4 ms·
You don't seem to mention pricing at all beyond the "5 devices and 5Gb/mo free". That would be useful to what I expect your main audience to be (people for whom
by dspillett 9y ago
You don't seem to mention pricing at all beyond the "5 devices and 5Gb/mo free". That would be useful to what I expect your main audience to be (people for whom the other obvious alternative is a cheap VPS and either OpenVPN or more manually setup SSH tunnelling).
- nine_k 9y agoI wonder why openvpn comes up so often, and e.g. tinc and zerotier, much less often.
- dspillett 9y agoMomentum mainly I suspect: it has been around and stable for quite some time so a lot of people have good experience with it so it is their go-to when thinking about VPN options (at least F/OSS ones). It has also been audited by third parties (example: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/05/16/openvpn_security_audit/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/05/16/openvpn_security_au...) which is reassuring as it has passed with minor issues which were fixed FDQ. I don't know if that is the case for the other options you've listed.
- 3pt14159 9y agoI set up an OpenVPN server on DigitalOcean from scratch and it wasn't nearly as easy to use as I expected. Connecting from ubuntu meant connections would randomly hang and I'd have to restart the client and iPhone didn't work out without some third party app. Honestly if I weren't in Ukraine I would have given up completely, but paranoia is justified in Kiev.
- throwanem 9y agoThird-party app? OpenVPN Connect is first-party, and I've been using it for years now with no trouble.
- 3pt14159 9y agoThird-party as in non-Apple. It's taking over my networking so I'd prefer it was baked right into the operating system.
- dspillett 9y agoI have no experience with iDevices, but when I did use OpenVPN on Android I found it to be reliable. If you find 3rd party apps unrelibale, perhaps you could try setting up a server that uses one of the protocols that are officially supported out-of-the-box (https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201533 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201533) and see if they are less troublesome?
- thesmok 9y agoUse IKEv2 instead -- it's natively supported in iOS/macOS. I'm using [this](https://github.com/gaomd/docker-ikev2-vpn-server https://github.com/gaomd/docker-ikev2-vpn-server) Docker recipe on the $5 Digital Ocean instance and it works great. Also setup was much easier than OpenVPN.
- Faaak 9y agoIt just works. Why reinvent the wheel ?
- nine_k 9y agoIt takes more configuration, and does not seem to have some of the nice properties, like direct connection between two VPN-connected hosts when on the same LAN. It's a killer feature for me, when I can sync a gig or two between my laptop and my home server when at home, without routing them through a box outside the LAN.
- dspillett 9y ago> like direct connection between two VPN-connected hosts when on the same LAN If they are on the same LAN then they should be able to see each other through the local interface. If connections between them using local addresses are going through the VPN then you have a routing issue - even with the OpenVPN interface set as your default gateway the gateway for the local subnet should still be the local, presumably physical, network interface. If you are using VPN provided addresses (or public addresses) for the connections then that is the issue. It shouldn't be the VPN's job to say "I think this should be routed locally instead". If you are using non-local local addresses, i.e. if you have two subnets on your physical network are talking between them, then you need to set the gateways for those subnets appropriately. The VPN will see them as separate networks (they are addressing-wise) and again it is not its job to decide routing apart from for its own virtual network.
- nine_k 9y agoI want a private network which has its traffic encrypted while routed over public internet, and just always use the names bound to that private network, not caring about the local physical addresses I receive from a particular point of connection. I also don't want to pass the traffic over a remote gateway if a local link is available. I don't know and don/t care if it's a "VPN proper" or something else, as long as it gives me an IP interface with these properties, and is open-source. ZeroTier provides that. Tinc provides that. OpenVPN provides something more narrow, which I happen to prefer less.