3 ms·
Any time there are metrics for success, there is potential for unhealthy incentives to arise in a system, which results in an overall decrease in whatever the m
by danso 9y ago
Any time there are metrics for success, there is potential for unhealthy incentives to arise in a system, which results in an overall decrease in whatever the metrics were supposed to optimize for. If this is the premise, then having other communities optimize for the metrics is not going to result in a positive outcome for Silicon Valley or society in general.
Test scores were seen as a fairly efficient way to determine academic skill and intelligence. Obedience to school authority is seen as a metric for character. Also, being penalized by school authorities makes it significantly harder to be an active participant/leader in school activities, which is seen as an important metric for well-roundedness, talent, etc.
Imagine how much of SV wouldn't exist today if the prevailing mindset -- in society and among venture capitalists -- was that a good-tier college degree was an important metric for tech workers and entrepreneurs. Not to sound like Peter Thiel here (and admittedly, showing some serious survivor bias here in this line of reasoning) but SV has shown that huge success can be made from folks who didn't go through formal college. Would Steve Jobs and Steve Woz even be taken seriously as entrepreneurs in today's environment, where college degrees are significantly more common than they were in the 60s and 70s?
> And if those other communities have a history of systemic oppression, poorly funded school districts, legal bias against them, etc, fix that too.
This has been an ongoing fight for decades. You think SV should wait on political overhaul before making decisions regarding optimization of their workforce>
- coldtea 9y ago>but SV has shown that huge success can be made from folks who didn't go through formal college From all industries I know of, SV is probably the poorest example of that, close to medicine for needing a degree to get anywhere in fancy SV companies. Commerce, the hospitality, the restaurant business, and tons of others are way ahead in that regard... Besides, shouldn't we demand more engineering and computer science, and less ad-hoc crap and reinvention of the wheel from self-taught programmers? More Xerox Park and Bell Labs, and DEC, and SUN, and SGI, and so on, that is, and less "dropout that builds some social BS app"?
- danso 9y ago> From all industries I know of, SV is probably the poorest example of that, close to medicine for needing a degree to get anywhere in fancy SV companies. You must not be familiar with journalism, which has a long storied history of amazing journalists who never went to college. Today, it is nearly impossible to land any kind of internship without a college degree, or some other extreme qualifications (being very wealthy, or from a very important family). I think it's a function of the commonality of a college degree and the significant reduction of available jobs in journalism. > Besides, shouldn't we demand more engineering and computer science, and less ad-hoc crap and reinvention of the wheel from self-taught programmers? As someone with a CompEng degree myself, I'm not going to argue with you against the benefits of an engineering degree. And I won't make an argument based on the existence of Woz (a college dropout who managed to be a stellar self-taught engineer and programmer). And there are obviously successful SV startups that have been started by people with formal educations, as well as complete disasters from dropouts (e.g. Theranos). But you think the main driver of innovation in SV is coding/engineering aptitude and discipline?