11 ms·
> Bill Gates' (to name a random American citizen) has a far larger share in the GDP than most other Americans. If you want to solve that raise your taxes on the
by koolba 9y ago
> Bill Gates' (to name a random American citizen) has a far larger share in the GDP than most other Americans. If you want to solve that raise your taxes on the rich and lift up those that are at the lowest end of the scale. That will have a lot more effect than some fiction where you get to do a bunch of make-believe bookkeeping.
Or go a step further do what nobody has the balls to do: tax wealth
That's what all these schemes are really trying to do, albeit in roundabout and inefficient ways. Taxing wealth has it's own complexities (unrealized gains and non-cash assets are the big ones) but it'd be saner than a negative tax (i.e. entitlement) calculated off GDP.
- smeyer 9y ago>do what nobody has the balls to do: tax wealth Just to clarify, nobody in the US is doing this, but it's not unheard of elsewhere. For example, Norway has a wealth tax of about 0.85% and there are some other examples at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_tax#Current_examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_tax#Current_examples .
- khuey 9y agoWe tax real property, which is a form of wealth taxation.
- colanderman 9y agoMunicipalities do, but the federal government does not.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- saas_co_de 9y agoRight. The bank owns 100% of the property. The "owner" is underwater. And the owner pays property tax. So "wealth" taxation is perfectly fine for that situation.
- RivieraKid 9y agoThe drawback of taxing wealth is that it distorts markets, it discourages saving. EDIT: Can't comment ("You're posting too fast, blah blah blah"). Here are some replies to the comments bellow: > It's encouraging people to make their money be productive instead of stashing it under a mattress. When you have money in the bank, you're effectively lending most of it to other people. Your money is "productive", which is encouraged by the interest. > Everything distorts markets. The question is how to distort markets into providing the best outcome. Neutral tax (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimal_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimal_tax) doesn't. But of course, market distortion is not the only or primary factor in policy decision-making.
- cperciva 9y agoIndeed. And saving/investing is important! It's not a coincidence that the industrial revolution happened in a country with a secure established rule of law such that people could make investments without worrying about losing them at the whim of a dictator. Much better to tax consumption.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoTaxing consumption is regressive; as your wealth increases, the amount of dollars spent relative to your wealth continues to decrease.
- cperciva 9y agoIn the long run, every dollar of wealth gets spent. As a practical matter, consumption taxes can be made progressive by combining them with a low-income tax credit or a universal basic income.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> In the long run, every dollar of wealth gets spent. Not necessarily. "Apple (AAPL), Microsoft (MSFT), Alphabet (GOOGL), Cisco Systems (CSCO) and Oracle (ORCL) are sitting on $504 billion, or 30%, of the $1.7 trillion in cash and cash equivalents held by U.S. non-financial companies in 2015, according to an analysis released Friday by ratings agency Moody's Investors Service. That's even more cash concentration than in previous years, as these five companies held 27% of cash in 2014 and 25% in 2013. Apple alone is holding more cash and investments than eight of the 10 entire industry sectors." [1] Also, the top 1 percent owns 90 percent of wealth in the US [2]. "First, economic inequality has worsened significantly in the United States and some other countries. The richest 1 percent in the United States now own more wealth than the bottom 90 percent. Oxfam estimates that the richest 85 people in the world own as much wealth as the bottom half of humanity. The situation might be tolerable if a rising tide were lifting all boats. But it’s lifting mostly the yachts. In 2010, 93 percent of the additional income created in America went to the top 1 percent." > As a practical matter, consumption taxes can be made progressive by combining them with a low-income tax credit or a universal basic income. I agree that a consumption tax can be combined with other policy to prevent the regressive nature of a consumption tax alone. This requires wealth be taxed in various forms (ownership of investments, land, etc). [1] https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/markets/2016/05/20/third-cash-owned-5-us-companies/84640704/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/markets/2016/05/20/thir... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/24/opinion/nicholas-kristof-idiots-guide-to-inequality-piketty-capital.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/24/opinion/nicholas-kristof-...
- nickoakland 9y agoMany top corporate executives in Norway & Sweden will evade this by "living" in Switzerland for >183 days a year.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cjlars 9y agoInflation is not deductible, so the US (and most other countries) have defacto wealth taxes to the tune of INFLATION RATE * CAPITAL GAINS TAX RATE, or roughly 0.48% annually to high earners in the USA.
- beebmam 9y agoWithout a doubt, a global wealth tax would significantly improve the quality of life for every human on this planet; even those with the large amounts of wealth being taxed.
