5 ms·
A lot of the response focuses on the questionable morality of making this decision for the people who will be affected, and trading dollars for lives. Maybe we
by mikeash 9y ago
A lot of the response focuses on the questionable morality of making this decision for the people who will be affected, and trading dollars for lives.
Maybe we should shortcut that whole issue. Unlike most instances of pollution, we have a case where a single entity is clearly responsible for the contamination. That entity should be required to offer a buy-out of all property in the affected area at pre-accident market prices. They can then resell at whatever price they can obtain. If the damage caused by the contamination is small, the difference between the prices will be small, and their loss will be small. If their victims don’t think it’s worth moving at all, the loss will be zero since nobody will accept the offer.
Something tells me that this idea will be rejected as being too expensive, which should be quite telling.
- rlpb 9y agoThis will only work in a market with perfect information. When it comes to anything nuclear, I don't think it is controversial to state that this most definitely is not the case. The point of scientific study into this kind of thing is exactly what we need to be objective as a society, and this should be encouraged.
- mikeash 9y agoI don't think imperfect information would be an insurmountable obstacle for this. If people overestimate the damage caused by the contamination, they'll take the buyout. People who think the damage is less important will then be able to buy that property. The net effect will be a migration of people scared of contamination away from the contaminated areas, and of people who don't care about it toward the contaminated areas, which seems fine. In the event that everyone is overly scared of it, then the region will depopulate and the owner of the nuclear plant will be on the hook. They'll owe much more than the damage they actually caused, but I don't see a problem with this. There's no inherent right to damage someone else's health without their consent and then insist that they're wrong about how much the damage is worth. I'm all for objective scientific study into the actual dangers of this stuff. But the cited study goes well beyond that and makes a normative claim that relocation is bad policy. By all means, let's educate everyone on the true dangers of this stuff. Then let's allow them to decide for themselves whether it's worth staying or going. If the argument is that the populace is too ignorant to correctly make that decision, then fix that. I'm very much in favor of nuclear power, but stuff like this doesn't help at all. It's true that people are ignorant of the true dangers, but this isn't going to convince them. "Don't evacuate, it won't kill THAT many of you" doesn't sound like someone making decisions in your own best interests.
- rlpb 9y ago> In the event that everyone is overly scared of it, then the region will depopulate and the owner of the nuclear plant will be on the hook. Right. I don't think there will be enough people in the region interested in repopulating. > They'll owe much more than the damage they actually caused, but I don't see a problem with this. There's no inherent right to damage someone else's health without their consent and then insist that they're wrong about how much the damage is worth. I disagree with you here. You're relying on some subjective assessment of what the damage is worth, which I think is uncontroversially an irrational overestimate. Instead, I think it is entirely appropriate for studies to attempt to quantify, objectively, the real value of the damage.
- mikeash 9y agoCan there be anything but a subjective estimate of what someone's health and life are worth? We have to put a dollar value on lives in many cases because it's impractical to let each person choose individually. Normal pollution regulations are a good example of this. You'll look at the economic value of lives saved versus economic value of the pollution controls and see which one wins. But I don't see that a nuclear accident requires this. The affected area is relatively small, the damage is already done and can't be reversed, and there's a single responsible party. It becomes practical to handle it economically rather than having the government dictate a solution.
- rlpb 9y ago> Can there be anything but a subjective estimate of what someone's health and life are worth? The requirement is that society reaches an agreement on what that estimate is. Relying solely on the estimate of the victims [and other local people] is not reasonable. There needs to be an equitable way of determining a value. Dismissing studies trying to establish an approach to this is not the way. Sure, it still has to be subjective. But the line between subjectivity and objectivity is a spectrum. More objectivity is possible, and dismissing this out of hand because complete objectivity is not possible is not reasonable.
- Retric 9y ago> market prices I would expect a rather large premium to be associated with a forced sale of any kind. Remember, if they where willing to sell at market rates they would have been sold. I am of the opinion that forced sales like this should provide ~2-3x market rates to reduce the need for such sales, and provide for the loss of property like cars which need to be abandoned if contaminated.
- news_to_me 9y agoThey could just be forced to make the offer instead, and if the original owner is willing to accept the damage, they can refuse to sell.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gpm 9y agoThen they are going to make offers at post-accident-market rates not pre-accident-market...
- mikeash 9y agoI had a similar thought. I think the important point is offering some sort of equitable buyout rather than just deciding for everybody. The details of exactly how much an equitable buyout would consist of are somewhat less important.
- OscarCunningham 9y ago>Something tells me that this idea will be rejected as being too expensive, which should be quite telling. Nah, it'll be rejected because you will be interpreted as saying that it's okay for poor people to be exposed to dangerous radiation. People view health as a "sacred" value that no one should be forced to trade for money, even if they want to. EDIT: See what I mean.
- hobs 9y agoThat is because it is inherently exploitative to ask poorer people to trade their health for money, as they simply will only have so much money to pay. When only the rich can afford to live the sacredness of this value starts to become apparent.
- roenxi 9y agoYes, but also this scheme is best rejected as being too convoluted. 1) Someone needs to assess pre-accident prices of every house. That isn't as easy as it sounds, it is a massive logistic challenge (and open to corruption from all angles). 2) This links a nuclear company's performance (after a disaster) to the property market, where they have no inherent expertise. That isn't fair or sensible. 3) If the company has to pay some sort of transactions tax on housing (eg, as is the case in Australia) then they are facing enormous costs even if the market value doesn't change. 4) The vast sums of money involved would probably bankrupt them for cash flow reasons even if the whole transaction were notionally profitable. 5) All of this doesn't even incentivise good behavior. May as well pass a law that if things go wrong the company gets wound up - same basic result (this is not a good idea either imo). Also, the people who are concerned about trading dollars for lives probably don't want to become regulators [1]. We don't know how to run a 0-death society and there are decisions that must be made in practice. Valuing life with money is a great way of doing that. [1] https://www.theglobalist.com/the-cost-of-a-human-life-statistically-speaking/ https://www.theglobalist.com/the-cost-of-a-human-life-statis...
- mikeash 9y ago1) This is a tiny problem compared to the damage caused by the accident. 2) It's absolutely sensible that the financial performance of a company that could cause massive damage to surrounding property would be linked to the value of that surrounding property, unless you don't think people should pay for the damage they cause. 3) So, don't do that? If we're talking about a potential change in the legal framework, "but the law would make it impractical" isn't a sensible objection. Exempt this stuff from the transaction tax if needed. 4/5) If the cost would potentially exceed what the company can pay, then require them to carry liability insurance. That's what we do for cars, and it works out pretty well both in terms of incentivizing good behavior and ensuring that victims can be compensated even when the damages exceed the perpetrator's ability to pay. I'm not against trading dollars for lives. I just want the people who own the lives in question to be the ones making the decision whenever possible. That's not always feasible, but this is a case where it looks quite feasible.
- 9y ago