11 ms·
A Public Option for Food
- thisisit 9y ago> That’s because I tend to think that when a service is for profit rather than for the public’s benefit, all sorts of perverse incentives arise. If schools operated for profit, with education subsidized by vouchers, the companies running the schools would have an interest in spending as little as possible actually educating the students, because every dollar they could save would be a dollar they could keep. The problem with this kind of argument is that it forgets the incentive of a government run or public's benefit is that they too have a different metric to adhere to - politics. They then lead to a cumbersome system with nearly zero responsibility. This then gets picked up by people on the opposite side of the fence as failures of public benefit, government run system. So, unfortunately things have to seen on a case to case basis. Public benefit schooling is a great thing. But public benefit food option? That is debatable. For some it will come off "government controlling what we eat" and hurting fundamental rights.
- bmcusick 9y agoMy friend, have you heard the good news about Public Choice Theory?
- thisisit 9y agoNot really. Please enlighten me.
- undersuit 9y agoFrom the article, I find it funny that the article actually loops around later to counter your cherry picked quote and argument from the first paragraph. >There is a tacit acceptance of the basic idea of “public choice theory”: that state actors are just as much selfish maximizers as anyone else, and that the only difference between the state and a corporation is that the state doesn’t have to be as accountable to its consumers.
- sandworm101 9y ago>>> because every dollar they could save would be a dollar they could keep. Which is why they shouldn't operate as corporations. They can still be "for-profit" but under a different corporate scheme. Make all the kids/parents shareholders/members in the association and keep those profits internal.
- kiliantics 9y agoSo a cooperative model? I like that. I think pretty much everything would be better off and we would all benefit more if our institutions were structured as worker-owner and worker-consumer cooperatives.
- clagio 9y agoAlso public school can be seen as "government controlling what we learn". Private and public have two different metric indeed, one is profit and one is politics. None of them is perfect, but I think one of the two is better especially if talk about food/health of the population.
- m00g00 9y agoThere is such a thing as non-profit organizations. And businesses will generally reinvest profits into the company themselves as the ROI is seen as higher than just accrued interest. If the private school really has no interest in investing in the school itself instead just pocketing money, I think they will find they soon have no money left because parents have pulled their kids from a failing school with a bad reputation. On the other hand, no matter how poor a public school is, it will always continue to get money, because the law demands people pay for it whether they send their kids there or not. So there's no incentive to improve, or fix management, because there's no real risk. The inability to let failure happen combined with legally sanction monopoly is a big problem with some public institutions.
- jnordwick 9y agoMarkets are incredibly good at giving people what they want, not what they say they want, but what they actually want (economists call this revealed preference). Some people, like the author, see this as a problem. He had no viable solution to the problem. We have actually tried to the "free healthy alternative" in schools, and what happens is either the healthy parts are thrown away or traded away.
- AnthonBerg 9y agoIs lung cancer from smoking a revealed preference?
- alexanderstears 9y agoSmoking is a revealed preference, lung cancer is a consequence but any person who buys and smokes cigarettes reveals their decision that the expected value of lung cancer is smaller than the expected value of smoking.
- Frondo 9y agoWait a minute...traded away? So somebody does want them?
- Retric 9y agoSchools with health breakfast and lunch options are strongly correlated with academic success. It's actually one of the most efficient uses of school funding even if many students don't partake the difference is staggering. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/brown-center-chalkboard/2017/05/03/how-the-quality-of-school-lunch-affects-students-academic-performance/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/brown-center-chalkboard/2017/...
- alexanderstears 9y agoLet's make sure that people have the choice for healthy food but it'd be idiotic to spend an iota of effort trying to get people to eat things they don't want to eat.
- 9y ago
- canjobear 9y agoAlso check out the interesting response from Slate Star Codex. http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/11/21/contra-robinson-on-public-food/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/11/21/contra-robinson-on-publ...
- zeveb 9y agoWow, that article is excellent, and says everything I could have said, but better. Highly worth a read.
- pjc50 9y agoThe argument seems to be that "government can also be bad" and that "food industry is distorted by subsidies". Which is valid as far as it goes. Getting to choose your own food and housing? Great, far better than being allocated by the government. Getting to choose your own healthcare and education? Do you really have enough information to make an informed choice there? Are people who are unconscious or under 5 really good at being informed consumers? Or are they just having the decisions made for them by someone else? Not getting any food or housing because you can't afford it? State option starts to look really great.
