9 ms·
The whole phenomenon of sugar and fructose being added to virtually everything is beyond comprehension. There are so many people, fat and slim, saying they don'
by qwerty456127 9y ago
The whole phenomenon of sugar and fructose being added to virtually everything is beyond comprehension. There are so many people, fat and slim, saying they don't want to be fat, yet eating foods with added sugar every day. Why not just replace all the added sugar with erythritol, for example? The whole situation with sugar reminds me of the situation with opium in early 19th century China
- abawany 9y agoErythritol can cause digestive discomfort for some [1], which is why I suspect it isn't prevalent. It was an eye opener to me how many packaged goods have sugar (HFCS) added, when intuitively it seems there was no good reason for any added sweet flavor to be present. By (mostly) assiduously reading the ingredients (the only source of truth, which is why it is often in the smallest print), I am often able to avoid purchasing rubbish that has no business driving me ever faster to a painful death. There are some goods that are proudly sugar free (on the marketing speak and in the ingredients list) and I make sure to buy these when possible. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erythritol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erythritol
- Retric 9y agoThe shocking thing is if you completely drop sugar from your diet you still notice plenty of sweet things. The only changes is the threshold before you consider something sweet. IMO, we need to have a big fat "This is Candy!" label on anything that's got more than 1 gram of sugar/hfcs/whatever per serving. Yes, that includes Apple Juice and other 'hidden' sweeteners.
- webkike 9y agoIt's crazy, 20 grams of sugar is pretty much the standard and I wouldn't be able to stand that much sugar in a week!
- mpd 9y agoEven peanuts become candy under your definition.
- Retric 9y agoPeanuts are candy. Just look at a snickers/payday/Mr. Goodbar or 50+ others that add peanuts with say caramel/chocolate/etc. They can be fine as part of a larger dish, but really don't make a heathy snack on their own.
- mpd 9y agoI'm not sure why you brought chocolate and caramel into the picture, but I'm going to stick with my opinion that peanuts are not candy. I think you're attempting to redefine a word to fit your narrative, and I'm not having it.
- Retric 9y agoI am not redefining Candy, I am using non food definition of candy to make a point. "Something that is pleasing or pleasurable, usually in a superficial way" Peanuts are frequently used as part of a wide range of sweets for texture. But, they are also sweet enough to not be out of place and in no way make them heathy by proxy. Similarly, eating a full serving of penuts regularly is generally a bad idea.
- leakyabs 9y ago> Similarly, eating a full serving of peanuts regularly is generally a bad idea. Why? Nuts are full of healthy fats and a single serving has a decent amount of calories. With the nutrition nuts have, they make a great snack to propel you through part of the day. If I start to dip around 2:00/3:00 PM and get hungry, one of my go-tos is a single serving of mixed nuts (although I also just toasted some walnuts for the same purpose). It keeps me full until dinner. I don’t understand why you hate nuts so much. I mean, obviously you should enjoy them in moderation, but that’s true for a lot of foods.
- 9y ago
- KozmoNau7 9y agoI agree on this. Added sugar to me means candy or cake, and while I like candy and cake, they are definitely a "small portions, very infrequently" type thing.
- leakyabs 9y agoI cut out almost all processed, added sugar a few weeks ago (soda, energy drinks, and sweet coffee drinks (e.g. mochas) were my biggest vice) and the difference is amazing. I have consistent energy throughout the day. My mood has improved, I think (could be unrelated). I actually have normal feelings of hunger at normal times. If I need something sweet, I have some 72% dark chocolate squares, each with 3 g of sugar, that I eat after dinner with some mint tea. Helps the cravings immensely. I’ll also add a serving of agave nectar to yogurt. But what I’ve noticed is that I need less and less sweetener over time. I made a smoothie with yogurt, milk, and some non-sugar-heavy fruit and it was sweet enough on its own. I wasn’t expecting that.
- epmaybe 9y agoI'd imagine it's because erythritol isn't absorbed, so it just sits there in your gut drawing water out osmotically. That will make you feel really uncomfortable really quickly.
