4 ms·
The author seems to be unaware of the long-explored concept of "Last thursdayism" (described in e.g. https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Last_Thursdayism https://rati
by PeterisP 9y ago
The author seems to be unaware of the long-explored concept of "Last thursdayism" (described in e.g. https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Last_Thursdayism https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Last_Thursdayism) - any argument that would apply for a world that's created 10000 years ago with all the fossils already "placed there" would also apply for a world created yesterday with all of us (and our memories) placed there.
- lurcio 9y agoNo need for the fossils to be "placed there" as they would surely be ante-diluvian evidence in any coherent creationism.(2 Peter 3:5-6, among others) Thanks for the Thursdayism link. Didn't know idea had been monikered. I first saw this as a young lad in Russell - the shilling shocker iirc. Or perhaps,...
- kbenson 9y agoI think the targeted audience is important. This reads as an explanation of Last Thursdayism and why even if we were all created a week ago seems plausible to you why its not a good refutation of an older world, because it's considerably less simple than the alternative.
- xupybd 9y agoLast thursdayism is an interesting concept that really challenges what you can determine as truth. Fundamentally all we can really do is come up with some good probability estimates that reality is as we think it is. Much like the matrix, if something is powerful enough to fool all of your senses, including your memory how do you even detect it? At the end of the day I don't think it matters very much. If our reality is an elaborate trick or not science allows us to predict and manipulate the physical world in ways that improve our existence. So it's worth perusing and using as a tool but there are somethings you'll never know for sure.
- Digory 9y agoShe was right to avoid it, even if she knew of it; Last Thursdayism doesn't answer the question, it just makes a (teensy-bit smug) point about epistemology. I think she does a good job of explaining why it's not scientifically possible to refute the idea, but offering a philosophical reason it's not satisfying. If the Almighty spawns worlds like Minecraft, and controls the sliders of time and physics, it's not clear how we Steves can ever figure out how our world was really spawned -- apart from direct intervention.
- jdhzzz 9y agoI'm reminded of the Steven Wright joke: "Someone broke into my apartment last night and replaced everything with exact duplicates." (https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/25236-last-night-somebody-broke-into-my-apartment-and-replaced-everything https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/25236-last-night-somebody-b...)