- jrs95 9y agoI'd be fine with a wealth tax on a national level with restrictions on offshoring cash, but I don't want to steal wealth from everyone in the west to distribute it globally. You'd also have a very difficult time getting nations like China to agree to something like this. Edit: sorry, wasn't aware of the exact definition of this. Having everyone pass this sort of thing is a great idea imo.
- addicted 9y agoA global wealth tax does not distribute the tax globally. It just means that every nation collects a wealth tax. This is to prevent a race to the bottom which would penalize the first countries that enacted a wealth tax.
- duderific 9y agoOnly if the tax revenues are spent wisely. In the US, some 42% - 57% of the tax base goes to defense spending [1]. It's extremely arguable if that is a good way to spend such a large quantity of tax dollars. One could argue "we should elect representatives who make better spending decisions," however the defense lobby makes sure to get involved with all lawmakers. Once again it comes back to campaign finance reform as the necessary first step to straighten out the political system.
- bensonn 9y agoJust to clarify, it is 42-57% of discretionary. When compared to non-discretionary spending like Social Security defense spending is pretty small.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe estate tax is a tax on wealth.
- dllthomas 9y agoOnly for mortals.
- TimPC 9y agoIt's actually a tax on wealth transfer, and it has far more favorable terms than tranferring wealth above gift limits while still living. In some sense, the entire estate process is a massive loophole that allows wealth transfer without realizing any income, but a fairly understandable one given the nature of family relationships.
- dv_dt 9y agoWe do tax wealth in a very limited way in the form of real estate property taxes. Though I would note that it hits the middle class and poor more disproportionately than the extremely wealthy. And I'd note that the tax cuts in front of congress propose making that scheme land even harder on the middle class by eliminating or curtailing the state/local tax (including property tax) exemptions from federal taxes.
- benmanns 9y agoCapital gains tax + inflation is a wealth tax. Each year you have to grow your money by inflation for it to maintain buying power. 2% inflation * 20% top rate LTCG tax means the wealthy pay a deferred 0.4% wealth tax yearly.
- dv_dt 9y agoThat's sort of true, but I'm not sure if that the inflation effects are truly a "tax on wealth". Inflation is a tax on everybody, holding a wide range of assets in that sense. Also because it's driven by inflation, those proceeds to the government are also just growth of proceeds needed to buffer against inflation in the goods that government purchases. Edit: Thinking about it a bit more. Inflation would also tend to drive up the numerical profits of companies, which will tend to buffer a stock price for example. So I'm not sure how this inflation independently contributes much of a specific tax on the wealth.
- bcoates 9y agoIt's not a matter of balls, it's a matter of understanding that the most important part of tax policy is compliance, that is actually collecting the taxes. Even our current methods of evaluating quantities and distribution of wealth are vague estimates, and that's without people incentivized by taxation to hide or minimize it. A wealth tax that turns into anything but a buildings-and-cars tax is a fantasy from an enforcement perspective, and significant property taxes have issues of their own.
- SimbaOnSteroids 9y agoThere is an option for enforcement you're not realizing here, called the Commodore Mathew Perry method, it goes like this. --Location: Tax Havens-- >Knock Knock Its the United States With huge boats, with guns, gunboats. >Open your banks' records, stop having them be closed and theres not much they can do about. So they sign a treaty making sure their banks' records are not closed. -------------------------------------------------------------- Inspired by this, both historically and in delivery https://youtu.be/Mh5LY4Mz15o?t=4m46s https://youtu.be/Mh5LY4Mz15o?t=4m46s
- Balero 9y agoAre you suggesting the USA does this to tax havens like Ireland, The Netherlands and The City of London? Is it not a thing for startups to be based out of Delaware for a tax advantage? Would the ships even have to leave the harbor to do this?
- rdl 9y agoThere is basically no tax advantage for startups in being based in Delaware -- you end up registering as a "foreign corporation" and paying in-state taxes whenever you're actually located. Delaware is chosen because of the body of corporate law and efficient secretary of state.
- matco11 9y agoYep. 100%. ...and it does not apply only to startups but also to large corporations
- derefr 9y agoFrom the perspective of trying to get the budget balanced, taxing wealth is probably the single most efficient way to do it. From the perspective of the tax code as an incentive system, taxing wealth is a strange thing—it makes people feel less interest in becoming wealthy, and thereby causes fewer GDP-building things to happen! (This is also, for a similar reason, why economists don't like corporate taxes or trade tariffs: they disincentivize exactly the things that help the economy the most.) Economists are usually more in favor of a land-value tax, because it punishes people for something that doesn't build GDP (investing their wealth into property and then sitting on it as it appreciates), and encourages them to instead do things that do build GDP (like investing their wealth into companies.) A land-value tax is still essentially a luxury tax, but it doesn't have the same problem of unilaterally discouraging GDP creation that taxing wealth does.