- simcop2387 9y agoAt least with erythritol some people have bad reactions to it. Nothing life threatening as far as I know, but it can give me very bad gas, and for one other person I know it's like eating Olestra Chips[1]. That said there are other sweeteners that don't seem to have that effect but they don't seem to behave quite as closely to sugar in cooking as erythritol does. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olestra#Side_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olestra#Side_effects
- didgeoridoo 9y agoMost sugar substitutes are indigestible by humans, but readily metabolized by gut bacteria. This can result in a "Satan's Diarrhea Hatebears" scenario [0], especially when suddenly consumed in large amounts. [0]: https://www.amazon.com/ss/customer-reviews/B00DE4GWWY https://www.amazon.com/ss/customer-reviews/B00DE4GWWY
- pmoriarty 9y agoTagatose has become my go-to sugar substitute. It is indistinguishable from sugar for me. There's an interesting article in Wired about its discovery and properties here: https://www.wired.com/2003/11/newsugar/ https://www.wired.com/2003/11/newsugar/
- gtrubetskoy 9y agoBecause price per pound: Erythritol: $20 Sugar: $0.44 Source: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:mhVolOSp6k8J:https://sweetenerusers.org/The%2520True%2520Story%2520About%2520US%2520Sugar%2520Prices.pdf+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:mhVolO... [Google cache, the original PDF is 404 Not Found] Edit: looks like one can find erythritol for as little as $15, which is still 34 times more than sugar.
- donjoe 9y agoSwitch to stevia instead?
- hans_mueller 9y agono, switch to xylitol.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoNo. Train yourself to avoid sweeteners all together :)
- hans_mueller 9y agoeven better
- leadingthenet 9y agoWell sure, now. But once the forces of scale take over it could potentially become cheaper than sugar.
- pizza234 9y ago> Doses over 50 grams (1.8 oz) can cause severe diarrhea, plus a significant increase in nausea and stomach rumbling. ... and that's "just" 50 grams.
- 9y ago
- jacek 9y agoThere's an interesting book on this topic that discusses both how it happened and what that does to our brains and bodies - "The Hacking of the American Mind" by Robert Lustig [1]. The book also is about other ways our brain is affected by a substance or behavior, but mostly about sugar. I highly recommend it. [1] https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/531013/the-hacking-of-the-american-mind-by-robert-h-lustig-md-msl/9781101982587 https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/531013/the-hacking-...
- nlperguiy 9y agoRobert Lustig is a quack although. Many of the things he said in his famous online talk are outright lie. He gave an example of Japanese and their healthiness, yet they eat way more fructose than the USA citizen he cites. There's a whole other bunch of misinformation in his speech and his studies are filled with flawed design (no control group, p hacking etc.).
- jacek 9y agoI have not heard about it. Could you give me a link and information on those lies please?
- nlperguiy 9y agoArticle below has more than 50 references that describe the argument well. http://anthonycolpo.com/sweet-stupidity-part-2-the-bitter-truth-about-robert-lustigs-anti-sugar-claims/ http://anthonycolpo.com/sweet-stupidity-part-2-the-bitter-tr... You can check the sources yourself too. Although, I believe Lustig changed the narrative and is currently promoting diets rich in starch (which means high volume - low calories) and most of his studies produce a caloric deficit (while he denies it despite the fact that less calories are metabolized due to digestion of starch). I believe he also likes referencing fructose extract consumption studies that have no direct mapping to a real diet. For example, consumping 100g of fructose through fruit won't do you any harm.
- s4vi0r 9y agoWhy is it that he's so popular on HN? Did I miss a recent front page post or something? I swear every time I'm in a nutrition related thread I see somebody mention his name or a book he wrote or talk he did. I used to be pretty deep into weightlifting and nutrition, and I don't know that I ever once ran into his name in all my reading, and I spent a stupid amount of time reading about macro + micro nutrients.
