4 ms·
OK, I'll bite. Maybe it is wrong that SV companies have proportionally more Asians than whites. Not "morally wrong", but wrong in the sense that Asian communiti
by danso 9y ago
OK, I'll bite. Maybe it is wrong that SV companies have proportionally more Asians than whites. Not "morally wrong", but wrong in the sense that Asian communities have optimized for certain metrics (tests, school performances, college aspirations) and SV companies have just gone along with what's in the pipeline. Despite the fact that SV has a long history of highly successful companies being started by dropouts and other kinds of "miscreants".
So these SV companies should alter their recruiting process so that their hiring pool isn't basically a mirror of Stanford's application pool. (full disclosure: I'm Asian. I also work at Stanford. I also play no part in Stanford admissions and probably have less clue about it than the average outsider)
That's fair enough. So what's wrong with making an effort to examine the ways that the SV hiring process systematically -- but not intentionally or maliciously -- filters out blacks, Hispanics, and women from engineering positions?
- coldtea 9y ago>Maybe it is wrong that SV companies have proportionally more Asians than whites. Not "morally wrong", but wrong in the sense that Asian communities have optimized for certain metrics (tests, school performances, college aspirations) and SV companies have just gone along with what's in the pipeline. How is that wrong? Let the other communities optimize for those metrics too. And if those other communities have a history of systemic oppression, poorly funded school districts, legal bias against them, etc, attempt to fix that too (which would be even more important for the community overall than getting more people from the community to work in some specific industry). >Despite the fact that SV has a long history of highly successful companies being started by dropouts and other kinds of "miscreants". That's just a myth based on a few selective cases, which even count people like Zuckerberg with a Stanford education or Bill Gates as "drop-outs" because they didn't finish their degrees. Besides, a founder can be of any potential background as they are not to answer to anybody else nor do they have to have any specific technical skills (a DB admin position however, or a data science one, does have to have them). And even then, they are usually from well educated, well connected, and usually well white, backgrounds. I'm not so sure we want to take them as example of with which criteria to hire.
- arthur_pryor 9y ago> > Maybe it is wrong that SV companies have proportionally more Asians than whites. Not "morally wrong", but wrong in the sense that Asian communities have optimized for certain metrics (tests, school performances, college aspirations) and SV companies have just gone along with what's in the pipeline. > How is that wrong? Let the other communities optimize for those metrics too. what if it's missing candidates that could do the job? what if the filter is using metrics that aren't actually the best proxy for what we're trying to optimize? you missed this part of the comment you were replying to: > Despite the fact that SV has a long history of highly successful companies being started by dropouts and other kinds of "miscreants". which is basically to say, after being (rightfully, i think) enamored with silicon valley's love of ability over credentials... why go back to just cargo-culting over credentials? > And if those other communities have a history of systemic oppression, poorly funded school districts, legal bias against them, etc, fix that too. to me, that's what diversity initiatives and hard discussions like this are part of: fixing the effects of historic systemic oppression. lots of other fronts on which that can be attacked, but no reason not to try to do it here too.
- coldtea 9y ago>what if it's missing candidates that could do the job? what if the filter is using metrics that aren't actually the best proxy for what we're trying to optimize? That's for the company to decide, and not "wrong". At worst, it might be ineffective. >to me, that's what diversity initiatives and hard discussions like this are part of: fixing the effects of historic systemic oppression. For me they try to fix at the wrong level (like using a bandage to stop internal bleeding instead of fixing the cause) and thus cause more problems than they solve.
- zimablue 9y agoBut you say "going with what's in the pipeline", that basically means "hiring on average the best/mean candidates according to their metrics that apply". To say that they shouldn't do that you basically have two options: Say that they should discriminate and hire candidates that will be worse on average by their metrics, in the name of social justice, Say that their metrics are wrong and they should adapt them. I'd probably accept the second statement but that has to be a complicated and difficult thing to do.
- arthur_pryor 9y ago> But you say "going with what's in the pipeline", that basically means "hiring on average the best/mean candidates according to their metrics that apply". > To say that they shouldn't do that you basically have two options: Say that they should discriminate and hire candidates that will be worse on average by their metrics, in the name of social justice, > Say that their metrics are wrong and they should adapt them. > I'd probably accept the second statement but that has to be a complicated and difficult thing to do. would you accept the second statement and then also accept the status quo because figuring out better metrics is complicated and difficult? would it be better to keep getting bad answers and perpetuating old injustices because the alternative is difficult reform work?
- zimablue 9y agoI think that there's an implicit assumption that there's a massive injustice, and that those things are most defined by race/gender and not, for example, parental income. In my limited personal experience of social justice measures you just give ethnic minority private school girls yet another leg up whilst working class white men get absolutely no chance (competing against all the rich white men, then placed at a disadvantage against everyone else). I definitely accept the second statement, I think almost everyone does. Damore had it in his memo. Noone is against behind the curtain auditions kind of measures, but far more people than would be willing to admit it publically are very much against quotas, or positive discrimination, or whatever the current PC term is for giving someone a job on the basis of their skin colour/gender and a perceived social injustice.
