8 ms·
From a quick look at their balance sheet, in the past year their total assets have increased from $12 billion to $28 billion, and debt from $2 billion to $9 bil
by DennisP 9y ago
From a quick look at their balance sheet, in the past year their total assets have increased from $12 billion to $28 billion, and debt from $2 billion to $9 billion, for an increase in net assets of $9 billion. Cash flow is fine too; total cash is up almost half a billion over the past year, for a total of $3.5B.
Looking at their cash flow statement, they are spending a lot but mostly on capital expenditures.
I don't see any reason to even think about bankruptcy. They're doing fine.
https://finance.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ATSLA&fstype=ii&ei=lPMaWoidLYnHmAHr6LuAAQ https://finance.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ATSLA&fstype=ii...
- ArmandGrillet 9y agoThose financial statements are not in the article and that's a shame. I would expect journalists writing about the potential bankruptcy of a company to give more numbers and less "maybe"s (word used 5 times in the article).
- majewsky 9y agoThe point of the article (as I understood) was precisely to explore every other angle except for the financial statement (since that's what every other article about TSLA covers).
- chipotle_coyote 9y agoIt's an opinion piece, not journalistic reporting -- the thesis isn't "Tesla is going to go bankrupt and here's why," but rather "here's why I don't think it matters whether Tesla goes bankrupt." It'd arguably be nice to have a sentence or two about "of course, they may not be in trouble after all," but it doesn't really affect the author's argument. I don't think this is really written for folks who are bullish on Tesla, anyway. It's written for critics, and for folks like myself who might describe themselves as "fascinated skeptics."
- eru 9y agoThanks for crunching the numbers!
- aaavl2821 9y agoRight now, their pp&e and working capital seem like they could be liquidated to pay back debt, so agree that bankruptcy doesn't seem to be a near term concern. However I don't know what covenants are in those loan documents, and its possible that given the delays tesla could trip a covenant and get in trouble with lenders. Though I'm sure Elon has worked his magic on them as well Hard to say if they're doing fine at this point, as the model 3 doesn't really show up in the financials yet. The real concern is that model 3 production capacity increases without sufficiently decreasing production efficiency. So revenue goes up but COGS skyrockets, and the business is structurally not profitable on even a gross profit basis. This would lead to huge financing needs, and also probably a drop in the stock price (though the stock price seems immune to dropping). This could lead to company failure and is not a theoretical risk
- DennisP 9y agoSure, if they end up selling the Model 3 at a loss they'll be in trouble, but I don't see any particular reason to think that'll happen. And most likely they'll be fine with lenders as long as they make the payments, which so far they seem perfectly able to do.
- aaavl2821 9y agoAgreed, they seem to be ok for now I don't know teslas model 3 unit production costs, but if you look at cost curves for other car companies as they scale up manufacturing, and take into account all the fixed costs and manual processes currently used in production of a small number of model 3s, the unit cost is probably massively high. Historically you can reduce those costs by 80%+ as you scale, so it is possible tesla can produce profitably. On the other hand, tesla set the price for its car before it started making it. So it's entirely possible that they were underestimating the cost / complexity of the manufacturing process and that they simply can't support their cost base with that price. Again, this is a hypothetical, but real concern More likely is they get there, but takes longer / more money than expected. And in a competitive world, that can be catastrophic We don't know which of these hypothetical scenarios will play out, so we must assess the likelihood that each happens and value the company that way. Current valuation suggests probabikty of success is very very high and value of success is very large; id argue that both those numbers should be lower
- mcguire 9y agoI'm not an accountant, and I don't have Tracey's (?) book on analysing financial statements handy but... Additional paid-in capital (https://finance.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ATSLA&fstype=ii&ei=lPMaWoidLYnHmAHr6LuAAQ https://finance.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ATSLA&fstype=ii...) went from $3.4B to $7.8B in 2016 to $9.0B as of 9/30. Issuance of stock provided $1.9B in 2016 and $0.5B so far this year (https://finance.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ATSLA&fstype=ii&ei=lPMaWoidLYnHmAHr6LuAAQ https://finance.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ATSLA&fstype=ii...). What happens when the currently-expected market correction hits and Tesla has a harder time going to the capital markets for money?
- xiphias 9y agoTheir Model S/X and battery divisions are profitable, so I guess they need to slow down Model 3 ramp-up (and future products) substantially, but they wouldn't go bankrupt. Another problem that can happen though is interest rates going up, which makes leasing much harder. Most of the buyers/leasers depend on these low interest rates I'm afraid.
- Someone 9y ago_If_ they are still performing as they are now when that happens, they will be in trouble. They predict to have a healthy cash flow from the model 3 soon, though. 5000 cars a week at the end of Q1 2018 would bring in at least $175M a week on income or, ballpark, in the range of a billion a year in margins. I don’t think that would be enough to warrant their share price, but it would be enough to keep the company running. (minor negative: $1000 of the money paid for each model 3 sold already is in their bank account)
- Retric 9y agoThey also get 1000$ from future model 3's before they are built, which reduces the impact. It's effectively a zero intrest loan and market validation, though eventually they are going to run out of customers willing to front that money.
