4 ms·
Given the scale at which demonetization seems to be occurring, one would expect the evidence to be obvious: videos espousing an explicit ideological point of vi
by krapp 9y ago
Given the scale at which demonetization seems to be occurring, one would expect the evidence to be obvious: videos espousing an explicit ideological point of view would be demonetized, and those expressing the opposite ideology, or none at all, would not.
If you read about and watch content related to the issue you'll likely fail to notice such a pattern. If demonetization were merely about suppressing right-wing content, then why would Google also demonetize let's players, reviewers, vloggers like Hank Green (who would doubtless be considered "left wing"), anime channels, commercial and apolitical channels as well? The proof appears to be disproved by contradiction.
It is possible for ideology to affect demonetization, but not in the obvious sense that right-wingers mean (that of Google, being a "liberal" company, simply choosing to harass them.) The motives of advertisers are what is important here, and Google's desperation to make an unprofitable platform profitable and competitive.
This is hardly the first time a change in Youtube's algorithm has had major consequences for types of content and revenue - see Ross' video on the future of animation on Youtube[0] for instance... did Google have a political agenda against animated content on Youtube? No, and neither is it likely that Google's current monetization scheme is intended to suppress a particular kind of content as much as any content advertisers might consider unfriendly, which just happens to include content intended to be provocative, anti-establishment or controversial as a set.
Is it possible? Sure. Is it likely? No, at least not as a primary motivating factor. Is there evidence for it? Nothing objective, in my opinion. I would suggest that you do your own research and make up your own mind.
[0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gi6FcI2wFrw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gi6FcI2wFrw