7 ms·
Are there any non-religious anti-gay-marriage arguments?
by tome 16y ago
Are there any non-religious anti-gay-marriage arguments?
- icarus_drowning 16y agoI haven't found many. A vast majority are "natural law" arguments, which I think are exceedingly weak. A better approach (from a conservative/libertarian side) is to just ask the question why government is defining marriage in the first place.
- eli 16y agoI'm totally with you there. I was really surprised that to get married in New York, the officiant pretty much has to be a judge, the town clerk, or a religious representative of an "official" religion with an established place of worship. Seems awfully unfair that atheists have fewer options than members of popular religions. What possible interest does the state have in vetting wedding officiants anyway?
- kjksf 16y agoIt is a legally binding ceremony so presumably you don't want that to be performed by just anybody. The idea that it's performed by someone who is licensed with the state and therefore officially accepts obligations that come with the right to marry other people seems reasonable to me. As to unfairness, maybe it would be unfair if it would be a trouble to find an officiant that is not a religious representative. The way I see it is that allowing religious representatives to perform a wedding ceremony as accepting societal reality that many people are religious and are more comfortable when wedding is performed by a religious representative but in no way it constitutes harm to non-religious people.
- dieterrams 16y agoI disagree that this is a "conservative/libertarian" question, but I agree that this is the better question to ask.
- chc 16y agoNone with much plausibility. There are a lot of secular anti-gay-marriage arguments put forth by religious people, but they are, without fail, far less rational than the religious arguments.
- rubashov 16y agoYou don't have to be religious to notice that exclusively vanilla heterosexual marriage has been common to all advanced societies. There are plenty of other models, but any culture that rose to power picked the one. It seems to me perfectly reasonable to assert that there will be unknown consequences to screwing with a system that has worked reasonably well. The last time marriage was tinkered with back in the 60s, no fault divorce and alimony as normal were tacked on. Infidelity was also decriminalized. I find it very easy to believe millions of broken homes and fatherless children were a direct consequence. The social consequences in lower socio-economic strata have been severe in a way that educated people generally don't comprehend. In conclusion, the conservative impulse to "conserve" social institutions that have a long track record of success is not fundamentally religious. It comes from the same place as environmentalism: don't go screwing with complex systems you probably don't fully understand.
- chc 16y agoWhy don't we apply to the same logic to every potential decision? Many Republican tax cuts have been unprecedented, so (il)logically conservatives should have opposed them. The iPhone is a disruptive technology will have "unknown consequences", so clearly it should be banned. The reason we don't apply this idea (except to things we already disagree with) is because it's completely illogical. Caution is one thing, but simply dismissing every idea that could have "unknown consequences" is a great way to make sure that literally nothing gets done. It is certainly not rational. It is, in a word, FUD.
- rubashov 16y agoCommunications technology is to fundamental social institutions and mores as apples are to oranges.
- defen 16y agoWe (culturally) have thousands of years of social and legal experience with heterosexual marriage. It's a very complex institution. Making a radical change to it may have unintended consequences.
- rortian 16y agoIf you mean how women were property and polygamy was cool, then sure it's thousands of years old. Marriage, as it exists today, is very different.
- lmkg 16y agoMy view is that allowing gay marriage is itself a consequence (probably unintended but still welcome) of other radical changes to the institution of marriage in Western society in the last century or two. Such changes include the view of a marriage as a personal unit rather than an economic one united by love rather than mutual economic and social benefit, and the general increase of women's rights and convergence of gender roles (for example, women can own property, and are not treated as being property themselves). The whole "soulmate" thing is a relatively recent idea, but is the current ideal for marriage. We have thousand of years of experience with a variety of institutions that share the name "marriage" but aren't very similar to each other. The current institution that bears that name has arguably only been around for about forty years, most recently being re-written by the sexual revolution and the increasing social acceptance of divorcing and re-marrying. Considering how flexible we as a society have become with respect to gender roles, this change is hardly "radical" by comparison.
- Legion 16y agoI really hope nobody tries to use the internet to promote that argument.
- jwhitlark 16y agoNo, actually we don't. Marriage throughout history had very different social and legal rules. Inheritance rules, power, authority, and care-taking of children are elements that have changed radically over the years. It would be accurate to say we've had experience with many different kinds of heterosexual marriage, but once you're lumping in, say, 16th century English marriage laws and customs with 21st century Californian ones, gender starts to look like a minor detail. We talk about "marriage" as if it's a simple, single idea, but historically, it's been applied to a wide range activities.
- shotmaker 16y ago1. The people voted and agreed on California's definition of marriage to be one man and one women. The people's vote should count not over turned by 1 gay judge.
