5 ms·
That's pretty much the article's conclusion: "If gold can be stored in Fort Knox-like bunkers for just 0.08% per year, there is little reason it should cost 15
by DennisP 9y ago
That's pretty much the article's conclusion:
"If gold can be stored in Fort Knox-like bunkers for just 0.08% per year, there is little reason it should cost 15 times more for bitcoin to be stored in similarly safe solutions. For now, though, it’s easy money for the custodians"
- EugeneAZ 9y agoBitCoin should be abandoned for other reasons: https://quant.stackexchange.com/questions/37036/why-do-american-government-not-create-a-crypto-dollar https://quant.stackexchange.com/questions/37036/why-do-ameri...
- pmarreck 9y agoFirst of all, it’s spelled “Bitcoin.” Second of all, there are many many cryptocurrencies at this point and they are all thriving/competing with one another across various measures. Since fiat is incapable of competing with anything except on relative value, fiat is doomed to fail.
- ben_w 9y agoFiat currency is competing very well in a category I really care about: “things which have existed for more than 15 years and which I can expect to still be around 15 years from now”. Sure, fiat currencies can hyperinflate with less than 15 years’ notice, but 15 years from now I expect most fiat currencies will be similarly valued and most cryptocurrencies to be as gone and forgotten as a geocities homepage.
- bonestamp2 9y ago@ben_w You think bitcoin will be gone in 15 years? It's already been around for ~10 years and it's just starting to reach mass awareness. If it survived ~10 years in relative obscurity, please explain how it's going to be be gone in 15 years now that it's well known?
- Scea91 9y agoIf your logic was sound, it would basically mean, by argument of induction, that anything that exists for some time will exist forever.
- soVeryTired 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect
- bonestamp2 9y agoI'm not suggesting it will last forever, I'm just saying it has already survived far longer than most people realize and therefore it's more resilient than people probably realize. That said, I think saying that bitcoin will be gone in 15 years is a bit like those people who thought the internet was just a fad. People who "get it" understand its usefulness and as long as there are enough of those people then it will remain.
- Scea91 9y agoIt depends... I have no doubts that cryptocurrency will be around in 15 years. But Bitcoin? I am not so sure.
- fullshark 9y agoIt’s failing to serve its primary use case as a currency. It’s now a speculative investment vehicle with exorbitant transaction fees. I struggle to see how that’s going to last.
- testvox 9y agoCouldn't you say the same thing about gold? It manages to survive.
- fullshark 9y agoGood point. I don't have a strong refutation of it. The main advantage of bitcoin over gold is that you can transfer it anywhere in the world to a potential anonymous recipient, which is why its main success stories so far have been in shady businesses. The current main advantage(s) of gold over bitcoin is it's still a lot easier for the average person worldwide to acquire and sell it, cultural tradition, there's been a few recessions where gold has at least held firm so it's trusted as a store of value. So if bitcoin's competition is Gold (and not your local currency) it would need to get a lot easier for laymen to acquire and sell (I'm not just talking bay area engs, I mean like the Venezuelan farmers, which is why bitcoin enthusiasts trump up any and all reports of the like). The segwit x2 fork was at least an attempt at that, and coinbase has done good work reducing frictions. The 2nd and 3rd will take years but could happen. I just feel like at this point all of bitcoins gains in the past year have been driven by wild speculators looking to make a quick buck, which tells me that when the recession hits they will dump their holding and btc will tank. This will make people less confident in btc as a store of value, and will consider it instead to be a wildly risky investment vehicle, which it is. At that point, it will default to its only proven use case thus far: anonymous worldwide financial transactions. disclaimer: I have a smallish % of my portfolio in both gold and btc.
- CydeWeys 9y agoCurious as to why you linked to your own question on StackExchange that was removed as off-topic and had no good answers?
- CydeWeys 9y agoA better article title then would not have been "Bitcoin is more expensive to keep safe than gold" (which is untrue). It would have been something like "High management fees in Bitcoin funds caused by lack of competition in newly emerging marketplace".
- samirillian 9y agoThe former is more to the point and accurate enough. I think all of us in tech knew what the article was going to be about before we read it. The problem is real though. We must reckon with the possibility that all these anarcho-capitalist dreams will go to hell once the necessary minimum overhead of handling crypto turns it into an _even more centralized_ medium of exchange.
- CydeWeys 9y agoNo, all of us in tech certainly did not deduce the correct meaning from the inaccurate article title and contents. If that were true my comment explaining the inaccuracy of the title would not be voted to #1.