- JonFish85 9y ago> From the perspective of trying to get the budget balanced, taxing wealth is probably the single most efficient way to do it. Why? As a total layman, wouldn't it be incredibly inefficient? If we tax the wealth of, say, the top 100 richest Americans, wouldn't that cause some pretty terrible downsides? If we force them to sell their holdings, wouldn't that ripple through the economy? Take Jeff Bezos--if you forced him to sell a significant portion of his stock, wouldn't that depress the Amazon stock price, which affects a significant number of other individuals and businesses?
- megaman22 9y agoThe problem is that eventually you run out of other people's money.
- beat 9y agoOnly if they have a fixed, non-growing amount. Which isn't ever the case.
- cryptonector 9y ago
- WalterBright 9y agoIt'd be better to tax things we don't want, like pollution.
- dredmorbius 9y agoMassive inequality is among the things we really shouldn't want. Massive rent-seeking, enclosures, network effects, and benefiting by public infrastructure and institutions, without paying back full costs, or by imposing dislocations on other economic sectors, as well. Aviation accounts for 6% of transportation fuel use. For a small portion of passenger and minuscule fraction of cargo movement.
- edbaskerville 9y agoI like the idea of a wealth tax. The details will be difficult: how do you assess wealth with any semblance of accuracy, especially in the face of an increased incentive to hide it? I'd love to hear anybody's clever ideas to tax wealth in a way that catches cheaters. The biggest issue is what you do with wealth held overseas. But even if the cost of catching cheaters is many billions of dollars of enforcement apparatus, it seems worth it. Of course, you create a new problem: avoiding corruption in a large enforcement apparatus chasing after people with the resources to easily bribe them. (But this problem is not unique to wealth taxes, and I don't think bribing the IRS is actually much of a problem—people just bribe Congress.) There's another problem: wealth taxes would probably need a constitutional amendment in the U.S. From Article I, Section 2: "Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers..." There's already an amendment to clarify that federal income taxes are OK. But wealth taxes will need their own amendment. Conceptually, though, I totally agree: if the problem is unequal wealth, just redistribute the wealth directly to move toward a less catastrophe-prone distribution.
- rdtsc 9y ago> Or go a step further do what nobody has the balls to do: tax wealth Heard of this before. Have there been any attempts of that before and how did it fare? It would seem to be as soon as wealth is taxed, wealth will morph or change shape to avoid being taxed. We'd end up with some new arcane tax scheme where wealth is held in a tropical island nation and the owner of the wealth gets a stipend or I don't know, rents all their possessions from that entity.
- pnathan 9y agoI'm persuaded that wealth taxes and maximum income are the appropriate solution: after X million per year, you don't get more money, and after you and your family heap up Y million of _fluidly defined_ assets, you get taxed on what you hold/control/manage-via-tax-shelter. Obliterate the tax shelters, obliterate the tax havens, bring the money back home under threat of criminal law. I'm not saying you can't be a fat cat. But at a certain point (fluid and blurry, but distinctly present), it's just morbid obesity that is squishing other citizens.
- free_everybody 9y agoHow can you implement such a practice when our politicians and leaders are fat cats (or aspiring fat cats)? Only vote for people below a certain wealth line?
- pnathan 9y agoThrowing politicians out of office who don't do it and promoting a stigma around vast amounts of wealth will change things. Elections matter.
- bensonn 9y agoEverybody tends to put that certain point above where they are at. I realize, as limited to a US discussion, it is easy to say Bezos and Gates are rich, I am not. But if this was expanded, simply as a thought experiment, to the entire world would you be fine classified as a "fat cat"? Assuming (perhaps incorrectly) you are in the US, you are also reading Hacker News, so you are probably the top 1% of the worlds wealthiest. Again, just a thought experiment, but would you be fine with your government saying that as a 1 percenter in world wealth you can no longer earn anymore, you have hit that certain point, are a fat cat and can grow no more wealth, under threat of criminal law?
- smallnamespace 9y agoThis sort of logic is also why it's hard to get this sort of legislation passed nowadays. Media has done a good job of raising awareness of the problems of wealth disparity, and a lot of people nod along. But no matter how wealthy someone is, they can always point to the more-rich and say those people are the problem and should be taxed, not themselves.
- gumby 9y ago> Or go a step further do what nobody has the balls to do: tax wealth "Nobody?" Other countries manage it.
- dredmorbius 9y agoAny examples offhand?
- gumby 9y agoWell France is the most famous example, but several other European countries (e.g. Spain and Switzerland in my experience) do too, as well as some in South America. Hmm just checked the Wikipedia and it says that Donald Trump proposed it for the US as well.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThanks.