3 ms·
It is appealing for three reasons. 1) As computer engineers we understand it's doable. Give it a couple of centuries and our civilization could reach a comput
by elorant 9y ago
It is appealing for three reasons.
1) As computer engineers we understand it's doable. Give it a couple of centuries and our civilization could reach a computing capacity to simulate the entire observable universe
2) A lot of things just don't make sense. Like consciousness for example. We can't define it, and we don't even know it it's real. If you take consciousness out of the equation humans are just laborious software.
3) This is objective of course, but quite a lot of people are experiencing coincidences that seem unreal. That sounds metaphysics and most of us wouldn't touch it with a barge pole but from a simulation perspective makes total sense.
Oh and it makes a lot of people uncomfortable. For me it's one of the best ways to test someone's intellect. You bring it into a conversation and people start feeling unease.
- andrepd 9y ago> Give it a couple of centuries and our civilization could reach a computing capacity to simulate the entire observable universe This is not even remotely true, not even if a perfect Moore's law were to continue for thousands of years. Man, we're hard pressed to even simulate single molecules. > quite a lot of people are experiencing coincidences that seem unreal Oh come on x) "Coincidences" are psychological illusions and misatribution biases at work, not the work of an intelligence behind our universe. This is the "I prayed to god and my back pain healed; it's a miracle" type of thinking.
- danbruc 9y agoAs computer engineers we understand it's doable. Give it a couple of centuries and our civilization could reach a computing capacity to simulate the entire observable universe This seems at the very least questionable. Why do you think you can simulate the entire universe just using a tiny fraction of the resources of the universe? It seems to me that could only work if the universe were highly compressible and I don't see any obvious evidence for that. And even then I think it could not work because if the universe is in some sense redundant and could be compressed then it actually provides less resources to work with than if it would not have those redundancies. Take as an analogy for the later two processors executing the same code in lockstep as it is sometimes done for redundancy in safety critical systems. You can mostly get away with only simulating one of the processors but you essentially also only have one processor to work with. And while you can probably simulate the processors on the processors the simulation will probably be at least ten times slower than the actual processor if you only want to use one tenth of the available resources, i.e. clock cycles. And finally memory will be a real problem because you only have as much memory available as you want to simulate.
- chr1 9y agoYou don't need to simulate the entire universe, just the tiny bit where interesting things are happening (read surface of earth), places farther away can be simulated with much lower precision as long as they look plausible. In that sense the universe is indeed highly compressible as it is mostly empty/uninteresting. The question is how large computing device is needed to simulate a brain, and whether that device can be digital or analog. If the size of such device can be comparable to the size of human body, then we can create a useful simulation.
- danbruc 9y agoThe part of the universe that is empty also provides nothing you can use for a computer to run a simulation on, i.e. you don't have to simulate it but it doesn't help running the simulation either. And given that we probe the entire visible universe looking at gravitational waves from across the galaxy, spectral lines in the light of galaxies at the other end of the universe, and the decay products of Higgs particles, you still need a quite good simulation or good heuristic approximations for a lot of stuff in order to not produce inconsistencies. Or you have to limit what your simulated humans can do and keep them actively away from discovering your speed optimizations. Faking parts of something as complex as our universe without it becoming obvious would probably not be a small feat.
- elorant 9y agoFor all we know, 99,999% of the universe could be just a projection. You don't need to simulate all of it down to the proton level, just the things we can see. And the reason our cosmological theories fail miserably in things like dark matter or dark energy could be because there's really nothing out there.
- danbruc 9y agoIf 99.999 % of the universe is fake, than you only have to simulate 0.001 % of the universe but you also only have 0.001 % of a universe to turn into a computer and run a simulation on.
- tbtowzhtow 9y agoWhat coincidences? I have mine, a lifetimes worth, but there isn’t a framework for saying whether my experiences are somehow special and contrived by a higher intelligence, part of a simulated universe or something else, or just a misunderstood manifestation of some not yet discovered physical law. As far as I know, science doesn’t offer a technique to quantify what we experience as coincidence (beyond the trivial prayer for health example) in any way that evidentially supports the existence of a higher intelligence or design. We’ve replaced superstitions systematically with science, and this trend seems unlikely to change, although a merger of sorts seems an inevitable destination. Experience is often personal and difficult to express using known human communication techniques, much less quantify scientifically. Heck, we can’t even agree on whether there is a hard problem. These explorations for new approaches to quantum physics simply give hope for further understanding of reality that we may have already considered (simulation theory, for instance) or others we have not. Fun to speculate, though, in the meantime. As an aside, maybe religious folks are right, maybe MWI is true and heaven and hell exist in the multiverse. What’s possible in the mind can overwhelm to the point of shutdown given the right set of perceptions, and coincidence can certainly drive a person to insanity (or enlightenment) if crafted carefully enough. You can claim aliens contacted you, or that you have perceptions and experiences giving blindingly in-your-face obvious (to you) indication of some kind of contrived, controlled or influenced reality, but you’d better have science to back it up.