- mrob 9y ago>Every town has an American Free Diner in it. The music is great and there’s a buzzing neon sign. I think that latter sentence is telling. No music is "great" to everybody. In some cases any music at all may make the diner unusable, eg. for autistic people with sensory processing difficulties. The author appears not to have considered this. Centralized food provision will necessarily reduce choice, and reduced choice will harm many people. Of course capitalism isn't perfect either, for all the reasons described, but it makes more sense to address specific market failures with regulation than replace the whole system. Eg. I don't see why corporations should be considered people with free speech rights, so I'd support heavy restrictions on advertising.
- orblivion 9y ago> I think that latter sentence is telling. No music is "great" to everybody. I'm imagining the same people who run the DMV choosing the very best in royalty-free elevator music.
- addicted 9y agoI don’t necessarily agree with the article or the solutions proposed (and definitely not the subhead that free markets are a disaster) but your comment actually nearly illustrates why we need to address basic needs (health, food, shelter) differently from other stuff. Because while you are right about music, any food is almost always better than no food, unlike the music scenario.
- mattmanser 9y agoThat's a big jump from a tiny percentage to "many". How many autistic people with sensory problems would even attend a general populace diner and not their own state run diner attached to their adult care home? I think you should put aside your music objection. Of course, the NHS, which he used as an example, accommodates a wide range of people. I'm sure as they'd be so many diners needed they'd have rooms available without the music you've latched on to. I would imagine in the UK you might have one room on radio 1, another on radio 2, some silent, etc. While I doubt it would ever happen I'm pretty certain he's right that this would help far, far more people than it would hurt. And, bonus, if they don't like it they can go buy their own groceries and cook.
- golergka 9y ago> Americans live on junk food; they have terrible diets, with too much sodium, too many calories, too much sugar, and too few fruits and vegetables. Yes. That happens because they are able to execute their own free will and choose for themselves - and of course, most people are easily manipulated and choose poorly. But here lies the fundamental difference between "left" and "right" positions. "Left" tends to optimize for the best utilitarian value from some objective, authoritative point of view (like how good a person diet's is) and would favor a situation where a well-intended authority would choose what's best for the people. Meanwhile, the "right"-wing objective is to optimize a person's individual freedom - which, of course, usually leads to most people making poor choices and having less total utilitarian happiness. Which of those values we should optimize for, and what is the best compromise is a complicated question that lies at the basis of a lot of modern political debates. In this particular comment I'm not trying to take any sides. But why am I talking about it at all then? Because it seems surprising to me how people on the "left" side of such arguments naively assume that we all want to optimize for the same total utilitarian value, completely disregarding that the other side tries to optimize for a different metric.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pwinnski 9y agoPhrased this way, it starts to sound like an ML problem. Optimize based on a cost function, now what cost function do we use? Having people choose to maximize happiness seems to be leading to worse outcomes by many objective standards. The monetary costs are high for the society in aggregate (and the externalities are not distributed according to the costs), health outcomes seem to be getting worse even to the extreme of lowering life expectancy, and so on. Purely seeking individual happiness seems like the wrong cost function based on that. Of course, focusing only on economic cost to society would be even worse, and health outcomes tend to be based in large part on individual happiness. I guess I'm saying that as you've characterized things, you make it sound like the "right" position is the correct one, but there seem to be a lot of things about that position that aren't so great. To be fair, you said "less total utilitarian happiness," but I thought it might help to give examples.
- Doji 9y ago> Food companies such as Procter and Gamble, Kraft, and Campbell Soup were also curious about Lands’s work and invited him to give presentations. “But they didn’t want to touch the idea that they might be selling foods that were harmful to people with a ten-foot pole,” says Lands. “Bill, we sell foods that people ask for,” Lands recalls one executive explaining. “We don’t tell the people what to eat. If you convince the public that our food should have a different balance, we’ll change it.” - The Queen of Fats by Susan Allport Corporations are not guilt free in this mess, but they are not the root of the problem. The high carb, high omega 6 guidelines that have caused our health crisis were instituted in haste and ignorance by the government. The government corn subsidies have distorted the market and make junk processed corn products cheaper than healthy food. Guidelines to reduce saturated fat and cholesterol have caused people to move to industrial seed oils, causing a overconsumption of omega6 fatty acids and consequential inflammatory disease. Corporations have simply provided what we have asked for. The author of this argument is ignorant of the real causes of disease and chooses to blame cheese and salt for our problems. I'm much happier with corporations and the ability to make my own, well informed health choices than government interference.
