5 ms·
I have no doubt that we as a species today would still happily line up for this kind of awesomely stupid spectacle, most of us with our smartphones out. The dif
by danso 9y ago
I have no doubt that we as a species today would still happily line up for this kind of awesomely stupid spectacle, most of us with our smartphones out. The difference from 1896 is we have enough regulations to prevent such a thing.
Another fun detail from the event's aftermath that likely wouldn't happen today:
> Crush was immediately fired from the Katy railroad. In light of a lack of negative publicity, however, he was rehired the next day.
edit: the Wikipedia entry has some nice footnote/sources. I didn't read them all but the one from wacohistory.org has even more interesting details:
http://www.wacohistory.org/items/show/70 http://www.wacohistory.org/items/show/70
I think I'll bookmark this article for the times when people complain about how much dumber and shallower we are compared to folks from the olden days:
> Two people died and at least six other people were seriously injured by flying debris, including a Waco photojournalist, Jarvis Deane, who lost an eye. While the railway moved in quickly to remove the larger wreckage, souvenir hunters swarmed over the site, carrying off most of the remains despite burning their hands on the shrapnel.
- Ma8ee 9y agoSome people creates this kind of spectacles themselves: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6V0S1m5a7U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6V0S1m5a7U
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>I have no doubt that we as a species today would still happily line up for this kind of awesomely stupid spectacle, most of us with our smartphones out. The difference from 1896 is we have enough regulations to prevent such a thing. Stop being such a ConcernedMother(TM) A good rule of thumb I like to use is replace "safety" and "terrorism" with each other and see if the argument still holds water. Most of the time it's just hoopla and people getting exited over things they don't understand or can't be bothered to reason out. It usually holds water like a net. There's no reason you can't crash trains safely. If anything we should be doing more crazy stuff because we can plan it out more accurately today than they could back then. We can disassembly building surrounded by other buildings using explosives and air-lift robots on other planets. The reason it didn't work in 1896 but does in 2017 is because they weren't as accurate at figuring out the safe distance and the safety factors were lower back then. Run the numbers beforehand (which you couldn't do nearly as well in 1896), put the crowd a safe distance times some safety factor away and let the trains go. >I think I'll bookmark this article for the times when people complain about how much dumber and shallower we are compared to folks from the olden days: I'll bookmark this comment for the next time I need an example of someone killing the fun "because safety" when they really mean "because I'm too lazy to figure out how to do it safely" ;)
- danso 9y agoYes, it's possible to crash trains and demolish things safely; no shit, Sherlock. The difficulty is doing it in front of 40,000 people close enough to get a great view of it, in the middle of no where.
- cat199 9y agoever been to an airshow? yeah..
- danso 9y agoI've seen a few from a distance so I'm not an expert. Which modern airshows feature plans that crash or explode intentionally near the audience?
- Tomte 9y agoYou know about the strict restrictions to air shows imposed after Ramstein? Planes are not flying over masses anymore. Acrobatics are never performed towards the masses. Etc. etc.
- kirykl 9y ago> ...stupid spectacle...The difference from 1896 is we have enough regulations to prevent such a thing. I dunno exploding buildings by carefully planning an inward safe collapse is both regulated and celebrated as entertainment
- danso 9y agoSure, but I don’t think you give enough credit to the senseless spectacle that Crush, Texas seems to have been. Blowing up a building is entertaining but it is also (usually) useful and necessary. A more accurate analogy would be building a respectable, expensive structure and then blowing it up for the hell of it. But that doesn’t capture the fundamental chaos of the Crush, TX. Even if the standard of physics education was much lower back then than it is today, I would have to think that people knew the result of slamming trains together would have an amount of pure chaos and risk. And of course they went out en masse to see it!
- kirykl 9y agoIts definitely a senseless tragedy for those injured and killed, as it would be today. I agree there's risk involved when there's a an audience for such an event. But necessity or foolishness of an explosion doesn't really negate the ability to perform it both safely and for entertainment. But the modern equivalent of say crashing two high speed trains in front of an audience? would probably not occur due to insurance reasons
- coding123 9y agoWhat I find interesting is they didnt really know if 2 or 3 people died, so I do question if the people of that time thought it was a tragedy or just didn't care about the aftermath as much as we'd think.
- alanbernstein 9y agoThe aggie bonfire was only put to an end relatively recently, and we still have burning man.
