3 ms·
> that isn't a logical argument for making more intoxicants legal. "Alcohol is legal, therefore anything less harmful than that should also be legal" isn't a l
by StavrosK 9y ago
> that isn't a logical argument for making more intoxicants legal.
"Alcohol is legal, therefore anything less harmful than that should also be legal" isn't a logical argument?
- jonreem 9y agoNot if you believe that alcohol being legal is already wrong but are pragmatic about its pre-existing hold on society making it impossible to change. To be clear I don’t buy this argument since I disagree with the premise, but if you agree with the premise then it does make sense.
- xhedley 9y agoPre-existing hold plus the ingredients required to create ethanol (sugar, water, airborne or fruit or baking yeast, warmth) are legal and ubiquitous.
- StavrosK 9y agoThere isn't really a clear line that goes "you need to be less than THIS risky to be legal". We're comparing things with each other and kind of classifying them based on that. Alcohol and guns being legal definitely should move that line down, because it shows that, as a society, we're okay with some more risky things because <reasons>.
- tptacek 9y agoIt ignores the historical context behind controlled substance regulation, and also substitutes first-principles message board reasoning for empiricism. So, that's not quite the rhetorical kill-shot you're hoping for.
- StavrosK 9y agoI wasn't hoping for a kill shot, but that's beside the point. How would you argue for or against the legalization of something without comparing it to other things?
- tptacek 9y agoA case for prohibition of both alcohol and hallucinogens can be rational, but for the popularity of alcohol making it untenable to enforce that prohibition. In that set of circumstances, a prohibition targeting hallucinogens alone can still be rational even if the harm from alcohol is comparable. The point, of course, is that comparable harm from alcohol is not dispositive in the discussion of a ban on hallucinogens. Obviously, the notion that LSD is no more harmful than whiskey is also not broadly accepted in our public policy, or really the public policy of most western countries. So there's (at least) two hurdles for your argument to clear. But I'm stipulating the latter argument, because it's the logic you're employing that bugs me, not the equivalence you're trying to draw. These are positive arguments, not normative ones.
- mantas 9y agoWhat if alcohol is legal at the moment, but society is making it less and less legal, possibly outlawing it in far future?