3 ms·
> If you have Windows 10 Enterprise edition, all telemetry can be disabled. I remember reading that this common belief is wrong, but unfortunately I don't reme
by lucb1e 9y ago
> If you have Windows 10 Enterprise edition, all telemetry can be disabled.
I remember reading that this common belief is wrong, but unfortunately I don't remember where/who claimed that. Did it recently change, perhaps?
- userbinator 9y agoThat might be this: https://xato.net/windows-spying-and-a-twitter-rant-19203babb2e7 https://xato.net/windows-spying-and-a-twitter-rant-19203babb... It's so confusing to disable that a (admittedly self-proclaimed, but still) "security expert" got it wrong several times, and even after that it still continued sending data to Microsoft. It reminds me of the same scummy tricks used by spyware/adware in the past e.g. "do not disable for the best user experience", double-negative wording, etc. I believe it's still (deliberately) really easy to pirate/crack Windows, so I could get the Enterprise edition if I wanted --- but I wouldn't want it even if it was legally free, just like all sorts of other malware and unwanted software.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoNo doubt that it's easy to mess up Group Policies. He's not wrong in that you have to very clearly read each one's description because different policies expect you to do different things sometimes to do the same things. That's definitely not new to Windows 10, and arguably just bad design on Microsoft's part; there appears to be no standardized design pattern to how GPOs should function across the whole Windows team. But it is still entirely possible to disable all telemetry with it.
- m8urn 9y agoEven with Enterprise edition it is very difficult to disable all telemetry. The lowest official setting for telemetry is "security" which still sends data to Microsoft (see https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/configuration/configure-windows-telemetry-in-your-organization?f=255&MSPPError=-2147217396 https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/configuration/confi...). There are, however, a number of hacks that can trim that down even further. But being hacks they aren't guaranteed to always work--things frequently change. Since writing the article mentioned a couple comments up I have tried completely ripping out all telemetry components from the install CD, which seems to be the most effective option. Tools such as Blackbird (http://www.getblackbird.net/ http://www.getblackbird.net/) also are quite effective. Nonetheless, monitoring traffic still shows connections to Microsoft-controlled servers. There are so many ways Microsoft (and therefore possible governments) can gather--or at least infer--information about your system. To completely protect yourself would require manually monitoring, selecting, and installing updates, manually updating certificate revocation lists, constantly watching for new settings (including firewall and hosts entries) that must be addressed, etc. So no, it is not possible to completely disable all forms of Windows 10 telemetry without also committing to an unreasonable amount of work.