- shotmaker 16y agodown vote all you want. If you want to know some of the reasons people oppose this look at this http://www.massresistance.org/ http://www.massresistance.org/ There is an agenda there...
- theBobMcCormick 16y agoI'm downvoting you because you're a bigoted shithead. That's all.
- cninja 16y agoThe main one I have heard is the slippery slope argument. If marriage is redefined as something other than a legal union between a man and a woman, where does definition of marriage come from? In other words, if someone is for gay marriage, then on what grounds can they forbid polygamous or incestuous relationships or incestuous relationships? Of course, this assumes that these other less popular alternative lifestyles should be forbidden as well.
- axod 16y agodon't forget bestiality. If a man and a consenting horse wish to get married who are we to deny them that right!
- MartinCron 16y ago-1 Horses can't give meaningful consent, silly. +1 You spelled bestiality correctly.
- axod 16y agoHow about a dolphin. They're pretty intelligent.
- OpieCunningham 16y agoHow about a man and a chicken? If you tell me a chicken can't give meaningful consent and therefore a man can't force a chicken into marriage, then what right do we have to eat them? Seriously, I'm not joking. It is a valid point when arguing against gay marriage to point to the "slippery slope" of bestiality. But it is also a valid point to state that there's really no good reason to make marrying a chicken illegal. Fundamentally, I believe most opposition to gay marriage is based upon disgust. And I'm confident the same is true for marrying a chicken. Disgust is hardly an adequate justification.
- brianwillis 16y agoMarriage has evolved over time. If it didn't, then it probably wouldn't be around any more. Examples: -Inter-racial marriage was once illegal in the US. Now it's not. -Marriage was used as a tool to forge alliances between royal families in Europe. Now it's not. -In Europe, it was once common for a bride's family to pay a dowry as a part of the marriage agreement. Now it's not. My point is that elements of our collective cultures evolve all the time. The concept of marriage exists to serve culture that it's a part of, not the other way around.
- jberryman 16y agoWell I can see the idea of a gay couple raising a child sounding like a strange and dangerous idea to someone who hasn't been exposed to it, religious or not. For example: couldn't this lead to children being confused about their own sexual identity? But one of the reasons for this ruling was that it was shown in the court-room that children do as well when raised by a same-sex couple as by a heterosexual one. It then follows that recognizing those couples would be even better for those families.
- MartinCron 16y agoWe live in a hetero-normative society. Hetero couples are everywhere in media and popular culture. I'm pretty sure that kids being raised by same-sex parents can see that different people have different sexual orientations and work that out. I'm sure it's harder for young gay people to have straight parents than for young straight people to have gay parents, yet nobody ever worries about that scenario.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI'm against gay marriage and my reasons are completely non-religious. Currently, marriage consists of a default package of contractual rights given from one partner to another (e.g. default will, medical proxy) and I have no problem extending this to gays. In fact, this part of marriage can already be pieced together with a few legal documents. Marriage also consists of laws which force single people to subsidize married couples, for instance the non-working spouse of a worker gets SS benefits that neither spouse paid for. Gay marriage supporters are in the unique position of thinking about this issue and recognizing the unfairness of it. But rather than advocating for fairness, they simply want to be allowed to join the favored class. I'll draw an analogy to the civil rights: think of an Asian American in 1960 saying "I'm not against Jim Crow, I just want Asians to be classified as White rather than Colored." As a single person, I'm in the same boat as gay couples. Gay marriage supporters want to throw me overboard in order to join the favored group, forcing me to subsidize a slightly larger group of people. Why should I do anything but oppose that? Marriage fairness (i.e., no subsidies), I'll get behind. Gay marriage, no. [edit: I thought my last line was clear enough, but from the responses it apparently was not. I favor ending marriage, or at least ending the subsidies for it. I also favor ending the penalties for it, which apply in certain circumstances.]
- madair 16y agoRegarding the social security benefits...in actuality married people in the U.S. pay what's euphemistically called the Marriage Tax, because the rules as codified actually require married people to pay more than if they filed separately. Regarding the rest of your arguments, I suppose they work assuming an extremely weak social contract. Or at least, in my opinion it would require a very weak one. It's hard question to test in relation to marriage since marriage is a legally sanctioned relationship in all countries, but i am most certainly not well read on this topic.
