32 ms·
I wonder if I'm alone on this. For their examples, I do prefer the literal translation, and I can't stand the "localized" one. Why can't we have some respect f
by snvzz 9y ago
I wonder if I'm alone on this. For their examples, I do prefer the literal translation, and I can't stand the "localized" one.
Why can't we have some respect for the original work?
This is a bad trend in game translations, and sadly does extend further than that. I do hope it comes to pass.
- serf 9y agoI don't think you're alone in disliking translation 'liberties' , but I don't think most people really like literal translation either. A literal translation of many sentences from Japanese to English (and vice-versa) reorders words to the point of gibberish. Almost every idiom is broken without reinterpretation -- well except for the really good crude ones.
- ethbro 9y agoOr as I saw misattributed to Keynes in a comment here: "It is better to be vaguely right than exactly wrong." -Carveth Read With humility for one's own skills and respect for the author, there are many times a literal translation would not accomplish the author's intent (in the target language).
- x1798DE 9y agoI don't think anyone would argue for word-level translations without any grammar - that wouldn't even be possible, since there isn't a 1-1 mapping between words in different languages. But for a translation, I think most people want you to do the minimum possible to preserve the original meaning. So no switching "ramen" to "spaghetti" because you think people won't understand.
- snvzz 9y ago> A literal translation of many sentences from Japanese to English (and vice-versa) reorders words to the point of gibberish. To be clear, by not taking liberties what I meant is preserving both meaning and intent. So called localization does often screw with one or the other.
- cholantesh 9y agoEh, I remember watching a 'literal' fan translation of the scene in Dragon Ball Z where Majin Vegeta explains the impetus for his continuing feud with Goku. The script simply lacks power compared to the Funimation dub. I think it might be more respectful to the source material to consider intent, as opposed to linguistic parity.
- patio11 9y agoAll translation is a creative act and respect for the original work is likely going to counsel taking some liberties with regards to "literal" translations. Here's a line: > そんなに簡単に使えるものなのか、"魔法"ってヤツは? > Is this "magic" stuff really that easy to use? That is a literal translation, to a point, but it is a lossy translation. You've substantially lost the characterization of the solider, who is obviously lowborn/uneducated/crude/etc in the original (to a degree that "stuff" does not capture -- the giveaway is ってヤツは?, which is content-free and hence murderously difficult to translate). The shipped translation makes a nod in the direction of that characterization, and (correctly) captures that Solider B is the sophisticated one of the two, by a fair but not impossible margin. Also, to the extent you believe authorial intent is a function of authors rather than of texts, this translation (like many!) is a joint creative endeavor of the author and the translator, and (again, if you believe authorial intent matters) the author's direction trumps your aesthetic preferences. (Disclaimer: comment informed by professional experience as a J->E translator/interpreter.)