- ams6110 9y agoThe reason is that in the 1970s and 80s people started freaking out about fat. Everyone from the FDA to USDA to family doctor was telling people fat was bad. So food producers started making fat-free versions of everything. Only problem is it tasted like shit. So what did they do? They added sugar. So now you have sugar added to everything from salad dressing to pasta sauce to bread and muffins. The latter probably had some all along but the fat free varieties had a lot more. Edit: I'll add that saturated fat was considered especially evil, which begat trans-fats substituted everywhere. Turned out they were even worse. Bottom line, eat minimally processed meats and plants and you can stop worrying about it.
- tinha 9y agoThere's a documentary on Netflix about this, I think it's called Sugar x Fat.
- Fnoord 9y agoThere's 2 good documentaries I remember about the subject (though there's likely many more): That Sugar Film [1] and Fed Up [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/That_Sugar_Film https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/That_Sugar_Film [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fed_Up_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fed_Up_(film)
- perseusprime11 9y ago+1 to Fed Up.
- gukov 9y agoThat Sugar Film is good and fun.
- pgsandstrom 9y agoI dont know about Fed Up, but at the very least That Suger Film is very dishonest and not good science. Unfortunately the only good source I have is in swedish, but here it is: https://traningslara.se/hur-du-gor-en-storsaljande-men-usel-dokumentar-om-kost/ https://traningslara.se/hur-du-gor-en-storsaljande-men-usel-...
- raverbashing 9y agoWell, this is the US, and on top of that, it's most often not sugar but hfcs.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoYears back there was an NYT Sunday Mag (op ed) piece that blamed increae in waistlines - via the increase usage of HFCS - on farm subsidies from corn. My editorial: Thanks Uncle Sam.
- CodeWriter23 9y ago> The whole phenomenon of sugar and fructose being added to virtually everything is beyond comprehension. It may be absurd, ridiculous, perhaps even criminal or genocidal, but it is certainly within the realm of comprehension: https://mobile.nytimes.com/2013/02/24/magazine/the-extraordinary-science-of-junk-food.html https://mobile.nytimes.com/2013/02/24/magazine/the-extraordi...
- KozmoNau7 9y agoThat article is a damn good read, and scary as hell.
- jlarocco 9y agoWhy replace it with anything? Sugar and high fructose corn syrup get added to a ton of foods that don't need extra sweetening. Some varieties of Vlasic dill pickles, for example, have HFCS added. It's insane. For the past few months I've been trying to avoid added sugar in everything except for some baked goods (like zuchini bread or birthday cake). It took a couple weeks to get used to, but now I prefer food without it and when I try something with added sweetener it tastes too sweet.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoThe fact that people even consider adding sugar to ordinary food is mind-boggling to me. Sure, adding a small pinch to pasta sauce as a seasoning is reasonable, in quantities less than you would usually add salt. But seriously dumping sugar in food, so it actually tastes noticeably sweet? That's just insane.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoThat comparison is a great one. Sugar is addictive as well. Processed food isn't engineered and manufacturered to benefit the consumer. It's designed to increase consumption. What's most troubling is, it seems, plenty of people can't connect the dots between what they consume and their health. It's disheartening that we need a law that says, "You can't look down and see your penis when you pee...watch what you eat." Where do ppl think all that extra weight comes from, sunshine?
- KozmoNau7 9y agoAdded sugar is the insidious enemy. Forget the anti-grain alarmism and so on, if we can just cut the added sugar from our diets, that's a 80-90% solution that's actually achievable, compared to the insanity of trying to completely cut out all carbs. We're hard-wired to be attracted to sweet and fatty foods, because those were important back when food was scarce and a calorie surplus was basically unheard of. Now that food is abundant (at least in the developed world) that same hard-wired attraction is a burden that we need to consciously challenge every day. I'm a big fan of the No S Diet (http://nosdiet.com/ http://nosdiet.com/ - no affiliation) because it's straight-forward, easy to adhere to and has worked for me. It also doesn't try to sell you anything, it just asks you to cut out added sugars, limit your meals to single servings and to not eat between meals.
- kwhitefoot 9y ago> Why not just replace all the added sugar with erythritol, for example? Why not just stop sweetening things. When I took my family to the US for three months the children were astonished at how sweet everything was. You can tell that something is wrong when even children complain that things are too sweet to eat.