- waynecochran 9y agoYes. Government guidelines are bogus. The article actually scares me a little bit, that people think the gov't should be deciding what the individual should do. That is not America and I hope it never is.
- kiliantics 9y agoPlease. You really think the government hasn't decided anything in your life? The very infrastructure of the USA and why it is an oil-guzzling, car-crazy country is thanks to government design. The ghettoisation of urban neighbourhoods, resulting in poor education and high crime rates came about thanks to government legislation. Unless you have a very comfortable income so you can buy your way into a relatively "government-safe" situation (which is made available to the rich thanks to more government intervention btw), then you are very much at the whim of the government (or powerful corporations, which are essentially the same thing) for much of your basic day-to-day operations.
- js8 9y agoI think both options together are good. Both capitalist and government-planned economies have inefficiencies, but at different areas. If you have some service provided by government, then it's sometimes inefficient. These inefficiencies can only be reduced by better governance, i.e. people actually getting involved politically and forcing the management to straighten it out. If you have some service provided by only private companies for profits, then perhaps the production is efficient, but this efficiency can become lost for the end customer in the form of profits. In theory, this shouldn't happen due to competition but in practice it happens a lot (almost no private company operates at marginal costs). So if you have a choice of both options, in theory you should get optimal results. In practice, it is difficult for societies to keep both options, for reasons: 1. If the public option is too good (too efficient), no private companies want to compete (no profit). For example, look at some state-owned European companies, such as Swiss post or railways. 2. If the private option is too good (only decent profit), then there is no reason to have the public option. People want to avoid governance, if possible. The people who pay for private option will question if they actually need to fund the public option from taxes if the private ones are comparably good. So I think the big problem is that system with both (the best one) is unstable.
- fvdessen 9y agoWorst case scenario is that the private's solution is too good and the state thus regulates the private competition to be as bad as the public.
- js8 9y agoDo you have some examples? I can only see the obvious extreme example of communism, which forbade private competition at all. But I am not clear who (which party) would push for such a regulation. The benefit to the public is obviously bad, and the private industry would certainly oppose it.
- timthelion 9y agoI have the opposite example. In the Czech Republic, the national railway was sued by the private railways for being too cheep. And the private railways won in court!
- zeveb 9y ago> That’s because I tend to think that when a service is for profit rather than for the public’s benefit, all sorts of perverse incentives arise. If schools operated for profit, with education subsidized by vouchers, the companies running the schools would have an interest in spending as little as possible actually educating the students, because every dollar they could save would be a dollar they could keep. That strikes me as dangerous, and I can’t help but think that it will lead inexorably in the direction of giving children iPads rather than teachers. The trouble with a public system is that all sorts of perverse incentives arise. Civil servants' unions have an interest in maximising benefits to their members, and in the U.S. they spend their dues (taken, ultimately, from the taxpayer) to lobby politicians to increase their members' benefits (taken, ultimately, from the taxpayer). A public system mandates that everyone contribute, regardless of his or her beliefs: in Tennessee an atheist might be forced to spend on a school which teaches creationism, while in San Francisco a theist might be forced to spend on a school which teaches that there is no God. There would be similar problems with a 'public food option.' The author notes 'I could give you a dozen people who could run a nutritious, delicious, and decidedly non-dreary nonprofit diner given a sufficient budget': what would prevent those dozen people from each building their own little empires on the taxpayers' dime? Who is to determine what is a sufficient but not exorbitant level of non-dreariness? Is it okay for the Free American Diner to serve meat? Non-kosher food? None of this is to say that private firms don't also have perverse incentives: he's right, they do. But I think that the answer is generally to try to fix that (e.g. by regulation) rather than to go public. At least with competing firms one might have a choice: with a public option, only the very wealthy can opt out.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI imagine this author has never been to a soup kitchen. One experience with your typical soup kitchen should cure anyone of the notion that this is a good idea. The food is appalling. The service is terrible. If your stuff gets stolen while you eat because they insisted you leave it elsewhere, not their problem. They assume they know what is best for you, never mind they have no idea what your diagnosis is and no idea about the doctor ordered dietary restrictions that go with it. So the assumption is both flat out wrong and monstrously insulting. I would literally rather fast for a day or so than ever go back to a soup kitchen. That is not hyperbole. I have made that exact choice on a number of occasions while dirt poor.