- austenallred 9y agoIt’s funny to see everyone praise Amazon’s strategy of “invest everything you possibly can regardless of what the income statement looks like in the short-term. Tesla does the same thing and all anyone can say is “look at the income statement!” Granted there are some differences, but the strategy is the same.
- kamaal 9y agoFor people to see how this can be positive, some time needs to pass. Most people are tuned to think in terms of linear growth.
- nCwLABXpfJLz 9y agoExcept Tesla is almost never cash flow positive on an operating basis, while Amazon almost always has been. Tesla is financing their expansion (in addition to covering past loses) with new cash infusions, while Amazon financed their expansion with actual profits. Justifying Tesla losing money because of Amazon is a complete false equivalence.
- khaledtaha 9y agoI can't help but view Tesla as an ongoing kickstarter. This was made even more apparent in their latest unveiling. I say this as a fan of their vision, mission and current product offering.
- princeb 9y agoI see Tesla as a conduit for the wealthy to keep subsidising the technology for the middle class. In the same way that Uber is a way for the wealthy to pay for the commute of the middle class (cos let’s face it the poor aren’t taking cabs or buying EVs). For the sake of the community we need these vehicles of wealth transfer to keep existing. The moment companies like Uber and Tesla start making money, we need the visionaries to come in and start producing ever better products and services for ever collapsing prices.
- 9y ago
- IBM 9y agoWhat? Did you actually look at their cash flows? They are massively free cash flow negative, and it's only getting more negative every quarter. The only reason cash is up is because they regularly tap the capital markets with debt and equity, which is why Elon is constantly looking for new ways to boost the stock. The only way Tesla avoids bankruptcy is if the markets keep believing in the Elon magic, because the operations are definitely not financing the investment required. This is the key thing people miss when people falsely compare Tesla to Amazon. Amazon has always been free cash flow positive. They may never have turned a GAAP profit for many years, but they weren't issuing stock to finance their growth.
- aerovistae 9y agoYeah, because they didn't have to build out factories and 500,000 cars in order to grow. If they did, they would have tapped the markets too.
- IBM 9y agoAmazon's "factories" were fulfillment centers, data centers, and free shipping. All of which were extremely expensive.
- krschultz 9y agoThat's a complete misreading of Amazon. Their entire competitive advantage is having really cheap capital which enables unbelievable capital investment. First it was in distribution centers (3PL), then servers (AWS), and next likely be parcel delivery (look out FedEx). The e-commerce business is the first and best customer of each of these services, but they're basically a conglomerate of capital intensive low margin infrastructure services.
- dforrestwilson 9y ago^ Why was this down-voted? This analysis is correct. Tesla is on track to burn >$500m/quarter going forward and will once again have to access capital markets in 2018. Junk bond markets have been puking for the past 3 months, so that option probably is getting less likely. That leaves equity dilution. Not good for current shareholders. http://archive.fast-edgar.com//20171103/APA8Q22CZM22D262222M2WZ2BOKGZY22H292/ http://archive.fast-edgar.com//20171103/APA8Q22CZM22D262222M... A lot of the "Assets" noted on the balance sheet are the reservation costs for all of Tesla and Solar City's promised products. Tesla recently laid off a significant portion of their workforce at the Model 3 factory. Output was much lower than they had guided to for the quarter. It doesn't look like that's going to change soon. If customers start demanding refunds a lot of the assets listed on the balance sheet go away. The liabilities on the other hand, won't be going anywhere. People can insist that Tesla is effecting some positive changes in the world, but it seems to me that mostly they have been good at repackaging and reselling the tech of other companies in creative ways.
- pbhowmic 9y agoAgreed. This is a R&D heavy venture, hence the capital expenditure is high too. How can one fail to capture the fact that their intellectual-property portfolio is a store of their value, as are the factories and the market lead they have not just in self-driving EVs but in batteries & solar tech. This is one of the dumbest articles I have read in a long while. Money spent on NOT money up in smoke. Somebody give this guy a crash course in corporate finance.
- nCwLABXpfJLz 9y agoWhat market lead in self-driving EVs? Their lane-keep that occasionally veers out of the lane? The market leader in self-driving EVs is Cruise, and if you take away your EV qualifier, it's Waymo. The NUMMI factory is worth little. Automakers are unlikely to want to repurchase a CA factory due to all the regulations they would have to deal with. What solar tech? Solar City was an installation company, which Tesla bailed out and has been winding down. The solar freaking roof thing doesn't even exist yet--Tesla's reveal was a bunch of fake solar shingles. People will very generously give Tesla all kinds of benefit of the doubt, but these people might soon realize they don't know what they're talking about.
- nCwLABXpfJLz 9y agoIf you think they're fine, maybe look at cash flows a little closer. Cash flow is up half a billion because they just issued 1.8 billion in junk bonds (which are already trading in minus territory btw). Meanwhile operating cash flows are increasingly negative to the tune of hundreds of millions per quarter. Sure, they're fine if they continue to raise billions. But they're nowhere near profitable, and they're also going to continue to lose billions. What's going to happen if they receive a credit downgrade or institutional investors decide to stop playing along?
- colordrops 9y agoIt's just typical anti-Tesla propaganda.
- vectorEQ 9y agojust because they earn money ,doesnt mean it's their main goal. a lot of IT companies who are HUGE didnt even have a model to earn money. they just got a lot of it because they made something that was wanted by a lot of people.