3 ms·
> Linux desktop is on for the 86% if the train which only uses a browser ("Internet") Ugh. Stop it. Just stop it. It isn't the late 90s or early 2000s anymore.
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago
> Linux desktop is on for the 86% if the train which only uses a browser ("Internet")
Ugh. Stop it. Just stop it. It isn't the late 90s or early 2000s anymore. Hardly anyone uses a desktop computer just for the internet because that market is well served by phones and tablets. That segment of the market existed only for a brief time between the rising popularity of the internet and the invention of purpose built consumer devices for browsing the internet.
Linux Desktop community continues to prop up this strawman user because it is an easy target. Tell them something is wrong with how the OS works that's keeping people from wanting to use it and they'll point to their strawman and say "most people just browse the internet, and we can do that just fine, it must be something else!". Users hate your software? I'ts because they're drooling morons who don't understand it because they just use a computer to browse Facebook. It's a convenient ego-saving lie, like pretty much every excuse that comes out of the Linux desktop camp for why they aren't better. Excuses is what the Linux Desktop community is best at.
I could literally rant for hours about the problems with Linux as a desktop, but the short version is that it sucks because the community behind it sucks, and probably likes that it sucks because it allows them to feel smugly superior to all the "average" (read: drooling browser-only strawman) people.
Even when Linus himself bitches them out they don't pay attention:
"making binaries for Linux desktop applications is a major fucking pain in the ass. You don’t make binaries for Linux, you make binaries for Fedora 19, Fedora 20, maybe even RHEL5 from 10 years ago. You make binaries for Debian Stable…well actually no, you don't make binaries for Debian Stable because Debian Stable has libraries that are so old that anything built in the last century doesn’t work." --Linus Torvalds (DebConf 2014)
- atondwal 9y agoI don't think the "browser-only strawman" is condescending elitists dismissing users --- I'm a self-described GNU zealot on most days the only software I use on are apps like firefox, ssh, and vim and a few other bits like gnome/xmonad, liquid haskell, latex, and rustc. I have no clue how the "average person" uses a computer, but for me it really is all web. Hell, if I had consistent LTE on my laptop, I could very just spend the whole day in a full-screen firefox with a web-ssh connection to my work server for development.
- bunderbunder 9y agoAverage home user non-Internet use case # 0: Printing. If for no other reason, I will never suggest Linux as a desktop option to any of my non-IT-professional friends & family for this one reason. Use case # -1 would be "owning a laptop." Linux continues to be finicky on laptops - even when all the hardware works, you still end up with rando issues like poor battery life and fans that never turn off due to imperfect laptop power management. (That said, there is one version of Linux that has cracked both of these nuts for the case of people who really do just want to use the Web: Chrome OS. And I do recommend that to anyone I think it'll work for.)
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoIf you really were all-web, you would just use Chrome OS. As you said, though, you're actually a user of liquid haskell, latex, and rustc. In other words, either a computing hobbyist and/or developer.
- atondwal 9y agoThere are actually pretty decent webIDEs for all of those things (shareLaTeX's vim mode is pretty nice, too), and I did consider switching to a chromebook. I was actually about to buy one before I decided that the max 8GB of RAM was way too little for my usual browsing habits. That, and I'm dependent on some firefox addons that just don't have good chrome equivalents, so chromeOS is sort of a no-go. Edit: apparently there's a sizable segment of the market that agrees with both of us! > In the third quarter of 2016, Chromebooks made up 54% of computer shipments to K-12 classrooms in the United States, says IDC analyst Linn Huang. That market share figure even factors in iPads, which themselves have been successful in education. https://www.fastcompany.com/3067267/how-chromebooks-aim-to-finally-crack-the-consumer-market-in-2017 https://www.fastcompany.com/3067267/how-chromebooks-aim-to-f...
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoIf your argument is "most people don't need a desktop", then we're in agreement. So we should stop designing desktop OSs around them, right?
- BrandoElFollito 9y agoI honestly do not understand what you are talking about I am super lucky that my browser, Visual Code Studio and the Jetbrain suite works on Linux Desktop. My children downloaded Minecraft. Then double-clicked on it to start it. It opened an archive... WTF? How can a desktop environment can do that? Then they asked me how to start the game their friends play (Star Wars something) . Sorry kids - Windows only. So yes - people like me who have uber-restricted needs will be relatively fine - the others will be stuck. Try to get a complicated Excel sheet and open it on Linux, good luck. The community comment makes no sense: there is no Windows community either so what to compare?