3 ms·
Current FCC plans run afoul of anti-trust law since they would allow monopolistic ISPs who own the physical network and services like video, to harm competitors
by shmerl 9y ago
Current FCC plans run afoul of anti-trust law since they would allow monopolistic ISPs who own the physical network and services like video, to harm competitors (which provide over the top services that have to go through the above physical network) by using data caps, interconnection blocking and other anti-competitive approaches. How is that not a serious legal argument?
- notacoward 9y agoOne answer might be that it's a serious legal argument not under the FCC's purview. FCC has an interest in keeping communications media from discriminating, but anti-competitive behavior and many other aspects of what we think of as net neutrality fall under FTC instead. It was always a bit of a stretch for FCC to be taking the lead on this. It might even be better to let FTC lead on this, because they have authority FCC does not to regulate parties other than the connectivity providers. For example, they can forbid Google from using their market position in other areas to gain a competitive advantage with their own connectivity services. They can keep a close eye on Netflix's attempts to compete with or blackmail providers over CDNs. That might be real network neutrality, not the one-sided vision heavily promoted by content providers.
- TehCorwiz 9y agoCan you show an instance where the FTC has actually done this in practice? Currently, Joseph Simons, a long-time corporate anti-trust lawyer heads the FTC. We can expect a light touch from them for the time being. Removing a protection that has been respected either formally or informally since the inception or Arpanet would radically change the face of the internet regardless of how you slice it. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Preventing misbehavior by regulating the industry saves both time and energy on the parts of consumers as well as corporations.
- shmerl 9y agoThe problem with FTC is that they have an awful track record of handling such issues. FCC's NN rules while being incomplete actually managed to fix real abuse such as interconnection slowdown by Verizon and others. Pushing it to FTC would simply let this whole thing rot away, while following a formality. The problem of course is simply the fact that whole anti-trust regulation in US is messed up.
- mc32 9y agoIf true this might inform big tech's position with respect to net neutrality. It seemed a bit off that the FBs, Googs, and other big user facing tech cos would want the FCC and not the FTC in charge.
- shmerl 9y agoI think the reason is dysfunction of FTC. They claim they handle such cases on individual basis instead of establishing clear rules. It doesn't sound like an efficient approach to me.
- wmf 9y agoThe FCC says that they will allow the FTC to crack down on any anti-competitive practices. Now we need to hold them to that.
- shmerl 9y agoThat's their sneaky excuse for "nothing will be done to handle that, prepare for monopolistic dystopia, folks".
- indubitable 9y agoThe anti-trust behavior itself would run foul of laws, not the FCC plans. This is really the fundamental point of Pai's argument, at least so far as I can read it. Is that instead of creating an extensive set of 'preemptive' rules that are not necessarily forward looking. For throughout limited near future services like satellite or balloon internet, throttling/blocking/etc will almost certainly be necessary. The current rules, at least he ones written under Wheeler, had a completely undefined "reasonable network management" exception allowing companies to break any rule, but that's a somewhat uncomfortable clause to rely on when you're investing tens of billions of dollars. So instead of writing hundreds of pages of static rules which can arguably interfere with competition or innovation, deal with bad behavior as it emerges through the proper channels. And in many cases that bad behavior would not be managed by the FCC - as you mention we already actually have pretty reasonable anti-trust law as well as consumer protections. And organizations like the EFF would certainly be on the forefront of making sure these protections are utilized to the max potential allowed by the law.
- shmerl 9y agoSince FCC facilitates that monopolistic behavior, there is a strong legal argument against it. That was the point. Pai has no valid argument. He basically says: "We should let monopolists run amok by removing current rules. Get lost if you don't like it". That's because dealing with monopolistic abuse through "proper channels" produced close to zero results in the past. And somehow EFF are rarely involved in anti-trust issues. I wonder why.