4 ms·
It's been really interesting to see the interplay between State Attorneys General and the federal executive branch over the past decade. I don't know enough leg
by epistasis 9y ago
It's been really interesting to see the interplay between State Attorneys General and the federal executive branch over the past decade. I don't know enough legal history to know if this contention is new or has always happened. But the contrast between what happened with regulation of carbon and coal is fairly striking. The federal judicial brach said that it had to be regulated in order to meet the laws that the legislative branch had passed, executive branch followed through with regulations based on science and input from stakes holders. We ended up with regulations on coal plants that are weaker than Chinese restrictions on their own plants. State AGs revolted, to little effect.
In the last year, regulatory decisions at the FCC, EPA, and DOE are being made by fiat, without any of the typical study and justification that typically goes into them. In particular, DOE suggestions to FERC have been denounced by nearly everybody in the energy industry, by nearly every interested outsider, and in a bipartisan fashion from lots of prior FERC commissioners. The general whims of a single person are taking precedence over having market principles, or really any other principle at all. The only parties in favor of the regulations at all are those who directly benefit by guaranteed payments, and they only justify their favor of the regulations through a massive and legally questionable expansion of regulatory power of the regulatory agency, something that these particular partisans are usually against.
With the FCC, we see something similar, an impulse to make regulations without much reasoning behind those regulations except that they favor a small group.
This type of regulation, where particular parties are favored, rather than particular principles, is madness.
- nerdponx 9y agoCan states regulate ISP activity within their states? Could the New York state legislature pass a law stating that ISPs who offer services in New York must provide net-neutral services?
- bognition 9y agoThey could try but the FCC would almost certainly contest that the states do not have the right to pass such laws. Additionally there is nothing stopping the FCC from passing rules forbidding states from regulating net neutrality.
- dawnerd 9y agoStates could make life really hard for the companies. Impose taxes on those that are not neutral, make permitting difficult and even start up state run internet.
- briantakita 9y agoThat's the idea. Get the Federal government out of the business of regulating the internet & open it up to competition. The cartel practices of the ISP oligopoly is a separate issue. They bought the state legislatures. The people of each state that is under the influence of the ISP cartels should demand an open internet for their state.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoStates should try and let the FCC slog through the courts to stop it.
- Spivak 9y agoI mean they might be able to but why do you think the states are going to be so opposed to this?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoBecause they’re more accountable to their constituents than the FCC.
- otp124 9y agoCould you explain how the FCC has superiority here? Doesn’t the constitution allow states to set local laws for things that aren’t expressly dictated in the constitution? Please forgive my limited legal knowledge.
- sdenton4 9y agoThe Constitution gives the federal government the ability to regulate interstate commerce, which, effectively, means almost everything. Taxing the hell out of non neutral ISPs at the state level may be viable, though? IANAL... It may be a case where a successful state level action in (say) New York and California covers enough people that national ISPs won't want to build a whole second system for all the other states; this is how many California environmental protection laws become de facto national.
- dsl 9y agoThe FCC can add what is called a "preemption clause" that effectively overrules states. The same sort of thing is used to prevent every city you drive though for having different insurance requirements for example. http://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=1575 http://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=1575
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoYes, but they'll be blocked. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/11/comcast-asks-the-fcc-to-prohibit-states-from-enforcing-net-neutrality/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/11/comcast-asks-the... https://www.theverge.com/2017/11/22/16691344/fcc-preempt-block-state-local-net-neutrality-laws https://www.theverge.com/2017/11/22/16691344/fcc-preempt-blo...
- theandrewbailey 9y agoMaybe, and the states have a leg to stand on. Along with net neutrality, the FCC voted to overturn laws that limit municipal broadband. The states challenged the FCC, and the states won. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/08/in-blow-to-muni-broadband-fcc-loses-bid-to-overturn-state-laws/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/08/in-blow-to-muni-...
- npsimons 9y ago> This type of regulation, where particular parties are favored, rather than particular principles, is madness. It's plutocracy (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutocracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutocracy), plain and simple. Some have been pointing out things like this and calling it plutocracy for a long time, but until now it wasn't so blatantly obvious.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- throwaway7645 9y agoThe stuff with FERC & DOE is a little more complex. Nobody likes coal, and the north American electricity market mechanisms have had prices for years that are too low for coal to turn a profit. Great, the market has spoken you say? The only problem is it presents a major issue for national security if all you have is natural gas and some renewable. What happens if the pipelines freeze? Grid resiliency means having a diverse enough fuel mix to still be ok if we have certain disasters. One day we'll hopefully have very large and affordable batteries and a lot more renewables, but despite huge growth in this sector, most demand is still sourced from unclean fossil fuels today. Nobody (except Perry) is really expecting or wanting coal to make a comeback. They're just trying to provide a market mechanism to compensate power companies to keep just enough coal online so we can better hedge against blackouts.