3 ms·
I'd be curious to see if the courts will apply that same argument to other laws. For instance, will/should the courts eliminate all marriage benefits on the gr
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I'd be curious to see if the courts will apply that same argument to other laws.
For instance, will/should the courts eliminate all marriage benefits on the grounds that marital subsidies simply enshrine into law the notion that couples are superior to singles?
I'd also be curious to see if gay marriage supporters believe the courts made the correct decision, and if they would apply the same logic to other situations.
- gcheong 16y agoI'd be all for it - in the subsidy case anyway. And I'm married.
- kjksf 16y agoYou're using very simplistic and very wrong definition of what equality and discrimination is. For example, denying gay marriage discriminates against gays by denying a specific, identifiable group (gays) the right to marry that is given to everyone else. You're trying to claim that the same logic applies to e.g. laws against smoking which, in your naive interpretation, "discriminate" against smokers. The crucial and not so subtle difference is that law against smoking bans a behavior. It would be discrimination if we had laws that prohibits smokers to marry. So yes, the courts made the right decision I do want the courts to apply constitution in the future to abolish laws that violate mine and yours constitutional rights, equality being among them. Using your reasoning serial killers are a minority and laws against killing are discrimination.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoGays have the right to marry an opposite sex partner. They may not prefer this, but they have the right to do it. Thus, laws prohibiting same sex marriage discriminate against people who prefer same sex relationships. Similarly, renters have the right to get a mortgage subsidy by buying a home. They may not prefer it, but they have the right to do it. Thus, the mortgage subidy discriminates against people who prefer rentals. Should we therefore eliminate mortgage subsidies (or any number of other laws which favor one preference over another) subsidies based on the same logic?
- brandon 16y agoYou're conflating incentives with prohibition.
- ubernostrum 16y agoGays have the right to marry an opposite sex partner. They may not prefer this, but they have the right to do it. Thus, laws prohibiting same sex marriage discriminate against people who prefer same sex relationships. The right in question is not the generic right to marry someone, but rather to marry the person you want to marry (if that person will have you). And it's pretty settled at this point, since the definitive ruling was over 40 years ago; Loving v. Virginia struck down "everyone is equally free to marry someone of the same race as themselves" as discriminatory, and this case is now simply following the logic to strike down "everyone is equally free to marry someone of the opposite sex". As to your mortgage examples: marriage is and has long been held in US law to be a fundamental right. Renting a house, meanwhile, is not and has not been held to be such a fundamental right. And specifically in the case of laws which subsidize buying but not renting, such "discrimination" is allowable so long as it serves a compelling government interest. Proposition 8 was found not to serve any such interest; its sole purpose was to make law out of the religious beliefs of a particular group, and this is not something government legitimately can or should be doing.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoSo what is the compelling government interest in the case of, e.g., mortgage subsidies? The common justification I've heard is that home ownership is more likely than renting to generate positive externalities (e.g., homeowners are more likely to improve their communities). If increased probability of positive effects is sufficient rational basis for government acts, then it is very easy to come up with a rational basis for supporting straight marriage (but not gay marriage) based on positive externalities generated for children (e.g., straight couples are more likely to have children than gay couples). I came up with a rational basis given only a few minutes of thought. I'm now a bit surprised that the judge couldn't come up with such an obvious rationale. It's almost a if he was making a political decision rather than a legal one.