- guitarbill 9y agoIt's possible to look at this the other way. For something that is supposed to be such a great employment, it sure has it's downsides. I'm starting to think it's inherent in the type of work, much like the stereotypes you know of accountants. Maybe not working as a coder is a sign your priorities are right. Part of it is that you need an insane amount of focus to be good at coding, and very few people have that and other skills like people skills (and if they do, there's plenty of other well-paying opportunities). That coupled with an understanding of technology (which most people think is magic) is actually pretty alienating. Hope you have some hobbies, otherwise you'll be socialising with "like-minded" people. So maybe articles could also focus on the downsides, like they do with e.g. oil and gas jobs. I know I wouldn't have chosen this career if I had known. Not sure why we're trying to push so many people into tech. Sure, some technical proficiency is good, but knowing how to code is like knowing semi-conductor fabrication - irrelevant for actually using an iPhone.
- danso 9y ago> For something that is supposed to be such a great employment, it sure has it's downsides Look, I agree with the sentiment. But it's easy to have this sentiment after you've lived it ("the grass is always greener", etc) and even if you didn't like it, you still enjoyed a level of financial stability in those years (nevermind the prestige that will help you land jobs elsewhere) that many people would envy. Maybe folks who are in the currently underrepresented groups will soon have the same loathing but the difference is that right now -- as the OP argues, evidently -- these folks don't get that choice. And we don't need to see diversity in tech as being just a way of restorative justice (as if that was SV's job). The argument for diversity in the workforce is that SV's userbase is diverse. And people from different backgrounds (not just racial, of course, but racial diversity is currently deficient) allows a SV company to be more innovative and successful to the bottom-line. In other words, a coder's benefits to a company's bottom line is not solely based on coding skill or achievement. Was Mark Zuckerberg really the best PHP programmer of his generation?
- guitarbill 9y ago> you still enjoyed a level of financial stability in those years [...] these folks don't get that choice. I keep forgetting how much it pays in the US. But agreed, if I was deprived of a way to make heaps of money directly out of university I'd be mildly annoyed. (Arguably by not being American, I kind of was. And this goes without saying, but since it's the Internet, I'm not trying to argue that this "injustice" is the same as the alleged racism.) --- I'm also involved with hiring people. Am I racist? I don't know, I only get the coding challenges without names. I do know that 95% of the applicants are shit, and most can't even be bothered with the coding "challenge" (on par with fizz buzz, it's mainly a test of do you have basic reading comprehension). Having a CS degree is meaningless as far as quality goes. So what I can relate to is that the university sucks at preparing people for the job. And the article does say that, but that's not the main focus. So going back to first principles. Why is the title "Why Doesn’t Silicon Valley Hire Black Coders?", and not "Man with industry experience is shocked to find University curriculum 25 years out of date", or "Universities hate us: This one trick to get hired"?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- threatofrain 9y agoWe should expect that hiring science improves over time if, in fact, the difference between the top talent and 2nd-tier talent really matters that much to firm success. And if tests, school performance, college aspirations are interesting things, then we should continue to improve our pedagogical craft, and we should continue encouraging youth to pursue college, as opposed to dropout. Not everyone can benefit from the Peter Thiel method. Examination has its bad parts, such as deviance from ground facts, but the lack of examination is even less grounded in empiricism. That is surely where dishonest thrives best, where wishy washy arguments dominate. We discuss competency because meritocracy is a counterbalance to nepotism, and meritocracy has a really nasty edge to it even if performed ideally. We often talk about how meritocracy could be done better, as implied when we criticize instruments such as tests, but even an ideal meritocracy retains a very harsh edge to it -- it bears moral judgment on the incompetent. Also buried underneath in implication is the idea that there's a sizable group of intellectuals who are stomped on by school, and they have Facebook in the garage potential (but not Elon Musk potential). I might suggest that processes that produce Elon Musks and Steve Jobs are mysterious, and criticizing education in favor of throwing thousands of kids into a black box creative process, hoping that Elon Musks and Steve Jobs come out, is a thinking even more cruel than unrestrained meritocracy. Our system would have been elite in a historical perspective, basically offering calculus in high school to just about any child in the US if they could take it. In today's terms, it's not so obvious why the American employee is that much better than a British or German engineer. Or at the university level, why an American student would be that much better. If anything, Americans have been routinely trounced on international math competitions. Rather than diminishing our education system in favor of black box hopes for more Steve Jobs (How many thousands of kids does it take to make a Steve Jobs? How many Steve Jobs are there per Apples?), I would hope we identify and improve gaps in education, and not throw out the art of examination.
- return0 9y ago> companies being started by dropouts and other kinds of "miscreants" But founders are not hired