3 ms·
What kind of causes do you think they could fix at this level?
by danso 9y ago
What kind of causes do you think they could fix at this level?
- coldtea 9y agoAt the hiring level? If two candidates have equal technical skills, color shouldn't matter at all, and "cultural fit" BS should not play a role.
- danso 9y agoOK, but this situation literally never exists in the real world. Even if two candidates have 10 years of professional Python experience, there is going to be a more granular metric you use to figure out who has more technical skill. Maybe candidate A has more experience in Python 2.7 -- what Google still uses primarily for internal Python, and so candidate A gets hired. But nothing in life is that simple. What if Candidate B has just 1 year less experience in Python 2.7x, and Candidate A has a domestic violence felony on their record? What is the optimal, objective decision then? Or consider a less dramatic example of "cultural" issues. Candidate A has 11 years in Python experience, Candidate B has 10 years. But Candidate A casually throws around the phrase "bitch work" and uses "faggy" and "retarded" as synonyms for "unfair" and "stupid", but is otherwise just as decent a person as B (however that is objectively measured). And let's imagine that this doesn't actually violate any HR policies. Is it objectively correct to hire Candidate A on the basis of technical achievement? What if Candidate A is going to work with a female boss and several engineers who are LGBT? You think that Candidate A's extra year of Python experience objectively outweighs the damage that he would do team cohesion? I'll humor you with your unrealistic scenario: OK, 2 completely equal candidates. And I'm playing devil's advocate for the diversity folks. You think that diversity advocates -- all things being exactly equal -- are obligated by their philosophy to choose the black candidate on the basis of being black? I sure as hell wouldn't make that rationalization, because that fits the legal definition of discrimination. Someone who is a diversity advocate can also be someone who isn't a federal law violator. So how would I resolve it? Flip a coin -- that's no more absurd a solution than the entire scenario in the first place. What would be your hypothetical solution?
- coldtea 9y ago>So how would I resolve it? Flip a coin -- that's no more absurd a solution than the entire scenario in the first place. What would be your hypothetical solution? If the 2 candidates are completely equal, then sure, flip a coin. Many managers do something like it already, even if it's just to hire among e.g. white candidates. Besides, the examples I find somewhat contrived. How about "fuck team cohesion" which is a euphemism for "hiring like-minded hipsters/brogrammers/etc", and just get the technically better programmer (or flip coin if equal). The team can cohese itself just fine. At worst, those others in the team, will have to learn that society is not just people who behave and talk just like them, but all kinds. That's an even better boost to real diversity (not just race/gender diversity, but diversity of opinions and character traits and walks-of-life, which matter even more).