4 ms·
We should expect that hiring science improves over time if, in fact, the difference between the top talent and 2nd-tier talent really matters that much to firm
by threatofrain 9y ago
We should expect that hiring science improves over time if, in fact, the difference between the top talent and 2nd-tier talent really matters that much to firm success.
And if tests, school performance, college aspirations are interesting things, then we should continue to improve our pedagogical craft, and we should continue encouraging youth to pursue college, as opposed to dropout. Not everyone can benefit from the Peter Thiel method. Examination has its bad parts, such as deviance from ground facts, but the lack of examination is even less grounded in empiricism. That is surely where dishonest thrives best, where wishy washy arguments dominate.
We discuss competency because meritocracy is a counterbalance to nepotism, and meritocracy has a really nasty edge to it even if performed ideally. We often talk about how meritocracy could be done better, as implied when we criticize instruments such as tests, but even an ideal meritocracy retains a very harsh edge to it -- it bears moral judgment on the incompetent.
Also buried underneath in implication is the idea that there's a sizable group of intellectuals who are stomped on by school, and they have Facebook in the garage potential (but not Elon Musk potential).
I might suggest that processes that produce Elon Musks and Steve Jobs are mysterious, and criticizing education in favor of throwing thousands of kids into a black box creative process, hoping that Elon Musks and Steve Jobs come out, is a thinking even more cruel than unrestrained meritocracy.
Our system would have been elite in a historical perspective, basically offering calculus in high school to just about any child in the US if they could take it. In today's terms, it's not so obvious why the American employee is that much better than a British or German engineer. Or at the university level, why an American student would be that much better. If anything, Americans have been routinely trounced on international math competitions.
Rather than diminishing our education system in favor of black box hopes for more Steve Jobs (How many thousands of kids does it take to make a Steve Jobs? How many Steve Jobs are there per Apples?), I would hope we identify and improve gaps in education, and not throw out the art of examination.