- jbarciauskas 9y agoLike any government program, or anything really, it could be operated well or poorly. We can examine what about the proposal might make it hard to implement properly, such as the wide variety of dietary restrictions as well as peoples' personal tastes and the fact that food for many people is a central part of their family and culture. Maybe that means such a program should focus more on the raw ingredients than delivering prepared food. I'm not sure because some soup kitchens are bad, we should discount all publicly funded food. For one, it does in fact feed lots of people today via free school lunch programs.
- fvdessen 9y agoThe difference is that when a private program is run badly, it goes bankrupt and is closed. When a public program is run badly, it keeps going on forever.
- jbarciauskas 9y agoI think this is a bit naive. Badly run corporations find ways to keep themselves alive, it's not like owners and shareholders look at a bad situation and just say "Oh well, we tried" and go home. I think there's a strong case to be made that shareholders should be much more willing to just close up shop and cut their losses when the world changes around them, but that's not how people work.
- PatientTrades 9y ago> I went to a public school. I enjoyed myself there. I believe it taught me some things. My mom switched me from public to private school in elementary school. Without a doubt the quality of the private schools' facilities, teachers, staff, and education were much better then the public school. I ended being held back in the 3rd grade simply because I was so far behind my other classmates in terms of knowledge that was not stressed at the public school. Yes, private school can be expensive, but if you have the resources and can find a good school with a track record of success, I highly recommend enrolling your kids in a private school.
- madsbuch 9y agoCome to a Scandinavian public school. Then you'll see working public schools. Evidently, this has nothing to do with publicness or privateness, but rather a culture. The big question is: in what direction should we push the society?
- chiefalchemist 9y ago> "Then I remembered that nutrition in America is a total disaster, that ⅔ of the country is obese or overweight, and that half of the country either has diabetes or is at high risk of having diabetes soon. If we start providing education like we provide nutrition, then God help the little children…" The irony here is (pardon the hyperbole) literally deadly. If we're going to prevent obesity then more people need to be educated on the causes. In many (read: all) of the non-medical condition based cases, the individual is their own best enemy. There is nothing more choice based than what you put in your mouth. No doubt, there's room for improvement in the food system. But I've seen people with choices consistently choose badly. To blame the system is blaming a symptom.
- mattmanser 9y agoThis is discussed extensively in the article, and is in fact the main argument of the article. The thrust of his argument is that capitalism forces companies to play to biological triggers that are bad for us, and to play them hard. And then use psychological tricks to make you feel ok for falling for them, even though you logically know you shouldn't. If they don't their competitors will. So the system is deliberately exerting pressure to become obese, it's not a symptom, it's a direct cause. He even uses examples of how Brazil and other countries have been targeted deliberately by companies selling sugar and salt and have suddenly developed obesity problems, after US companies ran around giving away desserts and other sugar laden food. I would re-read the article and pay attention to the parts about Coke, Raisin Bran and Minute Maid juice, plus him discussing Brazil, if you missed the arguments.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoYes. I got all that. I see it everyday. My point is that when we've reached a point where it's acceptable to blame anything but ourselves for what we buy at the supermarket...for what we put in our mouths...then we are in very bad shape. Fixing the system isn't going to fix The Problem. The lack of self responsibility will only manifest itself elsewhere. Put another way, in the bigger scheme of things, we can't keep complaining about the power of the overseers (i.e., the 1% et al) and make every solution one that champions the Nanny State.
- peatmoss 9y ago> We don’t have government-run grocery stores like we have government-run schools. And yet most people in the country seem pretty happy with their grocery stores. They can get whatever they want there, and if they can’t afford it, we subsidize it with a “voucher” (i.e. food stamps). The profit motive hasn’t led to a rapacious system of exploitation. This isn’t strictly true for poorer areas. Grocery stores that have a predominately captive clientele (i.e. can’t afford to drive long distances and have big kitchens to store bulk purchases from discount big box stores) do tend to charge more for the same goods than stores in more affluent / mobile areas.