- 9y ago
- indubitable 9y agoRegulations are extremely useful in things like building integrity codes (quake tolerance/etc) but that's because in these cases they serve a useful purpose in preventing exploitative behavior. It's not easy for a regular person to tell the difference between a building that could stand for centuries and one who's foundation is ready to tumble if somebody sneezes too hard. And the latter is vastly cheaper to build - so there's a major incentive to exploit people in a way they could not be reasonable expected to appreciate. But in this case, why are regulations actually necessary? It's quite self evident that going to go see two trains collide is not exactly the safest activity. But so long as the consumer understands this, I see little difference between this and something like the Running of the Bulls or even independent activities like wingsuiting. One of the most bizarrely entertaining experiences I had was in the developing world. At a festival there was a large wooden tube that was several stories tall. Looking at it top down it'd look like a donut. The outer ring was a ramp that circled all the way to the top with intermittent standing room facing the inner ring. The inner circle was mostly solid excepting these openings. So what was it? A small door opened at the bottom a motorcycle came out and started driving around the inner tube climbing all the way to the top of the building before zooming back down and zipping all around. And he'd drive with one hand grabbing tips people would hold with their hands on the various levels with his other hand. And the 2, 3, and 4 more motorcycles came out and all were driving around the building doing the same thing. And then finally a truck came out of the bottom and started driving up the building as well. About that time the building was violently rocking. Absolutely insane, but absolutely fun. Everybody in there had a ton of fun at a moderate amount of risk - and I cannot imagine how much money those drivers were making in tips alone. Certainly the equivalent of thousands of USD for a night's work. The only thing I thought was "Never in a million years would this be allowed in the US" and it's an experience I'll fondly recall til the day I die. I remember seeing something remotely similar at a circus when I was young. Except it was done inside an isolated steel ring in the center of a stadium with everybody seated about 20 meters away at the minimum -- that was.. cute. And I think that's kind of a shame. Who in the world is the government to not allow people to engage in risk taking behavior so long as the risk is mutually appreciated? If anything, I'd be okay if there was a requirement of all participants and observers having sufficient commercial medical coverage such that in the case of an accident the victims would not be a burden on the rest of society.
- danbruc 9y agoNot quite the same but I would really be interested in witnessing an atmospheric nuclear explosion. Why? Simply to get an idea of the actual scale because I think that is something that is impossible to grasp without actually experiencing it in person.
- triangleman 9y agoApparently this was possible some 60 years ago. A recent PBS documentary[1] noted that "atomic tourism" to Las Vegas was great enough that Nevada Senators were repeatedly lobbying against a ban on atmospheric testing in the 50's. [1] http://www.vegaspbs.org/the-test/ http://www.vegaspbs.org/the-test/
- criddell 9y agoLas Vegas has The National Atomic Testing Museum and it's worth a visit: http://nationalatomictestingmuseum.org/ http://nationalatomictestingmuseum.org/
- stickfigure 9y agoOh, this kind of thing definitely still happens today. Just not in the US. There's this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Pyrotechnic_Festival https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Pyrotechnic_Festival I've been twice. The climax of the event involves pushing three-meter paper-mache bulls through crowds of tens of thousands of drunk people, all the while shooting out rockets and other not-even-remotely-safe-or-sane fireworks in what looks like a cluster bomb explosion. I saw dozens of people get seriously injured... and they come back every year. Personally, I could do without some of the regulations. It's liberating to go someplace that doesn't feel toddler-proofed.
- danso 9y ago> It's liberating to go someplace that doesn't feel toddler-proofed. Agree that America feels "toddler-proofed" relative to developing nations. However, I had a great experience at St. Louis's City Museum. Even if the experience may be relatively tame to what you can find overseas, it was still astonishing to me that such a place of interest existed in America with so few safeguards. Here's a great WSJ article about the thrills and trials of the City Museum: http://web.archive.org/web/20150612052257/https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304159304575183463721620890 http://web.archive.org/web/20150612052257/https://www.wsj.co...
- komali2 9y agoThat festival's fun as hell, but yea there's a major culture difference there, not just governmental. What shocked me was when they still did it the same year as the Formosa Fun Cost explosion [1], seems the Taiwanese bounce back pretty well. [1](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formosa_Fun_Coast_explosion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formosa_Fun_Coast_explosion)
- Retric 9y agoPeople just really like fire. A friend described how they accidentally created a fuel air explosion, at the Tag fall cave in when lighting the bonfire, strong enough to knock over the front row the the crowd. Nobody was seriously hurt, and peoples general reactions was they thought this was intentional and where disappointed it was not repeated next year...