- kenjackson 16y agoThat's a good point, regarding SS. See: http://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/issuepapers/ip2003-01.html http://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/issuepapers/ip2003-01.html
- mynameishere 16y agoThe practical purpose of marriage is to give protections to the woman who bears a greater liability in childbearing. This doesn't apply to gay "marriage", except in contrived cases. I'm actually yet to hear an argument in the favor of gay marriage that doesn't do one of the following: 1. Torture the definition of "equal". As if a law specifically designed to cover a specific relationship between a "man and a woman" is somehow invalid, whereas laws that cover specific relationships between a "lawyer and client" or "doctor and patient" or "parent and child" or "employer and employee" or "clergyman and worshipper" or 1000s and 1000s of others are never considered unconstitution. 2. Appeal to emotion. Ie, domestic partners can't automatically visit each other in the hospital when one is incapacitated, etc.
- MartinCron 16y agoThe practical purpose of marriage is to give protections to the woman who bears a greater liability in childbearing. That is maybe one practical purpose of marriage, but it's not the legal basis, and there's a lot more to it from a societal perspective. I think the lawyer/client and doctor/patient argument is interesting, but feels a little hollow, because people are in a position to choose to become doctors, lawyers, clients, and patients freely. There is no inherent discrimination in those relationships. Would you expect a special class of legal relationships between a black man and a white woman? I wouldn't.
- GiraffeNecktie 16y agoI can't believe you're being voted down. The idea that marriage is solely for the purpose of childbearing is patently absurd. Marriage is a lifelong partnership with a myriad of benefits and responsibilities, some of which are recognized and codified by the state. The state also recognizes that marriage provides enormous good to society, not only child care, but also care of the aging, the unemployed and the infirm. It is also a partnership that is deeper, longer lasting and more important to society than that between any lawyer/barber/personal trainer and client.
- axod 16y agoIf I could upvote this 100 times, I would. Well put.
- madair 16y agoThere are rational arguments, mostly coming from evolutionary psychology and similar domains. The arguments tend to fall apart under rational scrutiny when used to shape human behavior rather than simply explain it. A couple recent articles by Robin Hanson about polygamy cover similar terrain in interesting ways. The arguments, particularly in the second article, more or less break it down to the problems of utilitarianism. http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/07/polygamy-hypocrisy.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/07/polygamy-hypocrisy.htm... http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/07/hypergamy-and-polygamy.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/07/hypergamy-and-polygamy...
- axod 16y agoI'm against gay marriage for non-religious reasons. Civil partnerships fine, have the same rights and freedoms as married couples, just call it a civil partnership instead. But IMHO this isn't hacker news and will pretty quickly get nasty. edit: Also for same reasons as http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1576226 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1576226
- kjksf 16y agoFrom what you wrote you're against gay marriage for no reason at all. You stated a preference for how things should be, not a reason for that preference. And you seem strangely preoccupied with semantics. If marriage and civil partnership meant the same thing, what would be the point of having a distinction?
- axod 16y agoI think arguing that it must be called 'marriage' is petty. Redefining that word and stretching it to encompass more things is just stupid and less useful. Sure, give them the same rights if you like, but just call it a 'civil partnership'. If it was just about the rights, then I'd expect people to be happy with that. But it seems to be more about forcing an opinion onto others, which I disagree with.
- thingie 16y agoSo instead of just using the word marriage for something that IS a marriage, we have to invent another term that doesn't mean anything else than marriage, but of two people who are of the same sex. Just because we have to. And that isn't petty.
- axod 16y agoIt may be a 'marriage' as you like to define the word, but that doesn't magically make it so. Shall we use 'marriage' to also cover the union of a man to a horse? man to a table? man to a child? They have civil rights too!
- Jun8 16y agoFirst of all, religious arguments against or for anything should be irrelevant in civil arguments, it's a question of human rights. For example, the recent discussions on wearing burqas does center on whether their use is religiously dictated or not but rather the trade-offs of the rights between wearers and society at large. This trade-off point is my main counter argument. Specifically, this means that gay marriage can have drawbacks for the society, e.g. (i) as others point out, the same logic (consenting adults, personal rights, etc.) can be used to argue for polygamy and other forms of relationships that are outside current society's norms; (ii) it may have adverse affects on the couples children.
- kjksf 16y agoYou're missing the main point: it's about discrimination. A law that would forbid wearing a burqa as a societal trade-off would apply to everyone equally hence it wouldn't be discrimination. Even though it would affect the most people of a certain religion, it would also apply to secular burqa wearers. The main issue with a law that forbids gays to marry, and the reason it's discrimination, is that it denies them a right that everyone else has. Whether polygamy is legal or not has nothing to do with it. The law forbids a specific behavior (polygamy) and it applies to everyone so is not discriminatory. Constitutionally, it's in the same league as a law that forbids smoking in public places or, for that matter, killing people. So you're left with only one potential argument: that gay marriage causes specific, societal harm that is not caused by non-gay marriage. I would like to see a solid proof of that. "It may have" is not one.