- kiliantics 9y agoAs a European that has moved to the USA, I find these "food deserts" here appalling. In order to have access to local, fresh, quality ingredients, you need to be in an outrageously high income bracket. There is absolutely a food supply problem.
- adamwong246 9y agoSoylent- the UBI of nutrition! Soylent distribution machines in every school and prison cafeteria, on street corners, any place where food scarcity exists. Each has a single button which dispenses a soylent, free of charge. No limits, no strings. All the soylent you can carry! Do away with food stamps- send 150 bottles of soylent a month, by mail, to any human being who can ask for it.
- geodel 9y agoMoreover to reassure people it will be completely optional once they have consumed their first four bottles for the day.
- twoquestions 9y agoOne thing I was talking about with some other people is to have a community kitchen. You could buy prepared food, or if you have more time than money you could buy the ingredients sold there and make it yourself in the kitchen. This could be really great for people that lack a kitchen (like college students) or for people who weren't taught how to cook. The major problem with this is who's responsible for cleanup, and how would we divide labor for this place. What do y'all think?
- pythonaut_16 9y agoI have had similar thoughts. Also just an option for people who don't have families or live far from their families (e.g. single and moved to a new city for work) to prepare and share meals together. Like maybe I know that I'm cooking for ~6 people every Tuesday as part of a meal sharing, and someone else is cooking on Thursdays. Or maybe one night a week, I know that I'm cooking on the first Tuesday of every month, and someone else is cooking the second, etc.
- JustAnotherPat 9y agoThere's one huge flaw with the American Free Diner, and it's that it would inevitably be supplied by a place like Sysco or Aramark. Not only that, it would be the cheapest option with the lowest quality ingredients, and it would still wind up being relatively expensive to run. I remember the Malcolm Gladwell piece ripping Bowdoin for serving good food, and thinking how he got it all wrong. There are so many schools that wind up with garbage from Aramark, and they still pay an arm and a leg for it.
- peterwwillis 9y agoIn 2010, 18 million people lived in a food desert, without reasonable accessibility to any grocery store, and 41.2 million people live in a food-insecure household. That's 10 percent of the population with no access to healthy food, and 1 in 7 Americans going hungry every year. And this guy wants to build Diners (where no grocery stores exist) and not only collect food there, but cook and serve it to people. And thinks this will solve our nutrition problems. Sorry, but this guy is a fucking idiot. Besides the fact that this would be a bigger infrastructure project than fixing all our ailing bridges and roads, How are you going to handle thousands of people all wanting to eat at the same time? Are you going to provide transportation for them all? Leftovers? Handle all possible allergies, dietary and religious restrictions? Is the food going to cover a range of cuisines, since people in the US all come from varying backgrounds and traditions? There's probably a thousand different problems with forcing people to go to a specific place every single day just to get a meal, besides the fact that this would never get funded by the government, because almost all food banks and soup kitchens are privately funded, because the government won't.
- theBuess 9y ago> If schools operated for profit, with education subsidized by vouchers, the companies running the schools would have an interest in spending as little as possible actually educating the students, because every dollar they could save would be a dollar they could keep. How can someone actually believe this? That point of view makes the rest of this article hard to take at face value.
- mrguyorama 9y agoI have an aunt that works private education in Florida. This is in fact the norm of private education there
- ctdonath 9y agoMy kids have been in 3 schools. Public (among the best in the area) has proved far worse than private. "Keep" too much, and the money walks.
- mnm1 9y agoITT, Devry, University of Phoenix, Corinthian Colleges, etc. Yeah, I wonder why people would think for profit education is not in the best interest of the students too. /s
- jbattle 9y agoSure seems like something our society could experiment with and see what happens. Step A - build one (1) of these in a city somewhere, maybe another in a sub-urban location and see if people show up. Don't cut any benefits or anything, just see if people are interested in the setup. If that works, scale it up in a single large city, then a single state. The place where I see this most likely to fail is that the organization will be under constant dual pressure of budget restrictions (pressuring them to serve cheaper foods) and 'usership' (pressuring them to serve less healthy == tastier foods). As with any system, the incentives have to be set up properly from the start.
