3 ms·
> Of course this makes sense, because handling bitcoins is mostly terrible. The fate of every bitcoin exchange, I often say around here, is to have its bitcoins
by mirimir 9y ago
> Of course this makes sense, because handling bitcoins is mostly terrible. The fate of every bitcoin exchange, I often say around here, is to have its bitcoins stolen, so CME is quite sensibly launching a bitcoin exchange without any bitcoins to be stolen.
This is a strawman. Only fools keep substantial Bitcoin balances in exchange wallets.
Edit: OK, fools and ordinary people. But this is an article about investors in Bitcoin futures. The author could have at least mentioned offline wallets. Also, it's true that you need exchange wallets for speculation. But there's the Kelly criterion, and you can keep most of your winnings offline.
- empath75 9y agoThere are a lot of fools.
- vesinisa 9y agoThough, there is no shortage of attacks against electronic wallets on personal computing devices either. The average, technologically moronic user might actually be safer storing his Bitcoin on a trustworthy exchange, as opposed to a personal wallet protected by a weak passphrase, if any, on the same computer/phone where he surfs, reads email and runs software of dubious origin. Best way to protect against unauthorized use of your funds, as the article notes, is to go really old school and print your private keys out on a piece of paper, and store it in a physical vault. Of course, none of this would be a problem if the exchange acted as a trusted ledger and could simply revert any unauthorized transactions on the user's funds. Like a traditional bank, but just with all the crypto hype!</s>
- mirimir 9y agoOne can have numerous Bitcoin wallets. I have dozens of active ones. I'm not a speculator, so I don't keep anything substantial in exchange accounts. Unless you're holding more than a few Bitcoin, you don't even need to go full offline. Linux VMs on Linux hosts are not likely pwned. You clearly wouldn't keep much on a phone.
- mdip 9y ago> Only fools keep substantial Bitcoin balances in exchange wallets. Or, "regular folks". My in-laws who have no idea what it actually is that they purchased use Coinbase and have no idea that doing so is not much better than giving your wallet to a stranger and asking them to keep the money safe and have it available when you want to go to McDonald's. Is it all that much better than them keeping it in a local wallet for them? I wouldn't trust my in-laws to keep their computer safe from the myriad of threats that the Internet has to offer. I wouldn't trust my parents to use a password more complicated than one originating from the Spaceballs movie to protect their private key (let alone them understand with any level of accuracy what a "private key" actually is). I'd put more faith in Coinbase handling that for them, despite being a radically larger target than they are as individuals. For us? Yeah, it's an insane proposition. My ETH lived in my Coinbase wallet from about the time that I noticed the transaction went from Pending to Completed to about the time it took me to fill out the form to turn it into cash to deposit into my savings account at my local bank. And the first time I used Coinbase, I moved the first couple of coins one at a time just to limit my losses if something went horribly wrong. The thing is, to secure it well, locally, you have to do quite a lot. My wallet keys and wallet aren't even stored on a computer -- I've got them on three encrypted thumb drives, one in a safe at my house, one in a safe at my parent's house and one handy. I fire up a VM started from a checkpoint just after installation (after running updates) which itself is stored on an encrypted volume when I need to move money from my wallet to reduce the risk that my machine was compromised with something looking for those keys -- ready to swipe them on access[0]. My parents inherently trust the software and their computer to not become their enemy and wouldn't take even the most basic precautions around protecting their key from loss (Hi, son, I was wondering how to reset my password on my wallet; I forgot it) let alone protect their key from folks who write malware designed to steal it. [0] All the while not being sure something exists out there for ETH, but knowing that if the price continues to go where it's going, it absolutely will.
- mirimir 9y agoOK, but are your in-laws holding substantial amounts? A little searching provides options for safe storage: https://www.coindesk.com/information/how-to-store-your-bitcoins/ https://www.coindesk.com/information/how-to-store-your-bitco... https://medium.com/@nellsonx/how-to-properly-store-bitcoins-and-other-cryptocurrencies-14e0db1910d https://medium.com/@nellsonx/how-to-properly-store-bitcoins-...