3 ms·
So these "new" birds are distinct from all the other birds on the island that they form a separate breeding group. But how distinct are they from the outsider t
by phkahler 9y ago
So these "new" birds are distinct from all the other birds on the island that they form a separate breeding group. But how distinct are they from the outsider that started it all? Would they breed with birds from that birds home island? If so, I'd say they're not really a new species but a displaced species that survived one generation of interbreeding with the locals.
While certainly interesting, I wouldn't say this is a great example of speciation. One might even argue that it's an invasive species.
- bsmithers 9y agoWhether or not the speciation is "complete" is not really the point - the title of the article says they are "...caught in the act of becoming new species" - in fact the article highlights the difficulty in stating what determines something to be a separate species.
- phkahler 9y agoI'm just saying they may well be an outside species as opposed to a new one. There is certainly no new genetic material or variation that arose.
- 627467 9y agoThe beautiful thing about Life (and it's complexities) is how fluid and continuous (as opposed to stratified and segregated) it is. Depending at what scale (in size and time) you observe, we are all one species. Even in biology there are multiple definition of species. It shows how hard it is to pigeon-hole Life.