5 ms·
Because they interview them but they aren't a "cultural fit". Nothing is more important than protecting "the culture". https://medium.com/@bchesky/dont-fuck-up
by andrewstuart 9y ago
Because they interview them but they aren't a "cultural fit".
Nothing is more important than protecting "the culture".
https://medium.com/@bchesky/dont-fuck-up-the-culture-597cde9ee9d4 https://medium.com/@bchesky/dont-fuck-up-the-culture-597cde9...
The article above says that "Culture is simply a shared way of doing something with passion.", but in fact means "same as us: young white/indian/asian boys".
"Culture" is a get out of jail free card that allows anyone to deny a job to anyone at all whilst sounding entirely credible and important.
If you really want diversity then you would require reasons for rejecting any candidate, but you're not allowed to say "they weren't a cultural fit".
- friendly_chap 9y agoSo what is the reason that white/indian/asian boys are preferred? Genuinely curious. I have mostly experience in London and there the landscape is extremely diverse. Why would any company not hire any ethnicity if they are good at what they do?
- yters 9y agoI've wondered this. If there are so many talented underpaid people, isn't the right response to form a company that specifically hires from these groups? Should be a whole lot of money to be made.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoHired.com Triplebyte Paysa HackerRank :)
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoSecond, why don't these people (apparently) band together? Where are the <underrepresented demographic> founders that hire people that are a cultural fit for them? I don't get why the blame is put on "silicon valley"; they don't have an obligation to provide work for everyone.
- danso 9y agoMaybe whites/indians/asians aren't "preferred" in the sense of active racial discrimination. But the people currently at the company, being mostly of that ethnicity, may have personal contact lists/rolodecks that are weighted toward that ethnicity. I can attest to that as a Vietnamese-American myself. The vast majority of my childhood friends are white because I grew up in the Midwest. But I had far more Vietnamese friends than would be statistically expected because the few Vietnamese families in the community just hung out regularly even as they integrated with the rest of the town. If you grew up not just white, but upper-middle class and above, how many black people, statistically speaking, are you regularly in contact with? Versus someone who grows up lower-income or in the inner city? Being relatively well-off, you have a statistically better chance of getting a better K-12 education, which leads to a better chance at a top-tier school, and then to a top-tier company. You eventually are in a position to make recommendations for hires, and statistically speaking, you know more qualified whites than you do blacks and Hispanics. Statistically speaking, at many companies, recommendations from current employers carry a lot of weight. Over time, this statistical weighting of life experiences would lead to a mostly white/Asian workforce at a tech company. And no one in this process was ever thinking "No blacks". So to actually get a workforce that includes a representative number of a disenfranchised minority group, you actively have to seek it out. If you are in Silicon Valley, you have to actively make the decision to fly out to Howard U to do recruiting instead of the much more rational and cost-efficient decision to base recruiting at Stanford and Berkeley.
- partycoder 9y ago+1. Very eloquently put. I would probably add that a portion of these are temporary work visa holders (e.g: H-1B). If you get terminated under these visas you are out of status and need to leave the country. Being on a temporary worker visa makes workers submissive and gives companies leverage over the employee.
- averagewall 9y agoStrangely, hiring your friends is seen as corruption when it's for the government, but it's somehow the proper way to do things for the private sector. If companies really do exist to serve potential employees, then we should require them to do that fairly. However, if they're there to provide value for their customers, then maybe it doesn't matter who's friends they hire or what race they or how the discriminate. Nobody has a right to work at Google.
- vasco 9y agoMy experience of "culture fit" is that it's actually used much more often for "can code well but is a jerk" than anything else. Anecdotal though.
- ztjio 9y ago"Has overly passionate opinions based well outside fact and is an ass about it constantly. Also we share those opinions."
- jstewartmobile 9y agoMy field report on "culture fit" would be child of academic or fussy schoolteacher. There's a sort of pedantry in their communication that will take you further than your abilities in academia, yet really rubs everyone else the wrong way.
- seppin 9y agoAs a company, or sports team, or anything, you have every right to protect the existing group dynamic and to avoid distractions or negative influences.
- andrewstuart 9y agoAn Indian mother with young kids and a heavy accent.... is that "cultural fit" to a hip and young fast moving programming team of boys who like to do hackathons and have beers on friday night? Does your team employ any such people right now? I know for sure there's plenty of them applying for jobs....
- trabant00 9y agoHow the hell could "same as us" mean "white/indian/asian boys"? I'm a white man from eastern Europe and the white americans I work with are anything but the same culture as mine. Indians could well be from another planet. Interestingly enough (though only anecdotal) black US workers have a more similar way of thinking to mine than white US ones. There's huge diversity in IT, you're just too blinded by your ideology to see it. You are the problem with your black/white quotas. You think there's diversity/differences inborn in the skin color. And that kind of thinking is called racism.
- saiya-jin 9y agoIf you ever worked for a truly great company, with tons of inspirational people, then you know the culture stuff is real. Very real. Once company loses it, most of the best talent will simply walk away, because there is only so much motivation you can get with money (and competition doesn't usually pay really much less anyway). Never worked in US, so hardly understanding the pathological obsession with political correctness there. I once experienced this great environment, and even though I am now paid maybe 4x as much, this was by far, far, far the best working experience I ever had. The relationships from this period are still alive across whole (former) staff even after the company was bought 8 years ago by international corp and lost much of its mojo (and within few months tons of those great people left for jobs that weren't paid more). As for the topic discussed, yeah just hire the best fit for hard and soft skills whatever the background, color of skin or native language. This is true equality, in mind and in action. Anybody expecting that spread across races/skin color/religion/whatever will be 100% matching that of general population is dangerously naive though
- retox 9y agoThe culture is young, single, not going to rock the boat. Why do they trendy SV companies have everything on site? So you don't leave them site. Parents do.
- scythe 9y agoYou're implying that "culture" so defined doesn't actually affect the work process. But what if it does? What if exclusive, unfair selection of employees actually induces them to work harder or more efficiently? I don't believe this[1], and if it were true, it wouldn't make the situation much better. But the alternate hypothesis is that all of these companies are leaving money on the table. These companies like to play on the idea that people should enjoy their jobs, which is obviously ridiculous because it's work, but if you can fool people into believing it, you can get them to work overtime and you profit. If letting your employees be casually racist means you get 15% more work out of them at the cost of 15% of your hiring pool it's a win because you save on labor costs. A necessary presupposition of the exercise is that the employees can be swayed by appeals to tribal psychology -- support the team (company) -- which is also the basis of racism. It sounds stupid when I say "letting your employees be casually racist" but if I substitute "only hire League of Legends players" it's obvious what's going on. It just so happens that the culture associated with many forms of entertainment techies enjoy is toxic to minorities and tends to be less black/Latino and more white/Asian than America as a whole. And all these things are tied together in the patchwork of culture. The utility of this sort of cultural Tom Sawyering extends beyond tech; it's crucial to the armed forces, for example, but appealing to minorities had more upsides for the financial backers in that case, and the military has more control over the culture it instills in soldiers, whereas Google et al ride the wave of contemporary US nerd affectations. [1] - okay, why not? There may be some culturally homogenous workplaces but it's not the norm in my experience. The lack of black people at tech companies probably is also related to the fact that they're in cities with fewer black people and depend heavily on referrals for hiring. But referrals depend on friendships which goes back to that culture of entertainment for nerds I was talking about.