4 ms·
Exactly. The biggest real example I know of is ring species. Everything else seems to be total handwaving. In fact "evolution" is just an umbrella term for many
by EGreg 9y ago
Exactly. The biggest real example I know of is ring species. Everything else seems to be total handwaving. In fact "evolution" is just an umbrella term for many different theories about how speciation happens.
I have no problem with the theory of common ancestry. That has a lot of proof. But the idea that speciation happens EXCLUSIVELY by random mutation and "natural selection" is just handwaving theorizing. It's super hard to prove and we haven't even begun to get close to what constitutes as a proof. It's on the level of ancient people thinking the ONLY way to get fire is by rubbing some sticks together.
And yet I see the latter ("natural selection") being used by many in the scientific community to suppress other theories even though it is completely handwavy and vague. That is bullying.
Basically common descent can be rigorously defined and shown. The PROCESS by which speciation happens is poorly understood and has been a subject of much posturing by the scientific community (including popularizers like Dawkins) for decades.
(PS: if you're going to knee jerk downvote this because it criticizes "evolution", at least address it with substance.)
- Retric 9y agoWhat is your specific objection? Their is plenty of examples where even short term separation results in population drift: EX: Skin tone among native Americans is unique even with only ~1,000 generations separating the land bridge from modern times. In the short term this may be adaptation to a new envornment but eventually random mutation takes over. Their is evidence that closely related members may have difficulty breading with anything from 1% reductions in fertility to 99%. Which arguably makes them the same species as they can still in theory breed. However, adaptation can make it's own issues. Grizzly's + Polar bears is a solid example where offspring is fertile but poorly adapted to either of their parents environment. So, now you have examples of drops in fertility and reductions in reproductive success as populations are separated. Nothing is going to stop this process from hitting zero net fertility and thus a new species.
- EGreg 9y agoMy objection is just that: genetic drift != speciation. They are still completely interfertile with Europeans after 1000 generstions! Yet here we have a breathless article reporting noting more than an existing male from a "separate species", which is in fact interfertile and had viable offspring, as being proof of "evolution"! We don't know how speciation happens, and many people including scientists use a lot of unscientific "just so" stories. To claim we know that every instance of speciation happens through 1. random mutation and 2. "natural selection", a catch-all term which is not well-defined and signifies very little, is not very scientific. But worse than that, it is then conflated with the theory of common descent, and the emergent sociological result is that many scientists and non-scientists constantly co-opt the word "evolution" to say "evolution is true and creationism is therefore false" or whatever. There have been different theories such as punctuated equilibria but we don't actually KNOW how speciation happens. It's all posturing and catch-all terms.
- Retric 9y ago1,000 generations is an incredibly short period ed: genetically. Dinosaurs to people is ~20,000,000 generations depending on changes in reproductive cycles likely significantly more than that. The shocking thing is how many differences showed up not that we are still mostly though again not 100% comparable. Remember, fertility treatments among young people are a thing and incompatibility first shows up as an increase in the natural abortion (miscarriage) rate ~(30% to 50%). You can find set's of people such that A/B and C/D are more fertile than A/D or C/B.
- EGreg 9y agoRight, but how do you get from that, say, to cats and dogs? Or the evolution of wings? In the former, you need to have some sort of event that separates the populations for millions of generations or they'd constantly be interbreeding. But allopatric speciation examples are few and far between. OR, you know, there could be ANOTHER mechanism besides random mutation and "natural selection" (handwavy term) that causes speciation. In the latter, how a morphological feature came to evolve when the intermediate steps would have most likely been valleys in the fitness function is an interesting question. Proto-wings do not seem to confer any evolutionary advantage other than the speculative one trotted out by people who must have the development of morphological features proceed ONLY by random mutation and natural selection. No one is disputing those two things take place. The question is whether they explain ALL SPECIATION.
- Retric 9y agoMany kinds of protowings are useful and currently exist. Feathers for example provide great insulation. Flying squirrels demonstrate another example. Important to note with flying squirrel vs bats is being even slightly better at flying is useful for squirrels. From their being slightly better at falling to flight is a steady improvement. Even normal squirrels splay their hips sideways to catch air and glide somewhat: http://feedingnature.com/how-high-can-a-squirrel-jump-off-the-ground/ http://feedingnature.com/how-high-can-a-squirrel-jump-off-th... Even their tails get into the act. Flying fish similarly benefit from jumping out of the water, as part of a continuum of other fish that jump slightly further than normal out of the water etc. Even seemingly useless stubby wings provide for threat displays like a Cobra's hood. Aka, I can make my self look bigger without needing to grow big. Evolution is often just as much about removing things as adding. So, intermediate form may look clunky and then get cleaned up at a local optimum. PS: Insects provide some great examples of wings with various amounts of utility.
- rf15 9y agoAgreed, and it's depressing to see that so many people see any disagreement with "natural selection pressure and mutation is the sole method for formation of new species" (despite these two being rather hand-wave-y in parts) as anti-scientific.
- Scarblac 9y agoThe problem is with the concept of species. It's a very informal concept, introduced because we like to categorize.
- macspoofing 9y ago>But the idea that speciation happens EXCLUSIVELY by random mutation and "natural selection" is just handwaving theorizing. What alternative mechanisms are there?
- EGreg 9y agoWho knows. But we shouldn't use an argument from ignorance to say "X did it".
- sago 9y agoI downvoted you (sorry, It's not often I do), and it wasn't knee-jerk. Because: 1. In both your comments on this thread you seem to want to relitigate some beef with 'random mutation and natural selection', even though that wasn't the point of, and isn't directly relevant to the article cited, Which is about the (predicted, but now for the first time observed) role of hybridisation in speciation. 2. You seem to have left your understanding of the mechanisms of evolution somewhere in the 1970s. I did my PhD in the 1990s, and I don't recognise "The idea that speciation happens EXCLUSIVELY by random mutation in natural selection" [caps yours], Except -- to be honest -- from historic papers and antievolution websites (though I'm very willing to believe it is a misunderstanding shared by journalists). Certainly the people I studied with had a much more nuanced view of evolutionary dynamics, not to mention one that didn't assume sexual reproduction or closed species. 3. Proof is for mathematicians. Obsession with proving evolution is again, something I only know from creationist rhetoric. 4. Citation needed for your bullying claim. There are certainly some who think natural selection is the most important mechanism in evolutionary change, there are those who would emphasise genetic drift, they go to the same conferences. Your image of the state of the science is fiction, in my experience. (Though I've been out of academia for 15yrs).