5 ms·
The people who believe it’s listening would never accept even the most ironclad “proof” that it’s not. This is a hallmark of conspiracy theorists. So why bothe
by paulcole 9y ago
The people who believe it’s listening would never accept even the most ironclad “proof” that it’s not. This is a hallmark of conspiracy theorists.
So why bother?
- superbrama 9y agoNot all people with such a belief are immutable in that view, nor are all conspiracy theorists. There’s value in debunking a myth that seems plausible to the masses. In this case, the myth is plausible, and enough people without sufficient critical thinking skills believe it, therefore it’s worth debunking consistently at least within the tech community.
- logicallee 9y agoI believe it's listening based on an overwhelming amount of anecdotal evidence reported all over the Internet. (Where there's smoke, there's fire.) Including by intelligent, scientifically-minded people. At the same time, it wouldn't take much at all for me to believe otherwise: a simple blinded test where some people leave their phones in a room, researchers come and talk about some subject (absent the owners), then leave without ever interacting with the owners of the phone. There are two ways to do the next part: The owners of the phone 1 week later could be asked if they've seen any facebook ads on (topic). A control group would have to be compared (where researchers didn't speak on the topic.) Alternatively, the subjects of the study could be given 5 random topics when commencing the study and asked to record any ads they've seen on any of the 5 topics. The researchers could then speak on 1 of the 5 topics (differing from person to person) and a statistical analysis could be performed. A "proof" is a statistically valid correlation between what the researchers talked about out and what the blinded subjects reported seeing ads about. A refutation is a lack of such a correlation. Easy, and it would convince me personally. By the way based on the anecdotal evidence I strongly expect this study to conclude "facebook is listening." - Note: there are a few loose ends to take care of. The researchers who are tasked with speaking on a subject are more likely to google it on their own phones. (Having been exposed to the topic), and those are in geographic vicinity. There are other similar possible mechanisms. Perhaps the best approach is if subjects' phones are in a sound-proof vault and the researchers' speech is either fed into it via speaker/microphone, or not done so, but the researchers do not know for any specific phone whether it is able to hear them. (Making the study "double-blind", as neither the subjects nor the researchers know whether the subjects' phones have heard anything on a subject.).
- paulcole 9y ago>an overwhelming amount of anecdotal evidence reported all over the Internet This is exactly why I believe pizzagate, am a 9/11 truther, etc.
- logicallee 9y agoPublic interpretation of shared information is not at all the same as anecdotal evidence! Don't conflate these two things. I know beans make people fart because of anecdotal evidence I've heard from different people. That doesn't make this "fact" wrong. On the other hand, interpretation of public information is quite different. - Aside: Also I have a small aside here for you personally. I'd like to remove something from your mind so that you never speak about it again. I don't want 9/11 truthers derided here on Hacker News because I consider the example to be one that should not be included here. Flat earthers? Sure. As for 9/11: I'm not a "9/11" truther. I've never called for an investigation into it. I don't care about it. But for you, if you care about this subject for some reason, the standard for whether you should be a 9/11 truther, in the sense that you believe anyone had any prior knowledge those acts would be committed, is whether you find any leaks to that effect by such a government official.[1] The standard regarding whether it is feasible for 9/11 to have included a controlled demolition is the opinion of civil engineers, whose profession this sort of thing is.[2] So while I can't speak for you, I do have my own standards. This does not mean I'm a 9/11 truther. I'd like you to stop using it as an example, though. Use things that are false (like flat earth) if you want to make some kind of cheap point, please. Note: I want to reiterate that I am in no way, shape, or form, a 9/11 truther. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6eMq5Rit1w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6eMq5Rit1w - "From about August 23rd, every night, until September 2nd, September 3rd." This insider says "We are never going to look for who they are, and it's probably not worth looking for them." Her Wikipedia page is quite credible as an insider. In addition it includes major smears on her character and a complete refutation over the official channels you would expect. She meets the standard outlined above. [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Architects_%26_Engineers_for_9/11_Truth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Architects_%26_Engineers_for_9... - "The organization has compiled a list of criteria for a controlled demolition that it says the collapse of the World Trade Center meets: the destruction followed the path of greatest resistance, the debris was symmetrically distributed, the rapid onset of the destruction, explosions and flashes reported by witnesses, steel elements were expelled from the building at high speed, the pulverization of the concrete, expanding pyroclastic clouds, lack of pancaked stories in the debris, isolated explosions 20 to 40 stories below the wave of destruction, molten steel and thermite traces found in the debris."