5 ms·
We're quickly going to be in a world where all phone calls are VoIP and I don't think it's unreasonable to allow QoS tiers. I don't want to have my phone not wo
by jonknee 16y ago
We're quickly going to be in a world where all phone calls are VoIP and I don't think it's unreasonable to allow QoS tiers. I don't want to have my phone not work because my neighbors are torrenting. Hell, I already do this on my home network. Google just wants to make sure you don't have to pay to get in a QoS tier.
- ericflo 16y agoHow about a corollary: why should your neighbor's torrents slow down just because you are making a bunch of phone calls? (And remember, people are using torrents for legitimate purposes, like how Blizzard uses it to distribute purchased copies of Starcraft II.) The solution is to fix overall network capacity.
- pvg 16y agoThat's a 'fix' if network capacity were infinite. You can rephrase your corollary as 'why should my VOIP calls drop just because I'm downloading StarCraft II'. There isn't anything inherently evil in the notion that you might want to prioritize, say, latency-dependent traffic over traffic that isn't.
- nostrademons 16y agoHaven't people done studies on this and found that the cost to implement QoS is greater than the cost to just increase network bandwidth? That may not hold forever, but it holds now in the U.S. Current residential broadband lines in the U.S. could go much faster with zero technical effort. They're capped because Verizon and Comcast only give you enough bandwidth to make sure that you get more than you would with a competitor. They hold the rest in reserve so that they can raise speeds and please customers easily when a competitor raises speeds. We've got the slowest Internet speeds in the developed world, and you can bet it isn't because of technological reasons: http://www.websiteoptimization.com/bw/1004/ http://www.websiteoptimization.com/bw/1004/
- pvg 16y agoMy point was that 'adding bandwidth' is not actually a solution to congestion-related problems. Double the bandwidth, now StartCraft II downloads in two instead of four hours, during which time your VOIP calls still drop. This is not unlike a problem urban planners have run across - adding lanes to a thoroughfare often does not relieve traffic congestion. So unless you can add bandwidth indefinitely so that there is never, ever any congestion, the issues are somewhat orthogonal.
- Locke1689 16y agoSpoken like someone who doesn't understand QoS. QoS uses latency-aware networking to push low-latency packets closer to the top of the queue. That doesn't necessarily mean that they get full bandwidth priority. VoIP calls may delay Bittorrent packets by a couple tenths of a second. In other words, low-latency applications are usually inelastic, while file transfers are usually elastic.
- roc 16y agoAgain: that sounds good, until you think it through. What happens when an upstart wants to compete with Verizon on VoIP? Say they roll out an innovative new protocol that offers far better quality in a still-reasonable footprint. Or offers some sideband feature that existing VoIP doesn't. (say, streaming file transfer, letting you send data bits during a call while on the call directly to the person you're talking to. no need to open a mail client or sftp and negotiate a second connection) Why wouldn't Verizon decide that this new competitor is a new flavor of VoIP that needs to be in its own QoS tier? It will have a different traffic profile, so you can't very well argue that they shouldn't be able to "optimize" it separately on technical grounds. But now it's a new "type" and Verizon is free to kick it into the QoS round-file tier to either blackmail payment or simply hamstring adoption. Maybe they only do that until they catch up and offer similar features. Or maybe they launch their own next-gen VoIP protocol in yet-another QoS tier, where the upstart is still not allowed. Once you open the door to QoS by type --and leave type classification in the hands of the ISPs who directly profit from how these largely arbitrary lines are drawn-- there's a vanishingly small difference between QoS by type and by source.
- jonknee 16y ago> But now it's a new "type" and Verizon is free to kick it into the QoS round-file tier to either blackmail payment or simply hamstring adoption. This is what Google's looking to make sure doesn't happen. No one should be able to pay for a QoS tier or kick a competitor into a lower tier. It's not perfect, but as an end user I'd rather have SIP traffic prioritized and take a chance that a non-prioritized upstart standard will take longer to catch on than my calls to drop. Obviously the best scenario is a dramatic increase in network capacity so QoS is a non-issue, but that's not realistic in the short term.
- haberman 16y agoYour example doesn't make any sense. For purely technical reasons there would be no reason to send a VoIP call along with the "sideband feature" over the same connection. Even if your VoIP application offers a feature like streaming file transfer, you wouldn't actually implement that by sending that data over the VoIP connection, because the VoIP data requires real-time performance (the call starts breaking up if packets are delayed) but your streaming file transfer does not. It would be silly to let your multi-gigabyte file transfer DoS your VoIP call. If you simply opened a second, non-VoIP connection for the file transfer, everything would work fine. Would Verizon have an incentive to cheat by favoring its own services? Maybe, but that seems to be what these Google talks are all about in the first place. I think Google is aware that any agreement would need more teeth than trusting the goodness of Verizon's heart to comply.
- mortenjorck 16y agoFar be it from me to encourage the fostering of bureaucracy, but this is one case where a consortium with a self-governing body might actually be in order. Imagine an industry-wide QOS board. The board solicits input and transparently sets standards for types of traffic and the priority they recommend giving them. Then providers who have signed on to the charter agree to prioritize exactly according to these standards. The board reconvenes annually to examine current technological trends and review and update their recommendations. Possible? Palatable?
- jbooth 16y agoSounds like J2EE. Why don't we just call this QOS board the "FCC" and give it a congressional mandate?
- CapitalistCartr 16y agoWhile the problem your discussing is legitimate, your proposed solution is far from the only one, and I doubt it's the best one.