- ctdonath 9y agoSimilar has been done. "Pay what you want" restaurants featuring healthy options have all failed.
- padobson 9y agoAttacking the profit motive is insane. There were a billion people on this planet 200 years ago and now there are 7 billion people. The main reason for that is profits. When someone grows a bushel of wheat for $3.75 and sells it for $4.30, they're able to grow 13% more wheat in the next harvest. That profit makes the growing of wheat self sustaining and scalable. Now apply the logic to every crop, every home appliance, every energy source - every endeavor human beings pursue. The result is 6 billion people who didn't die of starvation, disease, or exposure. The biggest problem with lefty attacks on the profit motive is they simply don't realize that the profit motive could be used to solve the problems they describe! Upset about the education options in this country? Create a profitable alternative and you can scale it out to every student in America. Don't like the obesity problems developed countries face? Find a profitable way to turn fat people into skinny people and watch the pounds of every population dwindle. Profits are like magic. They make solutions to difficult problems available on a mass scale. There have no doubt been some growing pains as humans have learned to harness this magic, but the solution to those growing pains is not to eliminate the profit motive - the best solution is always profitable.
- Zarel 9y agoThis is a response to an earlier article by Scott Alexander, and he's already written a response to this one, too: http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/11/21/contra-robinson-on-public-food/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/11/21/contra-robinson-on-publ... The general idea is "you can't compare real capitalism with a fantasy government, you have to compare real capitalism with a real government, and real governments are worse than real capitalism"
- bad-joke 9y agoYou can absolutely compare the real with a fantasy. That's how innovation happens.
- Zarel 9y agoWell, yes, but you generally have to have a plan for how your innovation happens, rather than "my version won't have any of the problems the existing versions have" without having an explanation for how you achieve this.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoI agree with this. However there's a different way I'd look at it. It takes 25 sq ft of vegetation to feed a person. Along with this, you can also raise tilapia. Aquaculture. But this is backbreaking work. Farming sucks, and hurts the body. So, don't farm. We can instead use Farmbot.io as a platform of what to build. So we have a basis of how to automate farming. It still requires killing fish when they mature, but im sure even that can be automated. Now, back to 25 sqft. If there's 30k people to feed, that's 750k sq ft to feed everyone. Now, if we construct a building 3 stories tall, that's 250k sq ft per floor.. square root of that = 500ft x 500ft floor size... We need a building 550'x550' 3 stories tall to feed 30,000 people. And that would be climate controlled for the food you're producing, and ideally free for any to eat. I call it food security. It may be "communist" for some definition of communism. But I don't care. This provides a right to live, by the very fact that you now have a guarantee of a share of food. No compulsion or anything.
- ctdonath 9y agoYou were doing great until "free". It's not free. It's hard work, using resources of value. There is compulsion, whereby others must sacrifice (under threat) their own wealth & resources to facilitate what is falsely advertised as "free". You have a right to live, insofar as nobody else may unduly take your life from you. That you live, comes the responsibility to provide for yourself - and suffer the consequences of your choices. We've seen communism tried time and again. The death tolls & misery are staggering. Many of us will make sure it's not "tried", aka imposed by threat & violence, here; this is not up for debate, and you'd do well to understand why.
