5 ms·
The people who believe the 19th century pseudoscience you appear to be pushing generally don't rate Indian IQs that highly. Just the large number of people in
by ZeroGravitas 9y ago
The people who believe the 19th century pseudoscience you appear to be pushing generally don't rate Indian IQs that highly.
Just the large number of people in Asia (4.4 Billion) and a selection filter is a simpler explanation.
- retox 9y agoWhat do you mean by 19th century pseudoscience?
- barry-cotter 9y agoThey don’t find the science of psychometric credible. This is a trifle harsh since psychometrics is very, very extensively validated, not something one can say of social psychology, for example.
- ghostcluster 9y agoGoogle also extensively scores their job applicants on a number of metrics during interviews. https://www.wired.com/2015/04/hire-like-google/ https://www.wired.com/2015/04/hire-like-google/ Unless you want to call that pseudoscience as well.
- emsy 9y agoBasically confirming the parent comment. If it's not politically convenient it must be bogus.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoI mean believing that there's a scientific concept that corresponds to the pre-genetics concept of "race". These "race realists" claim they have a good way to scientifically measure IQ, and that IQ is really important and then propose solutions that don't involve measuring IQ, but rather looking at people's skin color. It's a somewhat transparent bait and switch (or mott and bailey).
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoI'm not sure that's what is happening here. If there are inequalities in race in America, it's kind of assumed that it's due to some sort of systemic racism. But what if it's caused by something else? What if it selects for socioeconomic status? Or cultural values? It's fairly known that there is a correlation between race and culture in America. If there is a culture that breeds better self-control, better long-term goal attainment, and greater consideration for other people, doesn't it make sense that it would be a culture that does better than others?
- coldtea 9y agoHow about the large percentage of blacks without degrees and with poor access to education? Isn't that an even simpler explanation?
- barry-cotter 9y agoThe Indian subcontinent has more population substructure than anywhere else I’m aware of. The different sub-castes (jati) are endogomous to a really surprising degree. It’s entirely possible some jati are way smarter than the Indian average. Parsis have the same kind of ludicrous over representation in terms of high achievement as Askenazim do. This is obviously not the whole story though. Sikhs, Hindus and Muslims from pre-partition Punjab are little different genetically apart from way higher Muslim inbreeding. IIRC all three groups outperform native Britons though and they’re mostly the descendants of peasants. Some likely very large portion of Indian/Pakistani/Bangladeshi educational underperformance is terrible education systems. There’s a great section in Poor Economics, Esther Duflo and Abhijit Bannerjee on education in the developing world, covering Kenya and India among others. It’s mostly crap.