6 ms·
This whole article is simplistic and inaccurate. They're making a straight-across comparison between two ETFs, one of which has high management fees and anothe
by CydeWeys 9y ago
This whole article is simplistic and inaccurate. They're making a straight-across comparison between two ETFs, one of which has high management fees and another of which has low management fees. The former happens to be a Bitcoin fund and the latter happens to be a gold fund.
Management fees vary widely across funds. They have everything to do with how money-grubbing the funds in question are and little to do with how expensive the assets actually are to secure. For example, you can pay >2% management fees on a really predatory S&P 500 index fund, the kind that John Hancock would sell you. Or you can pay .02% management fees on a top-level Vanguard fund tracking the same.
The only reason that the management fees on the Bitcoin funds is because they can be high since there's little competition so far, unlike with, say, S&P 500 index funds. It's not intrinsically expensive to store Bitcoin; far from it. It's far cheaper to store than gold, for all the obvious reasons that you don't have physical goods to secure.
- joosters 9y agoIt’s not a simple comparison between ETFs. The article specifically mentions Coinbase & their fees to store institutional customers’ bitcoins.
- CydeWeys 9y agoOK, so it's a comparison between two ETFs and then also some overpriced service from Coinbase that has similar characteristics to a mutual fund. The point still stands that there is as of yet very little competition in this space. Expect costs to come way down still.
- DennisP 9y agoThat's pretty much the article's conclusion: "If gold can be stored in Fort Knox-like bunkers for just 0.08% per year, there is little reason it should cost 15 times more for bitcoin to be stored in similarly safe solutions. For now, though, it’s easy money for the custodians"
- EugeneAZ 9y agoBitCoin should be abandoned for other reasons: https://quant.stackexchange.com/questions/37036/why-do-american-government-not-create-a-crypto-dollar https://quant.stackexchange.com/questions/37036/why-do-ameri...
- pmarreck 9y agoFirst of all, it’s spelled “Bitcoin.” Second of all, there are many many cryptocurrencies at this point and they are all thriving/competing with one another across various measures. Since fiat is incapable of competing with anything except on relative value, fiat is doomed to fail.
- ben_w 9y agoFiat currency is competing very well in a category I really care about: “things which have existed for more than 15 years and which I can expect to still be around 15 years from now”. Sure, fiat currencies can hyperinflate with less than 15 years’ notice, but 15 years from now I expect most fiat currencies will be similarly valued and most cryptocurrencies to be as gone and forgotten as a geocities homepage.
- bonestamp2 9y ago@ben_w You think bitcoin will be gone in 15 years? It's already been around for ~10 years and it's just starting to reach mass awareness. If it survived ~10 years in relative obscurity, please explain how it's going to be be gone in 15 years now that it's well known?
- Scea91 9y agoIf your logic was sound, it would basically mean, by argument of induction, that anything that exists for some time will exist forever.
- soVeryTired 9y ago
- matt4077 9y ago> since there's little competition so far, The competition is simply buying bitcoin, which isn't possible to do for the S&P 500 without investing a few million and constantly incurring fees to adjust to its shifting composition. The safe store is the only reason to buy this bitcoin ETF. Contrary to common myths, no investors, institutional or not, are constrained by regulations not to buy bitcoin directly.