- crankylinuxuser 9y ago> You were doing great until "free". It's not free. It's hard work, using resources of value. There is compulsion, whereby others must sacrifice (under threat) their own wealth & resources to facilitate what is falsely advertised as "free". Initially yes, it is an expenditure. It would cost tax dollars, which I'm guessing by your tone, is "theft by a gun from state entity". Yes, ive heard the normal libertarian trappings. But this provides guaranteed food. And for those preppers, it's also local production. And it's provided to all. > You have a right to live, insofar as nobody else may unduly take your life from you. That you live, comes the responsibility to provide for yourself - and suffer the consequences of your choices. Yes, and the law is equal, in that it bans both the rich and the poor alike from sleeping under bridges. The rich can afford whatever food they want. The poor cannot. This would provide a buffer for every living person in this country to get healthy food. Where you talk of "Self Actualization" ideals, there's people in this country starving. That itself should be abhorrent and disgusting. But I'm sure you'll have excuses why they should deserve to starve. > We've seen communism tried time and again. The death tolls & misery are staggering. Many of us will make sure it's not "tried", aka imposed by threat & violence, here; this is not up for debate, and you'd do well to understand why. Communism has useful tools and ideas. So does capitalism. Communism's been tried and gets stuck at military dictatorship on its way to stateless egalitarianism, every time. Capitalism goes the other way with large monied interests turning into their own dictatorships. It's not like many of the robber barons enacted company farms and company stores, and kept strikes from happening by violence... Oh, they did. Quite a few were killed by companies and National Guard. And the big difference that you fail to cede to, is that with computing, machine learning, and artificial intelligence, we can start changing: "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs" --TO-- "To each according to his needs". And that would entail nobody "by threat & violence". Try looking past 1850's political theory. I know I try.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- foxhop 9y agoTL;DR the CrossFit of permaculture Yes! We need this and I dream about dedicating my life towards this work. Permaculture fits in this. It might be tricky to keep the stigma of food kitchen out of this idea, or maybe expand and fund food kitchens some how. I want to farm healthy food and give it away. I want to cook healthy food and show people a better way of eating. I think the MVP of this idea is to sell food as close to cost as possible. Make it taste amazing. Make the atmosphere not feel like a cafeteria but more like a Starbucks. Invite people to stay as long as they like, invite them to help. The biggest expense would likely be the commercial kitchen (hopefully buying the building and land). The first versions of this idea could be private but substidised. Government gives me 100k and I use 100k of my own money to buy and setup the facility. Another idea is to treat it like a gym membership, like those crossfit clubs that have sprung all over the United States. Pay $150/mo for all you can eat healthy choices.
- Nelkins 9y ago"I’ve also always been suspicious of privatization schemes. That’s because I tend to think that when a service is for profit rather than for the public’s benefit, all sorts of perverse incentives arise." Holy crap, how can anyone take this piece seriously with this zinger in the opening paragraph. Neither private nor public are by themselves a panacea. Everything has trade-offs. This kind of polemic is not contributing to any kind of rational discourse.
- jriot 9y agoI understand the article is more about feeding in mass. However, how hard is it to eat healthy? I don't understand why people have trouble here. It is fairly simple concept we can apply logic to: if food is prepackaged: if food has ingredients you can't pronounce: bad for you else: probably bad for you else: good for you Do I eat salads everyday? No. I get my chickens from a local farm up the road, killed the day I buy them. I fry them up with collard greens on the side. The collard greens are made from the pig I bought from the same farm and had slaughtered - its understand collard greens are made with bacon slow cooking all day. Does everyone have access to these farms? No. Though you can still buy quality food at the super-market. I look at people's carts, and its full of soda, chips, frozen food, Starbucks coffee cans etc... Literally none of the food requires any type of cooking - heating in the oven or microwave does not equate to cooking. Plus this stuff is not cheap, chips are $3, soda is $3 - 5 a 12 pack etc... Drink whole milk at $2 a gallon or brew ice tea at $0.50 a gallon. Buy popcorn kernels at $8 a bag (expensive from local farmer, $3-4 is more likely), melt Kerrygold butter pour over top and add salt. If you do not know how to cook I recommend starting with 'The Essentials of Italian Cooking' by Marcella Hazan. You can make sauce and pasta (not required) from scratch in under an hour. Inexpensive, fair better tasting and healthy. Most recipes are simple and teaches you how to cook - Italian cooking at least.
- mattmanser 9y agoThis thread is full of victim blaming. The simple, completely obvious, counter-argument to this is that if it were that easy, every person would do it. There would be no obese people. Virtually no-one wants to be fat. Instead the problem is getting worse. Telling people to eat less and move more is simply not working.
- jriot 9y agoThere are no victims because it is a personal choice. If you want to be fat and lead a horrible life, so be it. Eating healthy is very simple. People research which TV to buy, what television show to watch, what political news story to be enraged about etc... But can't spend five minutes how to eat properly? There are no victims here, just people unwilling to accept responsibility for their choices.
- jacknews 9y agoYou can take a look at the English-as-a-foreign-language schools in a few Asian countries to see what a private education system would look like and it is just as described, even despite the results being fairly measurable (can you speak in English or not).