5 ms·
Does the new Firefox have a password sync feature like Chrome's? I'd much rather trust Mozilla with that sort of thing (especially if I could host my own backen
by robertlagrant 9y ago
Does the new Firefox have a password sync feature like Chrome's? I'd much rather trust Mozilla with that sort of thing (especially if I could host my own backend to it somewhere) than Google.
As an aside, one silly thing that tarnished Mozilla's brand for me was the treatment of Brendan Eich. I may not agree with his donation of money but I think impinging on his rights is a far more fundamental immorality than what he was accused of.
It's like Twitter's controversy over blue ticks. If they'd only given them as a result of identity verification, and not used them to indicate Twitter's approval of someone's beliefs, then they wouldn't be where they are now.
Stick to good tech and fighting for relevant causes, e.g. net neutrality, I say.
- rebelwebmaster 9y agoThe thing with Brendan happened ~3 years ago now. A lot of the leadership that was there at the time is gone now. How long should Mozilla be punished for that?
- robertlagrant 9y agoNo one is being punished - I'm not their parent not their government. Which is sort of my original concern. Mozilla was neither of those things to Brendan Eich, and yet more and more we see employers and influencers behaving as though they are.
- ChrisSD 9y agoI don't mean to rehash old arguments but in his position he was representing Mozilla. And Mozilla is an advocacy organisation with a deep interest in policy. They aren't just a browser maker; Firefox is merely their most widely known campaign. If the organisation felt he didn't represent them then it doesn't make sense for him to be CEO. It would have been less of an issue if he were in a more purely technical role.
- robertlagrant 9y agoThat's my point - I don't want them to spend their money on being a general-purpose morality organisation. I want a browser maker who specifically argues for the most foundational and important of needs regarding the internet. I don't want a social justice crusader who values PR above all.
- BrendanEich 9y agoAh, the acceptable bigotry of "those [people in my outgroup] can be CTOs but not CEOs". Well done. In fact, my leaving had nothing to do with advocacy _per se_. As Erin Kissane wrote at the time, if Mozilla were to become a narrow "progressive" advocacy group, it would fail at its stated mission. Whether it has taken or will take that fall, I won't attempt to evaluate here. But that's the risk Erin cited, and I agree.
- ikurei 9y ago> Does the new Firefox have a password sync feature like Chrome's? It's had that for years, and I'm yet to have a problem with it. > As an aside, one silly thing that tarnished Mozilla's brand for me was the treatment of Brendan Eich. I may not agree with his donation of money but I think impinging on his rights is a far more fundamental immorality than what he was accused of. I can't decide if what they did was wrong or not, but I'm not totally comfortable with that issue either... no person or company is perfect though.
- skellera 9y agoDoes it still allow you to see the password in the settings? I think that’s a not so great idea. I remember messing with friends by getting their saved passwords.
- tokenizerrr 9y agoYes. The same as Chrome. As it should be. If they weren't in the UI, you could just extract them from the browser's data files or process memory. All that preventing access does is annoy users and give them a false sense of security.
- andrewaylett 9y agoIf you set a master password, you need to type it again to see the saved passwords.
- pletnes 9y agoYes, it had that for years - including master password protection.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoFirefox Sync can sync passwords across desktop/mobile.
- 4bpp 9y ago> As an aside, one silly thing that tarnished Mozilla's brand for me was the treatment of Brendan Eich. I may not agree with his donation of money but I think impinging on his rights is a far more fundamental immorality than what he was accused of. Well, and Chrome's maker fired someone for a certain inflammatory manifesto. I don't think that at this point it is realistic to run a tech company of any sort in the US without some amount of displays of political loyalty to the vocal majority of your recruitment and customer base.
- Frondo 9y agoEich did not have his rights impinged on. He chose to resign--he chose that--because the community far beyond Mozilla didn't approve of his donations and he saw that he'd lost a lot of people's trust in him. His actions had consequences, which he recognized and owned. He has, presumably, gone on to find other work, after resigning, he still has a platform, he can still talk and associate freely. You can dislike the fact that he resigned, but blaming anyone for his actions but him doesn't make sense.
- greggarious 9y ago>Eich did not have his rights impinged on. He chose to resign--he chose that--because the community far beyond Mozilla didn't approve of his donations and he saw that he'd lost a lot of people's trust in him. His actions had consequences, which he recognized and owned. Yes, this is a key point people forget. No one fired Eich. However, a large chunk of Mozilla's open source contributors (along with a decent chunk of their paid employees) were ready to resign. Eich may not have had good politics, but he legitimately cared about the organization and was not going to let it implode on his account. Funny how so-called-libertarians love at will employment until it's used to pressure a bigot to resign.
- bzbarsky 9y ago> However, a large chunk of Mozilla's open source contributors (along with a decent chunk of their paid employees) were ready to resign. Citation, please. I'm a Mozilla employee, and was a Mozilla employee at the time. I'm not going to claim everyone was ecstatic about things; there was a lot of soul-searching going on for some people. But I don't recall any "Mozilla employees", in the sense of people working for the Mozilla Corporation, saying they would resign, nor calling for Brendan to do so. There _were_ a few such calls from interns, and a few employees, at the Mozilla Foundation. People who were not involved in Firefox in any way, did not know Brendan, and were not relevant to the things that Mozilla is actually known for doing. Of course the press spun the story in such a way as to make it seem like there was mass unhappiness internally... And most people read the press spin, not the actual blog posts actual Mozilla employees were writing at the time.
- sjellis 9y ago"As an aside, one silly thing that tarnished Mozilla's brand for me was the treatment of Brendan Eich. I may not agree with his donation of money but I think impinging on his rights is a far more fundamental immorality than what he was accused of." It wasn't about his rights as a private person. It was that he gave a non-trivial amount of financial support to a campaign to remove rights from other people, which did not seem consistent with the values of the non-profit that he wanted to publicly represent as CEO.
- BrendanEich 9y agoFlat wrong on "remove rights". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14845509 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14845509