3 ms·
The value of the bitcoin network lies in being a censorship[1]- and capital-control-resistant store of value. That is a social net positive, like investment in
by SilasX 9y ago
The value of the bitcoin network lies in being a censorship[1]- and capital-control-resistant store of value. That is a social net positive, like investment in the equity of productive ventures (except for different reasons). As more people use bitcoin, it becomes a more effective store of value and thus represents a further social good (modulo the increase in legitimately criminal stuff it facilitates!). Perhaps not exactly $50 billion worth, but value nonetheless.
>Crypto currencies cannot be valued - they don't have anything underlying them - they do not imply ownership of anything - and especially since they are not used as currencies - their valuation is a total fantasy.
>BTC is worth whatever the next guy thinks it is worth - and what he thinks it is worth is pure speculative fiction. Just a function of emotional dynamics and fad.
Isn't that equally true of any currency? It doesn't pay dividends and doesn't guarantee ownership of anything, and rises and falls based on the whims of the market. At most you can say that legit currencies are "ownership" of "the cancellation of X units of tax debt", but that's somewhat circular: there's no guarantee that "X units of tax debt" will be a large burden in the first place, and will itself fluctuate in value with the market.
[1] It's true that bitcoin has many failings at achieving anonymity but it certainly competes with international bank transfers for many use cases.
Necessary disclaimer: I'm long bitcoin and and author of understandingbitcoin.us.
- QAPereo 9y agoHow can something as inimical to privacy as Bitcoin be resistent to control? Direct and technical, maybe not, but China for example seems to work around that.
- SilasX 9y agoRight, it's an open question how good it will actually be at achieving the goals people want, like privacy. I don't have a firm reason to believe China will be successful or not. My point was just that there are legitimate reasons to believe Bitcoin will be valuable for non-bubble reasons and will not substantively differ from legit currencies in supporting a valuation.
- QAPereo 9y agoOk, that’s certainly a reasonably cautious stance, although st this point I wonder if that can be Bitcoin.