3 ms·
Yes, but also this scheme is best rejected as being too convoluted. 1) Someone needs to assess pre-accident prices of every house. That isn't as easy as it sou
by roenxi 9y ago
Yes, but also this scheme is best rejected as being too convoluted.
1) Someone needs to assess pre-accident prices of every house. That isn't as easy as it sounds, it is a massive logistic challenge (and open to corruption from all angles).
2) This links a nuclear company's performance (after a disaster) to the property market, where they have no inherent expertise. That isn't fair or sensible.
3) If the company has to pay some sort of transactions tax on housing (eg, as is the case in Australia) then they are facing enormous costs even if the market value doesn't change.
4) The vast sums of money involved would probably bankrupt them for cash flow reasons even if the whole transaction were notionally profitable.
5) All of this doesn't even incentivise good behavior. May as well pass a law that if things go wrong the company gets wound up - same basic result (this is not a good idea either imo).
Also, the people who are concerned about trading dollars for lives probably don't want to become regulators [1]. We don't know how to run a 0-death society and there are decisions that must be made in practice. Valuing life with money is a great way of doing that.
[1] https://www.theglobalist.com/the-cost-of-a-human-life-statistically-speaking/ https://www.theglobalist.com/the-cost-of-a-human-life-statis...
- mikeash 9y ago1) This is a tiny problem compared to the damage caused by the accident. 2) It's absolutely sensible that the financial performance of a company that could cause massive damage to surrounding property would be linked to the value of that surrounding property, unless you don't think people should pay for the damage they cause. 3) So, don't do that? If we're talking about a potential change in the legal framework, "but the law would make it impractical" isn't a sensible objection. Exempt this stuff from the transaction tax if needed. 4/5) If the cost would potentially exceed what the company can pay, then require them to carry liability insurance. That's what we do for cars, and it works out pretty well both in terms of incentivizing good behavior and ensuring that victims can be compensated even when the damages exceed the perpetrator's ability to pay. I'm not against trading dollars for lives. I just want the people who own the lives in question to be the ones making the decision whenever possible. That's not always feasible, but this is a case where it looks quite feasible.
- yongjik 9y ago>> 1) Someone needs to assess pre-accident prices of every house. That isn't as easy as it sounds, it is a massive logistic challenge (and open to corruption from all angles). > This is a tiny problem compared to the damage caused by the accident. For many people, the land and house they own is pretty much the total sum of their wealth. (Or even more, if they took mortgage.) If you think this is a "tiny problem", you underestimate the lengths people will go to protect the values of their properties. I've seen news of people committing suicide over a high-power voltage line going over their town. You visit a town struck by a nuclear disaster and claim you will assess the "fair market value" of every house, you'd better bring in riot gears.
- mikeash 9y agoAnd making everyone evacuate, or telling everyone to stay put and accept some compensation for the chance of dying from some horrible radiation-induced disease, would go better?
- yongjik 9y agoYes, because when people are hit by a nuclear disaster, the last thing they need is to get drawn into a bitter, decade-long feud between two halves of the town, the "sellers" and the "remainers". And that's what your policy will bring about. If you don't see why, imagine you own a home and the assessor says "Really? But your house is not any better than your neighbor's, and they have agreed to the price of $1M. Don't be so unreasonable."
- mikeash 9y agoImagine being told “We have calculated that this accident will subtract 9 months of life from everyone in this house, which according to our guidelines is worth $300,000. Here’s your check, enjoy your cancer.”