciences for a good ten years…
- pvg 9y agoIt was certainly its ambition to be an academic workstation originally but lots of other things were. 'OS (or hardware) of choice in sciences' doesn't really reflect reality.
- robotresearcher 9y agoHuh? It’s a market. Not the biggest market, but a real market that spends billions, has extreme needs in some cases, and influences well-trained people who become decision makers in other markets. Why is it not reality?
- pvg 9y agoComment says 'NeXTSTEP wasn't OS of choice in sciences', not what you misread it as.
- jcadam 9y agoBack in college (1998-2002), I had an old, white-bearded CS professor who kept (and actually did work on) an old NeXT Station in his office. He was a little... off.
- cat199 9y agonot really. More like Sun in those days (or maybe SGI or IBM rs6000, possibly HPUX though it was more for business) depending on whatever proprietary things you wanted to run.. but really Sun. from there: linux PC's until OsX, then a mix of both.
- rleigh 9y agoYes, but can vary much from department to department. A decade back the immunology department I was in gradually switched almost entirely from Windows PCs to Apple Macs. Primarily by people seeing how much nicer and more productive a user-friendly Unix-based system was than Windows; even the die-hards eventually switched over. We also had a large number of Linux/Unix people as well, particularly for bioinformatics, who bought fully maxed out Mac Pros from the G5 onward to do work which required a lot of memory and disc. Back then, they were good value for money. Today, Mac usage is declining. The cost:value isn't there and they don't manufacture any high-end kit. Given how much PC you can buy for the same price as a MacBook, like a 32- or 64-core Threadripper or EPYC with a massive GPU which blows any available Apple hardware away, it's not hard to see why. For computational biology, running Linux on it gives you a much more capable and productive system, and even Windows 10 with the Linux subsystem is perfectly adequate. Apple's mistake has been to focus upon only profitable consumer product lines, and drop the ball entirely on the high end. They didn't sell as many high-end units, but they were the driver for Mac adoption in many places, and without that Mac usage will continue to decline. A mediocre laptop isn't good for a lot of scientific uses.
- moonbug22 9y ago> Apple's mistake has been to focus upon only profitable consumer product lines, Yeah, what idiots.
- rainbowmverse 9y agoIgnoring an entire market is how BlackBerry got clobbered by Apple. They didn't see a consumer device company as a threat. I don't know what vectors of attack there are on Apple from the business and research machine market, but someone is going to figure it out.
- exikyut 9y agoSeems there's no real attack vector; it's just a matter of waiting and doing small tests to see if Apple are completely blind yet, then doing some big thing.
- chaosphere2112 9y agoI can report that the climate scientists I knew mostly worked on macs (laptops, largely; a variety had trash-can Mac Pros as well). Fairly sizable motivator was the Unix CLI; they all had come up working on supercomputers with C/TC Shells, so having that locally was a big win.
- Fomite 9y agoMy lab is pretty much exclusively OSX-based workstations/laptops and Scientific Linux servers.